• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast four different crime stories, 'A wife in a million', 'Superfluous murder', 'The man with the twisted lip', and 'The reluctant detective'.

Extracts from this document...


Reading the four different crime stories has allowed me to take different views on each detective. In the first story, 'A Wife In a Million', Maggie Staniforth solves a strange case in which the criminal is poisoning innocent people. 'Superfluous Murder' is about a crime involving John Mansbridge and his cousin Felix which is solved by an unnamed Superintendent. During the third story, 'The Man with the Twisted Lip', Sherlock Holmes investigates the peculiar disappearance of Neville St Clair. And finally, In the the fourth story, 'The Reluctant Detective', Fredrick Herring and his girlfriend Dawn set up their own detective agency and crack a mysterious case. I will now explore each character and decide who I feel is the most convincing detective of the four. When looking at the word 'convincing', there can be two different meanings relating to these stories. Firstly, is the character realistic in the way he/she is set out to the reader? Secondly, is the detective convincing in the way he/she solves the case i.e: is he she a good detective? I think that both these factors have to be considered before making a final decision. Maggie Staniforth in 'A Wife in a Million' is a very realistic person as she is described in a humane manner. She feels a tremendous amount of strain as she desperately tries to put a stop to the killing spree as "lines of strain around her eyes" and "Exhausted Maggie" show. ...read more.


The Superintendent shows that he is a great detective by the way in which he unravels every little fact concerning the case so interestingly. I enjoyed reading the intendent retelling me what had just occurred. In my opinion, though he may be a good detective, he is a unrealistic one, because of the manner in which he resolves the crime. It makes the super intendent seem super human because he easily solves a complicated crime. He also seems to feel no strain, stress or tiredness, unlike Maggie, which makes him seem even less believable. Looking at the factors above, altogether, I think that the super intendent is a great detective but has an unrealistic character. Moving onto the third story, 'The Man with the Twisted Lip' is about the strange disappearance of Neville St Clair. This case is solved by a detective known as Sherlock Holmes. Sherlock Holmes is easily the most famous of all four detectives and is one of the best. Holmes convincingly solves the case and shows us the skills which have made him possibly the most famous story detective of all time. One of the first things we find out upon meeting Sherlock Holmes is that he is a master of disguise. When Watson is walking in the opium bar, he sees what he thinks is an old man but to his surprise is Sherlock Holmes, "His form had filled and his wrinkles where gone..... ...read more.


They do not stand up to any of the three other detectives who are well organised. All the information above has allowed me to come to the conclusion that three of the four detectives are convincing. The three detectives I found credible are, firstly, the detective from "A Wife in a Million", Maggie Staniforth who solves the case in which people are mysteriously being poisoned. Secondly, The Superintendent from "Superfluous Murder" who solves the case involving John Mansbridge and his already dead cousin Felix. And finally the third credible detective is Sherlock Holmes who convincingly cracks the case he has been dealt and shows us the skills that made him so famous. On the other hand, the least convincing detective, or should I say detectives are Fredrick and Dawn who star in "The Reluctant Detective". These two detectives are terrible in my opinion as they struggle to solve the case. Out of the three convincing detectives, if I had to choose one, I would probably choose the super intendent in "Superfluous Murder" because he solves his case in an exciting fashion and it was enjoyable for me to read the detective unfold the case, bit by bit. None of these detectives are perfectly convincing but for me, the mysterious Superintendent is the most convincing as he is the cleverest and brightest detective and his character is at at least mildly convincing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle essays

  1. After Reading Three Crime Stories, Which Detective Do You Find Most Believeable?

    Unlike other stories where everything is nice and rosy in the household, in this one the writer constantly emphasizes that everything is not well in the home. Also the fact that the writer even bothered to put empathizes in relations in the household makes the story stand out from other

  2. Examine the settings which the writers have chosen for their stories in the Signalman ...

    When Watson finds Holmes, they then travel to The Cedars, Neville St. Clair's home, similar to Watson's house, that is another contrast as a place of warmth, comfort that and light. These two stories belong to the same genre, mystery, and so do share some characteristics, but they are also very different.

  1. Compare the way the authors of "The Red Room", "The Old Nurse's Story", and ...

    Also the narrative is fragmented narrative meaning that it is not all in chronological order, and includes flash backs. The conversational style narrative is effective because the reader feels although she is re-telling her story directly to us, this engages the reader into the story dramatically, the fragmented narrative may

  2. Sherlock Holmes essay Compare the two short stories Man with the twisted lip and ...

    "The front room was plainly furnished as a sitting room, and led into a small bedroom which looked out upon the back of one of the wharves". "The Speckled Band" is set in Stoke Moran on the Western border of Surrey in a run-down two-hundred year old mansion which is set in a few acres of ground.

  1. To what extent are the three/four stories we have investigated typical murder mystery or ...

    Because Dr Watson isn't as adept at solving crimes as Sherlock Holmes is Sherlock Holmes knows he has to explain his thought processes to Dr Watson. It is via this that he explains to the readers too, who are in a similar position to Dr Watson.

  2. Compare and contrast at least 3 of the Sherlock Holmes stories you have read

    Another possible conclusion would be that he was quite surprised to see his wife, and quickly moved away from the window, so that she wouldn't suspect his double life. "Convinced that something was amiss from him, she rushed down the steps-for the house was none other than the opium den

  1. How does Setting add to the atmosphere in the two Sherlock Holmes Stories - ...

    Miss Helen Stoner told Sherlock Holmes that when she heard her sister scream, she ran out into the corridor and heard a low whistling and low noise of metal dropping: "wild scream of a terrified woman...it was my sister's voice...

  2. Comparison Of Two 19th Century Crime Stories.

    hunting-crop swinging in his hand,' which is one of the more apparent details. Most of the time, Watson is perplexed and confused, and seems to make illogical observations, therefore the readers are able to relate to Watson, as he is an archetypal example of an average human mind.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work