• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Presentation of the Psychological Effects of the WarAnd the Setting on Stanhope, Osborne and Raleigh in 'Journey's End', andHilliard and Barton in 'Strange Meeting'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast the Presentation of the Psychological Effects of the War And the Setting on Stanhope, Osborne and Raleigh in 'Journey's End', and Hilliard and Barton in 'Strange Meeting' Written by R.C Sherriff in 1928, 'Journey's End' was the cause of controversy when the play was first produced in 1929, as the play's subject matter, the War itself, was still considered a raw period in history. 'Strange Meeting', written by Susan Hill in 1971, shared this subject matter yet, as Hill wrote of the War several decades later, she presented it from a differing perspective. Both authors however, present an extremely anti-war stance through their texts. Sherriff presents a microcosm of the War; setting all of the action within one dugout due to the restrictions of the stage, focussing on one small group of men. This enables Sherriff to present a detailed account of the events of the play, depicting a vivid image of life in the front line trenches, and the effect it had on the men involved. Similarly, Hill uses claustrophobic settings for her novel, although these settings vary unlike those in Sherriff's play. The limitations of a stage production consequently allow Sherriff to emphasise the strength and nature of the relationships between the men, due to the close proximity in which they live, through stage directions and set. Focussing on a small group of protagonists, Sherriff is able to present several stereotypes of soldiers throughout the War. Similarly, Hill bases the action of her novel around two central protagonists and several supporting characters, which enables her to present details of the formation of close relationships between men living in such close proximity, under such stress, through utilising different literary techniques, such as switching from the third person perspective to first person in Barton's letters. ...read more.

Middle

Contrary to this objective insight given by Hill, the limitations of the play as a genre mean that Sherriff uses stage directions to show Stanhope's feelings of dismay towards Raleigh upon first meeting him. Stage directions state that; 'he [Stanhope] stops at the sight of Raleigh. There is silence.' Sherriff then demonstrates Stanhope only talking to Raleigh in short, simple sentences, enabling the audience to recognise Stanhope's discomfort at Raleigh's presence; 'How did you - get here?' or avoiding speaking to Raleigh whenever possible. Raleigh and Stanhope are acquainted with each other since their schooldays, it would be expected that Stanhope would be more open and inviting towards Raleigh. Instead, Sherriff depicts a man emotionally withdrawn and guarded, using blunt remarks such as 'Oh. I see.' Hill's portrayal of the meeting between Hilliard and Barton parallels Sherriff's depiction of the meeting between Stanhope and Raleigh, however there are differences due to the different circumstances of the meetings; Stanhope meets someone from his past whereas Hilliard meets someone new. While Hilliard, despite fearing meeting Barton, discovers that he's surprisingly drawn to him, Stanhope is pleasant towards the 'new officer'; 'Oh, sorry...I didn't see you in this miserable light', until the realisation of who this officer is, causing his manner to change. Stanhope withdraws and becomes fairly guarded. The differing attitudes of Hilliard and Stanhope towards Barton and Raleigh can be justified by scrutinising the characters' respective situations. Having become isolated and hardened by the War, Hilliard may have been drawn to Barton's innocence and naivety; a boy not yet ruined by the brutality of war. It's also possible that Hilliard saw an element of himself as a younger soldier, in Barton, and so warmed to him. ...read more.

Conclusion

The strength and closeness of Stanhope's relationship with Osborne is reflected in Stanhope's reaction, as he satirises the point of the raid manoeuvre, adopting an extremely sarcastic tone; 'How awfully nice- if the brigadier's pleased.' He does this due to the realisation that his best friend and father-figure has just lost his life for no justifiable reason. The audience also witness Stanhope's despair at the loss of Osborne through the resentful tone he adopts towards Raleigh, who recognises this, stating 'You resent my being here'. Stanhope's 'voice is still, expressionless and dead' when speaking to him. Conversely, in 'Strange Meeting' Hill describes every aspect of Barton's experience as it happens, pinpointing the moment when Barton realises the complete futility of his actions; 'He thought, I shall stay here, I shall wait and warm my face in the sun and if they fire, they will fire...For it seemed not to matter, nobody's life mattered...He was here to make a map.' Through Barton admitting the futility of his assigned task, Hill is expressing her own view that the War, in macrocosm, was futile. This can also be said of Sherriff, perhaps through Stanhope's sarcastic comments, 'Still it'll be awfully nice if the brigadier's pleased', Despite the contrasting genres of Sherriff's and Hill's texts, they both effectively convey the psychological effects of war, caused by the physical demands. Through stage directions and dialogue, Sherriff is able to depict the behaviour of soldiers and the formation of close relationships that bind them. Similarly, Hill vividly describes the psychological progress of her characters, utilising the first and third person perspectives, enabling the reader to empathise with her characters. 2948 words ?? ?? ?? ?? Bethany Weston - 1 - ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE RC Sheriff section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE RC Sheriff essays

  1. English 4UO Independent Study - Comparative Essay

    The piercing heartache that Pi was forced to endure as a result of the ridicule is most appropriately illustrated on page 22, as Pi reflects that, "The sound would disappear, but the hurt would linger...the cruelty of children comes as news to no one...unprovoked, uncalled for."

  2. Journeys End Coursework. How does R.C. Sherriff create sympathy for Raleigh from the ...

    But when he asked why they were acting like that he replied (shouting), "To forget, you little fool - to forget! D'you understand? To forget! You think there's no limit to what a man can bear?" Here Raleigh feels guilty about what he has said.

  1. Journey's End - How do the key scenes present a dramatic demonstration of R.C ...

    This could be because he feels guilty about having the argument with him in scene 2 and that he feels he ought to apologize. Raleigh shows his heroic efforts by mentioning that he feels rotten when he is not involved in fighting for his country.

  2. Journal Entry

    and eyed out our target. He was crouched in the trench cleaning his rifle and humming along to a small radio which appeared to be playing a German war song. Osborne managed to place the gag in his mouth whilst and Sterling and I managed to grab him by both arms and drag him over the top.

  1. Horror And Futility In Journeys End

    The odd number of boots may have been due to the rats gnawing at the boots or lost when taking them from dead soldiers, this could be most disturbing for the audience. Mason resembles Trotter because they both are humorous, Trotter purposefully trying to lift everyone's spirits, Mason just happens to be humorous when he talks about food.

  2. Write about the presentation of Stanhope's relationship with Raleigh in Act Two Scene One, ...

    Stanhope doesn't express his feelings because he feels he needs to be strong for him and his men to succeed. The audience really feels for Raleigh, he is so young and naive toward the war, he expected to go out there and come back a hero and he is finding

  1. How does Sherriff introduce the characters of Raleigh, Stanhope and Osborne in Act I ...

    This makes the audience unsure of what Stanhope?s character will be like when he is introduced in person. A significant thing we learn from both men is that Stanhope has a quick temper and was Draconian at school, especially on the boys who drank whisky but we know from Hardy

  2. How does Sherriff make the character of Stanhope engaging for the audience?

    Stanhope also shows us his softer side by saying this; this tells us that he is not the ?hard man? that he is made out to be. This is engaging because although like Hibbert, we might condemn someone for drinking so much and question whether they are responsible enough to

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work