• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing and contrasting Silver Blaze and Finger Man

Extracts from this document...


Comparing and contrasting Silver Blaze and Finger Man When one thinks of detective fiction stories images of crime, murder, hero detective and villains enter a person's mind. These images have been constantly changing over years, but they are not very different from when detective stories first began in 1828. The birth of detective stories came about in 1828 with a novel called Memoires supposedly written by Vidocq a chief of France's detective force known as Surete. In 1841 a number of short stories were composed and collected to form The Murders in the Rue Morgue by Edgar Allen Poe but it was in 1892 when detective stories finally emerged and become known by the people. It was in 1892 when The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was published in the Strand magazine that detective fiction had become a great success. The years of Sherlock Holmes stories are considered as the 'Golden Age' of detective fiction, after this authors began to take different approaches towards detective fiction writing, the writing was most notoriously named 'Hard Boiled' detective fiction. Both types of approaches varied in different ways with each other, the 'Golden Age' era consisted of stories with closed settings and focused its characters in the middle and upper classes. In the Hard Boiled era the plot would be mentally just as challenging as a story from the Golden Age era, but would unfold and lead to violent twists and turns. ...read more.


When I read both stories there were many differences in character between Sherlock Holmes and Philip Marlowe. Sherlock Holmes is a more thoughtful and clue based detective where as Philip Marlowe relies on tip-offs and violence to resolve a situation. Sherlock Holmes is a methodical detective and relies in his wits to solve a case whereas PM uses his instincts. Within Silver Blaze Sherlock Holmes has a partner called Watson, the story itself is narrated by Watson and told through his view. PM is a one-man army and doesn't depend on anybody for assistance unless in dire circumstances. The change in text and dialogue is clearly shown once reading both stories. Pre 20th century text is very descriptive which is used as a feature of Holmes personality. In Finger Man the dialogue is very abrupt and direct, which also constructs an image of the stories setting and the characters persona. The dialogue and narrative probably the clearest and most noticed contrast between both stories. In the story Silver Blaze, the narrator is Dr. Watson who tells the events within the story as he interprets it. Although this story is written in first person, the first person isn't the main character. Watson describes the moment tells the reader about the surroundings, the mood and anticipating thoughts from Watson. Due to Watson's sideline he is always telling us Holmes' expressions trying to give understand what he is thinking. ...read more.


Marlow is an opposite. He takes risks that he has studied and thought about considerably before acting on it, but occasionally he acts on instinct making his behaviour unpredictable. Holmes is polite and sticks to the rules of the law. Holmes also can't resist explaining things, and he only speaks when he's ready, but when he speaks, he makes a long explanation. Marlow's conversations are fast, brief, and to the point. He speaks what is on his mind and doesn't care what other people think. Marlow seems more like a "tough guy", than a calm, composed detective like Holmes. Bending the rules is one thing Marlow doesn't really mind doing, he'll do what he has to do, to solve the case. If it means hitting another person, or shooting someone, he'll do it. The setting within the stories suggest stereotypical views of the surroundings and atmosphere giving the reader a whereabouts and extra dimension to the story. In Silver Blaze I imagined a dreary setting in the countryside, where it rains often and there isn't much form of transportation or communication. In Finger Man I in vision open top cars at daytime with the hot sun, but in the evening it is raining giving an eerie sense of things taking place. "...our rate at present is fifty three and a half miles an hour. The telegraph posts upon this line are 60 yards apart, and the calculation is a simple one..." ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle essays

  1. What are the roles of Holmes and Watson within Silver Blaze and what is ...

    Also we know that not only do both Holmes and Watson live together but also work together. This makes it hard but yet also very easy to evaluate their relationship. This is because I could evaluate the relationship between Holmes and Watson if I was to read all the Conan Doyle books, which he wrote.

  2. Detective Fiction

    The reader would be psychologically trying to find out who or what the criminal was however the reader would normally get it wrong. Another reason to detective Fiction's popularity was that, before Queen of crimes reign a huge majority were involved in the world war, so a lot of people had experienced the deaths and mysteries first hand.

  1. Keeping up Appearances Comparing and Contrasting "The man with the twisted lip" with "Front"

    a good technique to keep the suspense on the readers, he writes that it looks like Holmes knows what happened and as it is narrated by Watson the truth isn't found out till Watson finds out; the last few paragraphs after Holmes gets to the police station and shows that Boone the cripple is Neville St.

  2. Silver Blaze

    They would have been too obvious and there would be no element of surprise when the killer had been discovered. As the villain was also the victim, he could not suffer any consequences, and the story would therefore be tied up.

  1. "The Adventure Of The Engineer's Thumb" and "The Destructors" are both crime stories - ...

    In "The Adventure Of The Engineer's Thumb", It must have also been very frightening at the time of the attempted murder for Mr Hatherley, as he was being attacked with a heavy weapon similar to a "butcher's cleaver"; but although he lost his thumb, there was no other obvious long term damage.

  2. Silver Blaze is considered one of the greatest examples of Sherlock Holmes' power of ...

    "I have not observed the quarter-mile posts," said I. "Nor have I but the telegraph posts upon this line are sixty yards apart, and the calculation is a simple one. The main clues that add up to the final conclusion at the end of the story seem to be almost completely irrelevant at the time but when put together

  1. Re-read the following Sherlock Holmes stories - In terms of narrative of the characters, ...

    The horse had wondered off and had been found by the rival horse trainer and then hidden. In these three short stories there are some big similarities, they all contain a murder they are either at the start of the story, end or both.

  2. To what extent do the detective fiction stories looked at imitate 'The Murders in ...

    There is another 'point', which is evident in the detective stories we have read. This is that the detective seems to be an amateur and someone who doesn't like the Formal Police Service. Take Dupin for example. He said this about the Parisian Police: 'The Parisian Police, so much extolled for acumen, are cunning, but no more.'

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work