• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparative Essay - Blood Brothers & Annie

Extracts from this document...


Joseph Kingham Drama - Part One Comparative Essay - Blood Brothers & Annie Within this essay I intend to evaluate and compare the similarities and differences between two devised thematic scripts intended for performance to an audience. The two scripts I have chosen to compare are Blood Brothers, as originally written for and performed by Merseyside Young People's Theatre Company, and Annie, as performed by Hill House St Mary's School Doncaster, 2007. I shall begin with a basic outline of each story, and the way in which it was intended to be performed. Blood Brothers is a tragedy, a tale of love, brotherhood and class set in Britain in the 1980's, which highlights the economic turbulence the country, and especially the working class, were in the midst of in this period. It begins with Mrs Johnston, a humble working class Liverpudlian, who falls in love and marries. Unfortunately the man she falls in love with is false and deceitful, and leaves her after impregnating her with what they believed would be their eighth child. In contrast, Mrs Lyons in an upper-middle class happily-married woman who, due to unfortunate biological barriers, is unable to conceive. ...read more.


Although acting is mainly intercharactorial, on occasion (especially through song and dance) it is performed directly to the audience. This makes the audience feel more involved, and makes it more fun and more suitable for children, whereas in Blood Brothers the audience require at least a modicum of insightfulness to enjoy the production. A similarity is, however, the basis of the story, the adoption of a child, from a poor, working class background into a richer, more comfortable middle/upper class, albeit at different ages. In Blood Brothers, Edward (one of the twins) is adopted as a baby by a woman who raises him almost single-handedly. In Annie, Annie is adopted into an extremely wealthy - if unorthodox - family consisting of a strong alpha male (Mr Warbucks) and his team of employees, who act as brothers, sisters, aunties, uncles, and in the case of Grace (Mr Warbucks' personal assistant) it could even be argued a mother. Another strong similarity is the underlying current of dissatisfaction and class segregation in both 1920's America and 1980's Britain. In Annie it is portrayed especially through a scene in a 'Hooverville,' (local term for a slum) ...read more.


This is a sad reminder of where lies lead, and is an attempt by the writer to warn the audience of messing with fate - and the ultimate punishment for doing so. This leaves a lasting message with the audience. Annie, however, ends with perhaps the best outcome possible. After Daddy Warbucks becomes aware of the scam to try and claim the money by impostors, he offers to adopt her himself, an invitation she gladly accepts, in a heart-warming (although, again, slightly predictable - another similarity perhaps?) finale. The impostors are arrested and sent to jail, and everyone sings to their heart's content on Christmas day, leaving the audience with that warm feeling in the pit of their stomach (the one that's nice, not indigestion). Overall, I think the similarities between the productions is enough to warrant the evaluation that, on the most basic level at least, Annie and Blood Brothers are the same story, only told in a completely different manner - hence the enormous differences. Despite the dissimilarity in ending, both productions cause some very interesting debates, such as whether nature or nurture is more influential in the upbringing of a child, or whether class and social divides really are influential enough to prevent friendships that, in other conditions, may have blossomed. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. Drama Comparative Essay BB+M+BE

    Although he was over powering when he told Billy to dance on the table he was trying to show compassion that he is only a little boy and should not go to ballet school. I tied to play Taylor as very headstrong but towards the end he was a bit

  2. Blood Brothers response

    Without a real enclosed space Jacob would have to pretend being trapped which could seem unrealistic. All these techniques contributed towards the effectiveness of the drama. Our second task was to create an alternative beginning to the "Blood Brothers" script.

  1. Blood Brothers

    Plus later on when the husband of Mrs Lyons (Mr Lyons) places his shoe on the table, Mrs Lyons become panicky herself as she loudly screams "no..." to make sure the shoes were withdrawn from the table. This helped to create tension as we could see Ms Lyons becoming more

  2. Blood Brothers review

    As children when Mickey and Eddie first met, you could see that he was wearing stretched out shirts and shorts, which clearly told the audience that they were hand me downs, and he wore a tank top that had holes in it.

  1. World Literature Essay Number Two:The symbolism of Blood and Water in the play "Blood ...

    the blood in her hair symbolises the sexual passion which was involved in her relationship with Leonardo, and which led to his death. This image again reinforces the violence of their death, and the extent of the spilling of the blood.

  2. Free essay

    nature verses nurture blood brothers

    The class difference between the two twins is also apparent when Mickey asks Eddie if he knows what "the F word" is. Eddie has no idea because he was brought up in a society where no one ever uses illiterate language.

  1. Blood Brothers

    her how she can see the boy everyday and can look after him herself and that the boy will have everything he needs if he were to be Mrs Lyons' son. We use thought tracking yet again and this time we have Mrs Lyons in a freeze frame and Mrs

  2. An Evaluation of Blood Brothers

    His portrayal of the two different characters is great; the very quick change makes it even more impacting. The interventionist narrator plays a very important role in Blood Brothers. Throughout the play he tells the story, but a lot more than that.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work