• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Atticus and Aunt Alexandra- although they are brother and sister- have completely different viewpoints and what is meant to be

Extracts from this document...


Discuss how the incident referred to in this passage highlights the clash between Atticus and aunt Alexandra. Discuss with reference to the themes of tolerance and family values, using examples from chapters 12-14. Atticus and Aunt Alexandra- although they are brother and sister- have completely different viewpoints and what is meant to be a good person. Atticus for example feel that good people or 'fine folks' are those who do the "best they can with the sense they have", regardless of their family background, wealth, or social status. Aunt Alexandra on the other hand has a different opinion: she feels that a person's 'goodness' or respectability depends on his family background, or how long the family has been residing over a single piece of land. With such different viewpoints, it is evident that brother and sister will also differ in their family values and the qualities they want to instill in the children. Family values refer to those ethics and principles that every parent tries to instill in his children. With Aunt Alexandra presiding over the Finch household, it is inevitable that there will be clashes between Atticus and herself, as both of them struggle to teach the children what they think is right. ...read more.


She is also socially prejudiced as she cares about what people will say if a white girl from the 'respectable' Finch family is found in the company of blacks. Atticus knows that it will not harm Scout if she mingles with Calpurnia outside home, because he does not rely on the myth that all blacks are evil; rather he judges Calpurnia as an individual, and knows that she will never wrongly influence Scout or Jem. The third clash is related to the previous one in the sense that it also concerns Calpurnia. Aunt Alexandra feels that the children are getting too close to Calpurnia, and she feels that this is not good because she is a mere black cook. She urges Atticus to fire Calpurnia, but for once Atticus refuses to comply and stands up to his sister, declaring that Calpurnia is an integral part of the household. Atticus looks beyond blood ties and skin color and judges Calpurnia by her high moral standards, saying, 'Cal's lights are pretty good'. Atticus shows his tolerance by referring to Calpurnia as a surrogate mother for the children, regardless of the fact that she is a poor black cook. ...read more.


This is a drastic contrast to Atticus's liberal parenting style, and the fact that he pays no heed to what society might think, and does what he thinks is right. Despite the fact that he is in the right, Atticus tolerates his sister's strong-headedness, and even tries to go along with her wishes where he can. On her insistence he tries to tell Jem and Scout to behave in a manner fitting of the Finches; he even tells Scout to apologize to her aunt when she is rude, even though Aunt had no right to interfere. Although Aunt appears inflexible and narrow minded, it must be kept in mind that her eagerness tom rear Jem and scout and her pride in the Finch name, shows that she cares deeply for the family. Although the clashes are shown between Aunt Alexandra and Atticus, it is actually a much greater struggle between two great forces. Aunt Alexandra represents the conservative side of Maycomb, and the inflexible, narrow-minded thinking of her time. Atticus, along with Calpurnia and his children depict a style of thinking too modern for that time; a feeling of tolerance and acceptance and the ability to look past a person's exterior. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Harper Lee section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Harper Lee essays

  1. Atticus Finch & Silas Marner - Good Parents?

    It does not matter because he has given them a new tradition of thinking, a way that breaks them from the others of Maycomb. Jem and Scout do not think in terms of class and race. Scout does not have to think hard to know that she would "let Tom

  2. Atticus confesses that he sometimes thinks of himself as a "complete failure" as a ...

    and this is very important as it shows the extent of understanding and respect Scout has for Atticus and also shows just how well Atticus explained the complicated situation to Scout the night before. Scout is beginning to remember to be reasonable and this is a definite sign of her growing up.

  1. Comparing the Roles of Aunt Alexandra and Calpurnia

    It's more of the fact that Aunt Alexandra is Atticus' sister than the fact that she has earned the respect from Atticus truthfully and properly. But Atticus is obliged to respect her. Another reason why he needs to respect her is that she owns finches landing and Atticus was the

  2. Scout has 3 main guardians in her life; Atticus, Calpunia and Aunt Alexandra. How ...

    Additionally she has a clear sense of natural justice as her father Atticus is a lawyer. What scout learns we learn. Scout is influenced in many ways by many people in the novel. Her influences were her father Atticus, her brother Jem, her friend dill, Calpunia the families cook, her Aunt Alexandra and finally her neighbour Miss Maudie.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work