• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Managers who rely only on pay to motivate their employees to higher levels of job performance will always be disappointed n the results". Critically evaluate this statement.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Managers who rely only on pay to motivate their employees to higher levels of job performance will always be disappointed n the results". Critically evaluate this statement. Pay is one thing that causes many discrepancies within the work environment. Most employees continue to try and further themselves in work usually with the hope of better pay; fringe benefits i.e. company cars, pensions and so on. There are however, those who show "highly motivated behaviour where economic rewards are low."1 This citation agrees with the above statement, however, throughout this essay I will sum up where pay can be seen as a good motivator and where extrinsic benefits fail. Content theorists such as Maslow and Herzberg look at needs and what gives people the drive to work. A similar theme arises in the different theories which on face value seem opposing they all look at ones desire to work in order to satisfy their needs. To start, Maslow believed there is a hierarchy as to what makes people work. The first being for survival. ...read more.

Middle

Hygiene factors are the issues surrounding an employee whilst they work that "help avoid dissatisfaction with work."5 These include status, work conditions and quality of personnel management. What sets Herzberg apart from Maslow is the fact that he looks at how job design can be a potentially motivating factor. Herzberg would suggest that what truly motivates is intrinsic factors such as achievement rather than pay. This goes towards explaining why some managers who rely on pay may be disappointed - it's not what makes a job enjoyable. Despite these two theorists agreeing with the above statement Taylor is one content theorist more inclined to disagree. He favoured using incentive wage plans and was seen to continually achieve consistently good results. However, in the article Why Incentive Plans Cannot Work by Alfie Kohn he goes into innumerable detail about the disadvantage of using payment as a motivator. He explains that rewards can work, they will motivate people to strive for the reward. Employees will become accustomed to working for the sole reason of a reward as a teleological result. ...read more.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the essay has shown circumstances where pay works as a motivator and where it fails. The overwhelming feeling is that pay is fine as a short term motivator but when it is used continually workers can become reliant and it can put pressure on employee relations as well as encouraging them to work purely for economic reward. Managers will not always be disappointed with results as explained but there are other ways to motivate which have shown to produce continually good results such as job enrichment and making employees feel as though they genuinely matter. In my opinion, managers who use pay incentives can achieve good results but from reading the articles as evidence my advice would be to use them sparingly. WORD COUNT: 1054 words 1 Organisational Behaviour - compiled by A. Beauregard page 201 2 Organisational Behaviour - compiled by A. Beauregard page 204 3 This study "examined the changes in needs of a group of people." OB - A. Beauregard page 205 4 Organisational Behaviour - compiled by A. Beauregard page 205 5 Organisational Behaviour - compiled by A. Beauregard page 206 6 Harvard Business Review ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE People in Business section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE People in Business essays

  1. A study of Asda's personnel performance indicators.

    - Belief leave - all colleagues are offered the opportunity to take a total of two days unpaid leave (in additional to statutory and public holidays) at any time throughout the year to celebrate religious festivals. This gives department mangers notice with which they can cover shifts and therefore cuts

  2. "Managers should do everything they can to enhance job satisfaction of their employees? Do ...

    reviewed a large body of evidence generally unsupportive of the proposition that there is any appreciable relationship between the variables, let alone the idea that 'job satisfaction causes performance.' (McGee and Cavender, 1984) came to much the same conclusion as the earlier assessments, suggesting that high productivity and worker satisfaction

  1. METHODS FOR MOTIVATING EMPLOYEES

    Long chains also make feedback more difficult and more expensive. We should arrange the necessary tasks so we strike a balance between: Simple jobs which are demotivating V Complex jobs which are impossible for one person to do well. And between: A long chain of people with too many links

  2. Business at Work - ASDA

    in which it competes in: - 'To be Britain's best value retailer, exceeding local customer needs...Always.' The main mission and purpose behind Asda is 'to make goods and services more affordable for everyone'. Asda have stated that their purpose shows their determined commitment towards everyday low prices without the need to compromise on quality.

  1. Improving Motivation and Job Satisfaction at the Laredo Federal Credit Union

    Only 33.3 percent of the respondents are satisfied with the organization's compensation program. A 33.3 percent disagree that pay raises are consistent with the job evaluations versus a 40 percent that agrees that pay raises are consistent with the job evaluations.

  2. TNT case study

    They have always believed that their success can be attributed to its people and culture and that through continuous commitment to ongoing training and measurement of its effectiveness, they can continue to be the brand leader in the industry. TNT supports continuous development of all staff through investment in training, social programmes and working environment.

  1. Organisations and Behaviour

    They emphasised the needs of wider social needs of individuals and gave recognition to social organisations. The importance of groups and values was emphasised which influenced their individual behaviour at work. All of this led to continued attention being paid to matters such as job satisfaction, group dynamics, participation, leadership and motivation.

  2. Does performance related pay motivate or de-motivate employees?

    (Accel Motivation theory, 2000) Problems of poor training for managers and inadequate communication with staff have had a negative impact on staff morale. Studies of NHS managers in 1997 and 1998 showed that performance-related pay did not contribute to improve performance but did cause jealousies between staff and undermine moral.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work