• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The New Poor Law of 1834 Coursework Assignment - Study Sources B, C and D. Do these sources suggest that the Commissioners succeeded in making the workhouse 'an uninviting place'? Explain your answer.

Extracts from this document...


The New Poor Law of 1834 Coursework Assignment Question 2 Study Sources B, C and D. Do these sources suggest that the Commissioners succeeded in making the workhouse 'an uninviting place'? Explain your answer. Source B shows the plan of Linton Union workhouse in 1837. The main problem with the workhouse that concerned the poor would be the segregation of families. Parents separated from their children, who may have been very young. Even in death they would be separated because there are two dead rooms, one in the women's yard and one in the men's yard. The women's jobs were washing clothes and carrying out laundry. This is shown by the source because the washing room and the laundry room are on the women's side. The men's jobs often were to crush bones or stones or to mill corn in the flour and mill room. If they were deemed refractory by either committing a refractory offence or two disorderly offences within six days then they would be placed in the refractory ward. ...read more.


Although the food was bland and boring they would not starve or go hungry. The commission wanted to help the deserving poor by giving extra rations. For example the over 60's would be given '1oz tea, 5ozs butter, 7oz sugar per week in lieu of breakfast gruel' and 'children under 9 years old' would get a 'flexible diet'. The commissioners were strict Christians so as a result they enforced that 'All drink water- no alcohol'. In Linton on Christmas Day they would be given extra rations of 'fare of beef, plum pudding and beer' this was going against the rule but was disregarded due to it being a merry occasion. Source D displays the Linton workhouse timetable and rules of conduct. The inmates would work for 10hrs a day, this was a relatively short day compared to jobs in the factories or in mines where it was not uncommon for people to work 14hr days. The work would not be dangerous and they would not have to travel miles each day to get to work. ...read more.


The commissioners did indeed achieve their aim of making the workhouse an 'uninviting place'. The least appealing of the three sources would have to be Source B. This is because of the segregation of families. Older couples who had been together their whole lives would be split up and put into same sex yards. The next least appealing would be the working hours; the timetable would not allow them to talk during meal times and would not give them much free time. The punishments for disorderly and refractory actions were also a major deterrent, because the inmates' one bit of enjoyment would come from their meals, which would be reduced if they committed an offence. The source which is the best of the three would be Source C. The diet in the workhouse was far better in some circumstances. Especially in such places as the slums of Manchester, they would often starve. As a result the workhouse could not make the diet worse than the lowest paid labourer. Overall the workhouse test was implemented effectively and in nearly all cases only the most destitute would enter. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Food Technology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Food Technology essays

  1. Kosher Coursework A)

    * Milk (milchig- Yiddish): all milk and dairy products- cheese made with animal products is not permitted. * Parev or Parve are all the foods in which are not milk or meat such as eggs, vegetables, fruits, cereals, beans, pulses, fish and according to the bible, locusts.

  2. Evaluation; preparation of a Thai style meal

    sure I complete what I need to be doing in the correct time frame and that tasks do not overlap and create problems by running out of or not organising time. Although I was very happy with the finished result, I think that looking at the picture I could have garnished my dishes better making them more attractive.

  1. heal and social unit 2

    Because of smoking he can die early. He will also not be healthy. From not doing enough exercise he will have a week heart and he won't be healthy. Poor diet isn't good for him because he doesn't exercise and he smokes. This will make him get into a serious illness.

  2. Science Case Study

    Yet spurred on by a growing legion of super-skinny celebs including reality show star Nicole Richie, Superman actress Kate Bosworth and our own "skinny icon" Victoria Beckham, size 0 is now touted not only as an attainable, but a must-get goal by dedicated followers of fashion.

  1. Open and produce a marketing plan for a new restaurant.

    The Plane should have financial intermediaries such as bank and insurance companies. The banks will help the restaurant to keep all the money that this restaurant earn and do the business transactions of this restaurant. Insurance companies will insure the workers against the risks associated with their working place.

  2. Investigate the use of language in menus.

    Hence this research would show how language is used to advertise, persuade and sell to different target audiences. Due to the flaws in the investigation by The Good Pub Guide, I decided to use a questionnaire in order to obtain results of how effective the menus are to there readers.

  1. What Impact did the 1834 New Poor Law have on Gressenhall workhouse in Norfolk?

    Washing was done by the women and was hard boring work. The old laundry was converted into a boardroom and a waiting room where there were luxury floors and windows, as it was a meeting place for the middle class Board of Guardians.

  2. What do Sources A, C and D tell us about conditions in the Jewish ...

    `to give them any food` In source C we learn from the sketches of Prof. Ludwik Hirszfeld that the ghettos were overcrowded with people. `The streets are so over-populated, ` Secondly there is lack of clothing in the ghettos; many people do not even have a shirt to their name.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work