• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Creon’s Leadership Compared to Machiavelli’s Ideas

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Creon's Leadership Compared to Machiavelli's Ideas Sophocles's Antigone of Ancient Greece is a tale for all times. The actions and relationships between characters can be seen in any society. In particular, the leadership and actions taken by Creon in the play can be compared to the leadership traits that Nicolo Machiavelli suggests a leader should follow in his 16th century work The Prince. Machiavelli provides twenty six chapters on how leaders should act in specific scenarios. Princes and rulers need to maintain a subtle balance between love, fear, hatred, liberalism and meanness, all in addition to keeping possession of a newly obtained rule. Creon has obtained rule of Thebes through unique means. Etocles and Polyneices were to rotate rule between themselves, but since Etocles refused to allow Polyneices his time to rule, the two quarreled with armies, and killed each other, leaving Creon their uncle as the next hereditary male in line for the throne. (Sophocles 2) These deaths are bad ways to commence a rule. Creon needed to find a means to make the public view of him a positive one as he took leadership. ...read more.

Middle

He follows these rules for success as a monarch, yet he still fails in his doings. Fate has continued to curse his family name with ill providence and atrocities. Machiavelli warns of having to defend against and suppress conspirators. Antigone, in this case, could be classified as a conspirator. She was caught in the act, and didn't have any regrets about burying her brother. Machiavelli says that "The conspirators face nothing but fear, mutual distrust, and the prospect of punishment, so they loose heart" (57). This is the complete opposite for Antigone. She was only strengthened in her resolve to bury Polyneices as Creon continued his punishments for her, and this made her a martyr and backfired on Creon's leadership. Machiavelli's ideas failed again for Creon as he loses the love of his family and his people. Creon slowly looses the respect and love of his people and his family during his process of punishing Antigone. Haemon puts it perfectly when he says that "she is not going to die while I am near her. ...read more.

Conclusion

Creon is described as 'slither[ing] into wickedness sometimes' (Sophocles 16) by the Chorus. He seemed to have the original intent to aid his people, but later on when Antigone rebelled against him, he was irked that a lowly woman would try to question his authority, especially when he just attained power. He becomes crazed in his desire to stop her mini-rebellion against his influence, and it is at this point that his meanness is transformed into a two sided hatred: Creon towards Antigone's rebellious nature, and his people towards his suppression of a helpless girl trying to honor her family. When comparing Creon's leadership flaws to Machiavelli's ideals for a perfect rule, one can see how some of then work and some of them fail. Part of this is due to Creon's greed and open desire to have things his way. Through the suppression of Antigone's burial of her brother Creon creates an image for himself of a cruel leader, which in turns causes his people and family to turn against him and ruin his kingdom. This is in part caused by the Oedipus curse upon his family, which is his fate. But, Creon is hated as well as feared, which is the opposite of what Machiavelli suggests. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Classics essays

  1. 'Both Antigone and Creon deserve our sympathy'. Discuss.

    Haemon acts as a kind of mediator between the king and the people of Thebes. He knows that there will be public outrage on the death of Antigone, who is already being hailed as a heroine and martyr. However, despite the backing of the chorus leader, who agrees that Haemon

  2. The Roman Army: Why were the Romans able to conquer and maintain such a ...

    What he actually received may have been only a quarter or fifth of his gross pay. Here is part of a Roman soldier's pay account. It is dated 81 AD (before the wage increase)

  1. Science case study

    * Smokers have more colds and flu than non-smokers and find it harder to recover from minor illnesses. * Smoking can cause impotence in men, while women who smoke are less fertile than non-smokers. * People who smoke tend to have facial wrinkles appearing much earlier and, in general, look older than non-smokers of the same age.

  2. Medea - Euripides lived during the Golden Age of Athens, the city where he ...

    Announcing a full reconciliation with her husband, she concedes each of the arguments that Jason made in their last discussion and releases the two boys into his embrace. Fully aware of Medea's expressed intentions, the chorus nevertheless hopes that she has actually changed her mind and decided to curb her desire for revenge.

  1. Throughout the play 'Antigone' there is a constant emphasis on the use and abuse ...

    Creon's view of it is wrong. Creon offends the concept of human decency itself, he completely violates a recognised fitness. Sophocles was trying to make the readers think that way also, by coming to the conclusion that what Antigone did was right and what Creon did was wrong, according to the laws of the immortals.

  2. Who made the greatest contribution to the Athenian Constitution?

    which nearly fully prevented any sort of corruption or bribery from taking place, in that judges were selected randomly from a pool of hundreds, and only random votes were counted. Also, Peisistratos created a system where the extremely rich had to use vast amounts of money for the good of society, through a "liturgy".

  1. Multiple choice questions from The Crucible.

    Act IV E. Happens before/after the play 16. Elizabeth Proctor is arrested for witchcraft A. Act I B. Act II C. Act III D. Act IV E. Happens before/after the play 17. A witch is hanged in Beverly A. Act I B. Act II C. Act III D.

  2. Pericles and Athens in the 5th century BC

    They were educated I philosophy, history, politics, science, art and literature so they could carry conversations with intelligent and sophisticated men. Aspasia was considered to be the most beautiful and the most intelligent of all the hetairai. Pericles met Aspasia and immediately moved in with her.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work