• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Childhood is an integral theme in both Hard Times and God of Small Things

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How successful do you feel the authors are in portraying the world of childhood? Childhood is an integral theme in both Hard Times and God of Small Things but both authors have tackled the issue in a vastly different way. Arundhati Roy focuses her book very much on the way children relate to the world around them, while Dickens tends to look more at how children are treated by the rest of the world. This small change in perspective gives a vastly different view of children's lives, which are further enhanced by the writing styles of the two authors. Roy's greatest gift is her power of memory, the kind of memory Charles Dickens is famous for and a small number of other writers such as George Eliot and the poet Wordsworth, which can bring alive for the reader what most of us have forgotten but can recall if jogged. What it felt like to be a child, "a stranger and afraid in a world we never made", yet endowed with as much or more ability to experience the supposedly adult emotions of anxiety, jealousy, grief, despair, as well as what Rahel's uncle Chacko tells her are "possible in Human Nature. Love. Madness. Hope. Infinite Joy". The novel's lead characters, Rahel and her twin brother, Estha, become fit carriers for whatever the novel is saying about the ...read more.

Middle

He knows precisely what his seniors are looking for ("Quadruped. Graminivorous. Forty teeth...") and by giving them the answers they look for he gains enough of their trust and respect to cover his lack of scientific intelligence and to gain information he wants from them. He becomes an expert at understanding Mrs Sparsit and soon begins to have control over her by merely placing ideas in her grasp and letting her take the credit for them "you did object to names being used, and they're always best avoided". To watch Bitzer converse with Mrs Sparsit is highly amusing as we are directly seeing Dickens ridiculing her through the boy: "He now and then slided into 'my lady', instead of 'ma'am', as an involuntary acknowledgement of Mrs Sparsit's dignity". Dickens uses Bitzer as a fine example that children (or youths, at this stage in the book) have every right to be as sharp and manipulative as the adults are. Louisa can also be incredibly acute at times, demonstrated as she conversed with Mr Harthouse, leaving Bounderby perplexed by the speed and insightful nature of their conversation. Harthouse's innocent phrase "because I have no choice of opinions" is quickly torn apart by an astute Louisa who jumps in: "Have you none of your own". The rapid fire exchange is broken only by Mr Bounderby mentioning the postponement of dinner. ...read more.

Conclusion

While this does little to weaken the criticism that Hard Times makes it must be taken into account that when Dickens wrote it, it probably didn't seem quite as absurd as it does to us today. Roy presents the case of modern children of a younger age than Hard Times' characters so they are in most ways less hardened to life's cruelties. Instead Roy presents them coping with the troubles that young children have to overcome, and more importantly she tries to consider the thoughts that Estha and Rahel would be having whilst in these situations. This is where her memory and understanding of children really seem to come into their own. She manages to provoke feelings in her readers from their background that enables them to form a strong bond with her young characters, on a peer level rather than that on her seniors as Dickens tends to do. It is hard to say one author does a better job at presenting childhood than the other because they both focus on different areas of the maturing mind, but I feel Roy has done a very thought-provoking and insightful study of childhood in a fast paced page-turning style, where Dickens has instead attempted, and succeeded in making a lighter, and perhaps more fun, family targeted story book that aims to entertain and occupy the reader, rather than forcing them to take a hard look children and their lives. Word Count: 2256 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Hard Times section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Hard Times essays

  1. The purpose of this essay is to consider what role the circus folk play ...

    It is at this point that Gradgrind suddenly and probably to his shock discovers that he does have feelings and that all is not cut and dry, yes he accepts that Tom has stolen and should be punished but he doesn't want to allow Tom to be punished, he is

  2. 'What are the reasons which Dickens gives for the hard times described in the ...

    There are many social injustices experienced in the novel especially by Stephen Blackpool. This may have been caused by the inequality between the rich and the poor citizens of Coketown. When Stephen wants a divorce he cannot have one as he cannot afford one, despite his unhappiness.

  1. What techniques does Dickens employ in his depiction of Mrs Sparsit and what is ...

    Through this idea Dickens is able to create suspense as he reinforces Louisa descending down the staircase because the reader is interested to see what will come of Louisa and Harthouse's relationship especially as the following chapters are called "Lower and Lower", and "Down".

  2. Y10 English Literature Coursework

    He also starts every sentence in paragraph four with the words 'no little Gradgrind.' There is a sentence which has a lot of rhythm, 'that famous cow with the crumpled horn who tossed the dog who worried the cat who killed the rat who ate the malt.'

  1. Examine Dickens' presentation of the education system in 'Hard Times'.

    It may not be all sufficient. " Gardgrind has seen the effect of his theories on his own child and has realised he was wrong. He has realised that if she was allowed to 'fancy' when she was younger she would not be in the mess she's in.

  2. Look carefully at the opening chapters of Hard Times and explore Dickens attitude towards ...

    As he is a rationalist, 'dry' indicates a sense of bitterness, everything that comes out of his mouth is cold with no expression. As dry means little or no emotion, Dickens gives rationalists a negative display to the reader and does this to show how rationalism affects the way one speaks.

  1. Compare and contrast the way in which particular aspects of education are presented in ...

    Gradgrind uses the 'number system' to select Sissy from the class. The girl's father works for the circus which does not please Mr. Gradgrind so his solution to the predicament is to cover up this plain fact with lies "He doctors sick horses...Very well, then. He is a veterinary surgeon..."

  2. Looking at 'Down', consider how Dickens presents the impact that Gradgrind's philosophy has had ...

    the reader is introduced to the Gradgrind philosophy; "...nothing but Facts. Facts alone are wanted in life. Plant nothing else, and root out everything else." One of the things that Gradgrind believes should be rooted out is fancy; in chapter two when Sissy says "...I would fancy-", she is immediately interrupted; "Ay, ay, ay!

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work