• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the ways in which war is presented in 'The Charge Of The Light Brigade', 'Vox Militantis' and 'Drummer Hodge'.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast the ways in which war is presented in 'The Charge Of The Light Brigade', 'Vox Militantis' and 'Drummer Hodge'. The three poems 'The Charge of the Light Brigade', 'Vox Militantis' and 'Drummer Hodge' are set in the Crimean War and the Boer War. The Crimean War started in 1854 and in September of that year allies besieged Sebastpool in Crimea. In October the Russians attacked the British base at Balaclava. During this battle the Charge of the Light Brigade took place. The Charge of the Light Brigade was written immediately by Alfred, Lord Tennyson, after the reports came back to England. The Charge of the Light Brigade is different from the other poems because it is about a specific event whereas Vox Militantis and Drummer Hodge are more general. Drummer Hodge was written by Thomas Hardy; Hardy wrote this poem because he had heard of the death of a young drummer boy. The word Hodge was a word used for a 'country bumpkin' which he thought suitable because the young boy had lived in the country all his short life. ...read more.

Middle

The title of the poem, Vox Militantis actually means voice of the soldiers. In this poem, the soldiers get a voice to explain why they fought. The poem opens similarly to 'Drummer Hodge' and focuses immediately on the, 'wide veldt'. The descriptions of the landscapes are very similar to those in Drummer Hodge. Both of these poems are from the same war. In Vox Militantis, this theme is shown by the phrase, '...Boer and Briton lie...' this means that the enemies will become part of the same land and be with it forever. Most of the poem is taken up by a conversation between the stars and the dead soldiers, the stars are asking the soldiers questions and the soldiers are explaining why they chose to fight. The stars are seen as the voice of reason. The descriptions of them as 'cold, calm, and brilliant' have double meanings. The words 'cold' and 'brilliant' could mean unfeeling or cold or amazing or bright. 'Brilliant' not only refers to the physical brightness but also to the pure rationality and logic, which the stars represent. ...read more.

Conclusion

The poet is clearer about his attitude towards war in this poem than the other poets. In Drummer Hodge the poet is not quite as clear as in Charge of the Light Brigade whereas in Vox Militantis, the poet appears to be weighing up the two sides of the argument in his mind, making his opinion much less obvious. The poet in Charge of the Light Brigade talks about duty in stanza two, as does the poet in Vox Militantis. In Charge of the Light Brigade the poet also uses personification similar to Drummer Hodge but here the personification is used for a negative effect. This contrasts to Vox Militantis where personification is used for the stars and are looking down, protecting the men. In Charge of the Light Brigade the poet chooses to personify things which are bad to the soldiers. All the poets manage to create their desired effect and leave a lasting impression on the reader of war and its harsh realities. From these poems, I know more of the horrors of war and I feel sympathy for the men, as well as admiration for their bravery and heroism. Sophie Quiney ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

The essay writer makes a solid job of comparing these three poems, though the presentation here is a little "bitty", skipping from one feature to another in no particular order. The circumstances surrounding the poems are well explained and useful comparisons and contrasts are made regarding, for instance, the use of imagery and the attitude of the people involved.

Paragraph construction is well-managed, with a clear topic for each, and sentences are well-controlled.

The biggest disappointment is the conclusion, which should serve the task of bringing all these elements back together, briefly, and summarising their significance. However, the overall effort is good and just deserves its grade here.

4 stars

Marked by teacher Jeff Taylor 24/10/2014

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    compare the way love is presented in 'valentine' and 'sonnet130'

    4 star(s)

    goes back to their relationship and how there are different stages or 'layers' to it. The third stanza starts with a one worded line-'Here'. This is short and concise and calls the reader's attention away from the description of the onion and starts to say what the onion would do.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Farmhand by James Baxter. The poem is about a farmhand who is portrayed ...

    3 star(s)

    The fourth stanza talks of the farmhand's loneliness and vacuum he experiences in life. He longs for someone to love and someone who loves and cares for him. Like other people of his age and he yearns to have someone to walk with, to laugh and share life with.

  1. Peter Skrzynecki explores various aspects of belonging and not belonging in his poems ancestors, ...

    The "house" in this stanza symbolises their cultural identity and the act of pulling it down can be linked with the push for the assimilation of immigrants in 1950's Australia. Many migrants did not embrace the idea of assimilation and resented being forced to leave their homelands behind not only physically but in memory and custom.

  2. Out, out : How does Frost effectively reveal the fraglity of life in Out, ...

    The lack of detail suggest it is too tragic and gory to even consider describing. We are only told he tried to keep "the life from spilling". This use of metonymy is extremely effective as it shows the severity of the boy's accident.

  1. Seamus Heaney poetry comparison

    However Heaney does not just describe happy memories in both these poems, for in "Blackberry Picking" he involves the ideas of disappointment and the hardship of growing up, "I always felt like crying." Whereas in "Digging" he portrays his guilt that he did not follow in his father's footsteps, "squat pen rest, as snug as a gun."

  2. Essay: Song to the men of England

    Stanza seven and eight is written in a sarcasting tone, degrading the workers with words such as "shrink" and "trace your grave". The poet is doing this on purpose to get the workers feel low angry, making them want to stop working for their lords.

  1. Life-cycle' And 'Enter without so much as knocking

    "Hello, hello, hello all you lucky people" Followed by a comment highlighting the innocence of the child - Bobby Dazzler's false heartiness and slogans do not influence the child. 'and he really was lucky because it didn't mean a thing to him then' Dawe believes that the child is lucky because he knows nothing of this repetitive deceit of civilisation.

  2. Both of these poems Tramp by Rupert Loydell and Decomposition by Zulfikar Ghose represent ...

    For example the use of Decomposition could be interpreted in terms of death, or signifying the homeless person?s physical state. Overall, both poems are considering human beings I through non-human ways.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work