• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"By the end of the play, Eliza has benefited from her relationship with Higgins. Discuss."

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"By the end of the play, Eliza has benefited from her relationship with Higgins. Discuss." The word 'benefit' is defined as; 'a favourable or helpful factor or circumstance'. Many benefits are not immediately recognised, as they can be the result of something bad. In the play 'Pygmalion', by Bernard Shaw, Liza gains many benefits, but also disadvantages from her relationship with Higgins. Looking at benefits, she receives some beautiful clothes; 'I'm to have fashionable clothes' (p. 63), a good place to stay and financial ease. She meets other friends such as Freddy; 'I'll marry Freddy, I will' (p. 131), and she has permanent companions. However, though she has learned good speech with Higgins, she has not learnt manners, and is treated almost like an animal. She is unhappy for a while, and is used by Higgins greatly. But was it worth it for Eliza to have spent any time with Higgins? Do the benefits outweigh the disadvantages? Throughout her time with Higgins, Eliza immediately became financially viable. ...read more.

Middle

In contrast, Eliza also encounters a number of disadvantages working with Higgins. Firstly, she was taught badly in the manners of upper class people, although she did actually learn correctly through Colonel Pickering, such as; 'things about standing up, and taking off your hat' (p. 122). She decided that Higgins' bad manners were 'his way' (p. 122), as he behaved the same to everyone. However, she was taught badly by him, as few upper class people would behave as he did. Secondly, a disadvantage of her relationship with Higgins was Eliza's treatment. Higgins treated her as nothing more than a servant when he was not teaching her phonetics, and using her to win his bet. He simply treated her 'just the same as a scullery maid' (p. 122), and was very unfair towards her, when, having won his bet, he acted as though she were a toy he had finished playing with, and was now going to throw away. In addition to Higgins, the other characters, such as Pickering, affected whether Eliza actually benefited from her stay with Higgins or not. ...read more.

Conclusion

This may prove the relationship with Higgins to be a worthwhile experience. However, in contrast, the life Eliza is now living may be happy, but the life she would have had may have been better. This would not have been the case financially, but good friends and a better husband than Freddy may have been the result of staying on the streets 'soylin' voylets'. We can see that Higgins impression on Eliza has changed; in Act One being 'you squashed cabbage leaf' (p. 27) through to Act Five 'I can't turn off your soul' (p. 127). He considers her more of a human being by this time, and this may have proved to her benefit in later life. Eliza, however, realises the strange equality between herself and Higgins, beginning in Act One 'I've a right to be here, same as you' (p. 27) through Act Five 'I have been brought up like him ... using bad language' (p. 121). This may suggest that Eliza proved almost as much of a benefit to Higgins as he did to her. In my opinion, this relationship benefited both characters, and without this occurrence, their lives would not have been so fulfilled. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Authors essays

  1. Secrets. The Beautiful short story Secrets is based on the theme of relationships, which ...

    He obviously wanted her to know that he loved her. More evidence of their special relationship is shown in anther letter that the boy reads. "You remember when we swam the last two fingers of your hand went the colour and texture of candles with the cold.

  2. How does Ayub Khan-Din portray conflict in the play East is East

    he is basically suggesting that he hate Pakistani culture and then associating himself with it by eating traditional Pakistani food. "Paki enough when you want feeding aren't you?" This further supports the idea that Tariq is confused about his cultural identity and the irony of his love for Pakistani food but hate of Pakistani people.

  1. Looking closely at Pygmalion, consider the relationship between Higgins and Eliza. Where do ...

    Then when it is time to go, she hops into a taxi, showing off she has money: "Never mind, young man. I'm going home in a taxi."(p19). At the moment we do not have many feelings for Higgins because the play has not described much but likes to stick to his own class (Pickering)

  2. With Close Reference to two or three episodes, investigate the relationship between Sherlock Holmes ...

    quite different to the other elements previously written in this book the narrator is actually ... the sidekick; Using a sidekick is a very useful thing for an author whilst writing a book or making a film about detectives. The vast majority of all detectives have one or more sidekicks.

  1. How does Shaw draw the audience's attention to issues of social class in Act ...

    Bernard Shaw was a realist and really wanted us to think about the issues of social class by dropping in a lot of philosophical sayings. I think the society at the time in which the play was written, greatly influenced Shaw because things were just starting to change in terms of socialism and feminism was particularly strong in the UK.

  2. What do we learn of Shaw's attitude towards class from "Pygmalion" ?

    The Eynsford Hill's and Higgins' treatment of Eliza show the prejudices that Shaw say towards the lower classes from the middle and upper classes. Clara Eynsford-Hill treats Eliza with contempt, "make her give you the change.

  1. How does Charles Dickens create characters that are both memorable and striking in the ...

    This change in light of Pip's character is further aided by Wemmick's kindness which is also in contrast with Pip's new attitude. This makes him more memorable. This point can be further backed up by the contrast in settings between Wemmick and Pip.

  2. 20th Century Modern Play Coursework: Whose Life Is It Anyway?

    She changes him and just generally mothers him. The language she uses in relation to Ken is kind of condescending; "There. That's better. Comfortable?" it babies him, causes him to be slightly uncomfortable in that he can't do these things himself.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work