• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Elmer Andrews has argued that one of the most notable developments in modern American poetry has been the emergence of a “confessional poetry…giving direct expression to the poet’s personal life”

Extracts from this document...


Elmer Andrews has argued that one of the most notable developments in modern American poetry has been the emergence of a "confessional poetry...giving direct expression to the poet's personal life". (1996) How far do you think this comment is appropriate to the poems in this selection? In you answer you should refer to at least two poets The style of confessionalism revitalised the American literary scene. What is surprising is that two major exponents of the genre were both very shy and extraordinarily eccentric. Emily Dickinson was born into an upper-middle class family who were very religious, her father was a clergyman. Dickinson's desire to break free from the confines of conventional religion is apparent in her poem No. 67, in which she claims that American Patriotism is a new religion in its own right. In the first stanza, she shows her indifference to G-d and religion, "to comprehend a Nectar/ requires sorest need." The Nectar, the drink of G-d, is used to communicate Dickinson's views with the endnote, "requires sorest need." The reader could understand this as denouncing religion. This standpoint could be strengthened with quotes from the second stanza, "Not one of all purple host," which links the highest US military award for those who are injured in battle and the holy wafer used in the holy communion. ...read more.


This is very interesting in regard looking at her as a Confessionalist, as the differing attitudes within the poems could be attributed with a change of perception of the earth as Dickinson got older. Sylvia Plath used her poetry to convey her feelings of despair. This is at its most apparent in her poem Lady Lazarus. In Lady Lazarus, the speaker is developed as a character of religious persecution and Nazi incarceration. She uses extended metaphors and allusion to develop terrifying images of death that surround her attempted suicides. The speaker defines her consecutive attempted suicides and describes her internal conflicts surrounding them. She describes her suicides as a form of entertainment for an onlooking "peanut-crunching crowd," her revival as nothing more than "the big strip tease," a form of entertainment for others. The speaker describes dying as being "an art," yet, suicide is not so simple for her. In this way Plath developed the Confessional genre by creating a "Pop-Confessional" genre, by using her inner thoughts and using them to sell poetry and herself. In lines 65-79 she compares the doctors who helped revive her after an attempted suicide to Nazis giving her life which, the speaker felt, was worse than killing her. She uses metaphors and allusion to develop this theme. The speaker uses apostrophe to address the doctors in her past: "So, so Herr Doktor / So, Herr Enemy." ...read more.


I believe that, for Plath, everything in her life revolved around her getting attention. Her poetry was almost the handbook that accompanied her suicide "shows." I believe that Plath never really wanted to die and thought that her suicide attempts would be constantly foiled. The suicide attempts would allow her to gain more coverage. If Plath, was alive today, the cult status that she has obtained would almost certainly be eradicated. Elmer Andrews is certainly correct when he has argued that, one of the most notable developments in modern American poetry has been the emergence of a "confessional poetry...giving direct expression to the poet's personal life." The confessional style of opening up is one which is beneficial to culture and society as a whole. The most beautiful works are ones, which can touch the soul, and the raw emotion that the genre brings out invokes the emotions of the reader as well as the poet. However, I believe that the two poets above, Dickinson and Plath are very different in their poetry. Dickinson uses her poems like an external think tank where all her thoughts are on an external document. In my opinion, this is pure, unadulterated confessional poetry. This is in stark contrast to Plath's works, which is almost an advertisement to try and get more publicity. Although, Plath's works are important in modern American culture. I believe that the works of Dickinson's works will be far more influential in shaping society and will be of more value to society in the future. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Sylvia Plath section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Sylvia Plath essays

  1. Discuss the presentation of death within Plath's poetry, commenting upon how your view compares ...

    After the initial violent action of the axe cutting the wood, the echoes are set in motion irrevocably. The sap from cutting the wood "wells like tears" and is likened to water attempting to cover rocks. The rock becomes a white skull which is "eaten by weedy greens" under the water.

  2. Frozen Eyes -Explore and analyse the use of imagery of death and violence in ...

    This change gives an optimistic ending to Lady Lazarus, as she also conquers the extremes of a fire, and is able to 'rise' with her 'red hair', where the red implicates being burnt. Thus she survives the torture, taking a new form of life.

  1. An essay on the Comparison of two poems dealing with intense emotions

    You still left me at a young age and that is not right for you to do that to me, and suggests that he is evil for doing so. Her frustration is shown in one of the most emotional and vivid quotations in the poem, 'Chuffing me off like a Jew./ A Jew to Dachau, Aushwitz, Belsen'.

  2. The three poems I have chosen to compare are 'A Parental Ode To My ...

    The school had nothing else against you; The teachers twittered and gave in. So the teachers weren't trying to blame her outburst because of her mother's death but as they say, it would be unfair to. Something that is not like 'A Parental Ode...'

  1. How does Plath's use of extended metaphors and other literary features effect the reader's ...

    She has lost all sense of being a person. She does not have to worry about the unpredictability of life. She is happy with being like this, she likes the calm and tranquillity of the hospital "I am learning peacefulness, lying by myself quietly" This word "learning" this suggest a gradual process of learning how to be totally independent and totally self-centred.

  2. A Trapped Life: The Autobiographical Elements of Sylvia Plath's The Bell Jar.

    As she recovers, she uses the apt analogy of the distorted view of the world seen from within a bell jar to describe her former condition. Esther states near the close of the book 'How did I know that someday-at college, in Europe, somewhere, anywhere-the bell jar, with it's stifling distortions, wouldn't descend again?'

  1. How do Hughes and Hardy both use memory in their poems?

    Ted remembers Sylvia's vivacity, her liveliness. He thinks of her as being so full of life and joy, it must have disturbed him later on when he realised how unhappy she had become. She was bubbly, brimming with happiness because she was to meet Ted Hughes, just like a child waiting for Christmas.

  2. In Sylvia Plaths poem Morning Song, the poet expresses a range of fluctuating emotions ...

    clouds themselves, expressing the idea that motherhood is not a condition of control by the mother; the baby belongs to the world, to itself, to the elements which surround its life in the world. The next stanza structures many verbs and nouns which describe the child and the surrounding to create amazing images.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work