• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the two Victorian horror stories “The Red Room” by H. G Wells (1896) And “The Judge ‘s House” by Bram Stoker. (1891) Which seems to be the most effective example of the genre and why?

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the two Victorian horror stories "The Red Room" by H. G Wells (1896) And "The Judge 's House" by Bram Stoker. (1891) Which seems to be the most effective example of the genre and why? People in the Victorian era loved horror novels. This is for the same reason, as we love them now; they're scary, and make us jump. Stories set in the Victorian period seem to be scarier because of the lack of communication possible with others. This helps the horror story to set a "deserted scene". Many people enjoy horror stories because they want to see the downfall of the main character possibly because of the evil things he has done, or the way he has been portrayed by the author. Earlier gothic novels written in the 1700s have influenced both "The Red Room" and "The Judges house". These include Horace Walpoles' "Castle of Otranto" and Ann Radcliffes' "The Mysteries of Udolpho". If these books hadn't been written, possibly "The Judges House" nor "The Red Room" would have been written. Short stories were very popular in the late 1800s and this is exactly what our two famous horror novels are. "The Judges House" is about a young man, named Malcomson, who leaves his hometown for a while to study, undisturbed, for his "mathematical tripos" exam. He stays in a market town named Benchurch. The house he stays in is the old judges house, which is now deserted and feared by locals. Weird things go on in the house during his stay and then an enormous rat appears. The rat turns out to be the judges' spirit. Then the judge comes back from the dead, through a painting of him and hangs poor Malcomson. ...read more.


She even brings the doctor out one day to try and deter Malcomson from staying but it doesn't work. Mrs. Dempster is completely different. She is the cleaner for Malcomson and doesn't believe in the supernatural. What she does hate are the rats though. She states, " rats are bogies and bogies are rats". All this opposition between the two women creates tension. This is because the reader doesn't know who to believe even though Malcomson clearly believes Mrs. Dempster. In "The Red Room" we never learn the name of the main character. He is very much the same as Malcomson. He is arrogant and only goes to the red room to prove others wrong. He doesn't believe in the supernatural. For example, in the red room he convinces himself that it is a draft, which is causing the candles to blow out. The main character is very offensive which leads to us not liking him and looking forward to his downfall. The elderly inhabitants of the castle are referred to as "grotesque", having "monstrous shadows" and "withered arms". By describing people this way it conjures up thoughts of monsters and the undead, which goes very well with the horror genre. There were many young Victorian men who started thinking that they were far superior to older people. Putting these elderly men and women in the same room as a young, full of himself man creates an interesting juxtaposition. The main character is finally proved wrong though, when he says, "It would take a very tangible ghost to frighten me", but in the end it is an invisible ghost that scares him. When he is in the red room the main character checks for gaps in the wainscot and for secret entrances. ...read more.


"The Judges House" is written in third person narrative, which gives the author the freedom to decide whether the main character lives or dies. The author relates to the main character, Malcomson, as "he". "Malcomson made up his mind", is an example of this narrative. After a speech "said he" often follows, this shows an objective narrative. In "The Red Room" it would read "I said" because it is written in the first person narrative. It is subjective. Third person narrative gives a good ending because, until the end (unless already stated) doesn't tell the reader whether the main character lives or dies. Unlike "The Judge's House", "The Red Room" is written in the first person narrative, which immediately tells you that the main character survives. In this case the story needs to be exciting through out, in order not to bore the reader with a predicted outcome. I'm sure that the best narrative for the horror genre is the third person narrative, which is used in "The Judge's House". This is because it gives an exciting ending and an unpredicted outcome. Overall, I think that "The Red Room" Is the most effective example of the horror genre. This is because people can get lost in the story. It is a lot more magical than "The Judge's House" which is more or less set in real life. The story really excelled in the atmosphere of the red room itself because of the wonderful descriptions of the furniture and vastness of the room. The Red Room" is definitely more gothic styled than "The Judge's House" and this is what I think a Victorian novel should be like. By Louis Rummer- Downing 10L2 , 10JF ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE H.G. Wells section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE H.G. Wells essays

  1. Gothic Horror stories. The three stories are 'The Signalman' written by Charles Dickens in ...

    There are many grotesque characters in all threes stories. In 'The Red Room' there are grotesque characters there is the man with the shade "his eyes were covered by a shade," The man with the withered arm "man with the withered arm".

  2. This essay will consider the similarities and differences between the techniques and devices used ...

    The young protagonist seems to illustrate the more challenging views in society at that time. He believes that there must be another explanation for the ghosts, but is ultimately proved wrong. This shows that the younger generation is more naive but also rational in the way that they see ghosts.

  1. Both the Phantom Coach and the Red Room are Victorian ghost stories, however they ...

    His face was livid as the face of a corpse. His bloodless lips were drawn back as if in the agony of death, and showed the gleaming teeth between" Edwards goes from the good fortune of finding the coach to sheer horror.

  2. Wider Reading: Compare and contrast the landlady and a terrible strange bed, which story ...

    The landlady tells Billy the price of the room that Billy thought was very cheap, which he agreed to. The landlady directs Billy to his room where he goes and unpacks. When Billy finished he came down and signed the guest book, as he was signing the guest book he

  1. The Red Room and The Monkey's Paw(Compare and Contrast)

    a dark forest surrounded by noises and shadows which you can't interpret. The setting may affect the atmosphere and tension in the story by making it scarier and feel more afraid as well as make the reader less inclined to put the book down.

  2. In the three Gothic Horror stories studied, how does each writer's description of the ...

    The narrator becomes frantic and soon out of fear is unconsciousness. When woken he says that fear is the reason why everything happened in the room, it is all to do with the mind playing games! The castles long, subterranean passage led the narrator to an isolated part of the castle where the red room was.

  1. 19th Century Victorian Horror Stories: English Literature Coursework: How 19th Century writers of horror ...

    He uses the words "germinating and sprouting" to describe the overtaking darkness in the room. Creating the impression that the darkness is alive and growing like a "germ" and "sprouting" like a plant of some sort. HG Wells also uses many metaphors like an "Ocean of Mystery" to describe the

  2. Found it hard to decide which story is the most effective, but I have ...

    Carnford he'd be happy for Malcolm to have the term in the house for free to prove there is nothing wrong with it, which hints that something might be wrong, However he does pay his three-month rent. The tension is rising steeply when he talks about the house to a

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work