• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Emma vs Clueless. Amy Heckerlings Clueless and Austens Emma both explore the themes of marriage, social class and feminism.

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Angela Ni 11EX4 Transforming Emma into Clueless To what extent has the composer of the contemporary text appropriated the ideas and values contained in the earlier text to say something new? Angela Ni 11EX4 ________________ Transforming Emma into Clueless They may be nearly two hundred years apart, yet Amy Heckerling?s Clueless and Austen?s Emma both explore the themes of marriage, social class and feminism. Amy Heckerling has transformed and appropriated many of the values and ideas evident in Austen?s 1816 novel, Emma. The transformation of the novel allows new ideas to be presented, due to the change in values over the last centuries. Because of the vast contrasting contexts of the two texts, many themes and values present during the Romantic Period were changed to adapt to the social discourse of the 1990?s ? Heckerling?s time period. Contrasting views and ideas are portrayed and influenced by the context in which each text is contained. Marriage, being the social goal of females in Austen?s society, is a convention, which usually allows a gain in property or land, guarantees financial security and respectability in the community. ...read more.


Just as Emma acts against the social expectation of her generation, Cher acts against hers. Tai accuses ?Why should I listen to you anyways? You?re just a virgin who can?t drive!? This statement shows that the loss of one?s virginity and the ability to drive can make someone in the 20th century less authoritative because of their lack of experience. Virginity wasn?t an issue in 19th century Britain as a woman was expected to lose their virginity after their marriage to their husband only. If one did happen to lose their virginity, they wouldn?t be a respected part of society anymore and cast down to the bottom of the social hierarchy because they weren?t pure anymore. Both Emma and Cher choose different ways to rebel against their society, marrying for love and choosing virginity respectively. The social hierarchy in 19th century society was extremely rigid and not only determined by one?s inherited wealth but also their breeding. Emma, the reader learns, is at the top of hers: ?Emma Woodhouse, handsome, rich, clever, with a comfortable home and happy disposition, seemed to unite some of the best blessings in existence; and had lived nearly twenty-one years in the world with very little to distress or vex her?. ...read more.


Feminism is a prominent idea present in both texts. ?Emma? was set in a patriarchal society, and although her father was not a strong patriarchal figure, Mr Knightly instead fills that role. He upholds his place during the Box Hill incident as well as chiding her for her immaturity. In Clueless, Cher is allowed much more personal freedom than Emma, yet within her own household, she is still controlled by her father. Both female protagonists rely on their father for their wealth and social standing. In some ways, Cher can be seen as having less female power than Emma even though she lived in modern society where female have gained more rights. Her father reprimands her for sitting in his chair and for her parking tickets and Josh is her saviour as he rescues her that night in the Valley. Amy Heckerling has appropriated many of the ideas of marriage, social hierarchy and feminism from Jane Austen?s 1816 novel, Emma. The contrast in the context in which the texts were written and produced emphasises that many of the fundamental values and ideas have been left unchallenged by time while other ideas such as homosexuality and multiculturalism have been introduced and accepted. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Jane Austen essays

  1. Jane Austen's presentation of Emma as an unlikeable heroine

    We shall be always meeting!'" Though she is upset about Mrs. Weston's departure, she claims they will see them all the time. She looks for a positive side in a negative situation. She is trying to help her father get over the loss but no-one will help her get over it, despite this she is willing to help others.

  2. Has your perception of transformations been illuminated by your comparative study of Emma and ...

    Knightley when readers have seen that they were suited all along. Also irony is used with the relationship between Mrs Elton and Emma, the very qualities in which Emma dislikes about Mrs Elton are the very qualities she possesses herself.

  1. A comparison between film versions Emma and Clueless

    Settings from both films imply wealth and that both characters are spoilt. The lighting in the film Emma is dull in the interior setting this gives a romantic atmosphere, and makes her look as if she has a smooth complexion, as the main light source are candles, which are subtle and did not show blemishes like modern lighting does.

  2. ‘In what ways is “Pride and Prejudice” a Cinderella story?’

    Evidently their own mother and sisters have some qualities similar to those in "Cinderella." Mrs Bennet, though inadvertently, hinders any marriage between her daughters and 'respectable' men through her inappropriate and embarrassing manner - she is chaotic and thoughtless and gives her family a bad reputation.

  1. Independant Essay - Emma

    We become annoyed at her; and the way that she refuses to acknowledge she might be wrong. Moments such as this in the book significantly influence what the reader thinks of Emma. Our opinion of Emma is formed somewhat by other characters that are present in the book; giving them

  2. Jane Austen's use of Gothic Traditions in Northanger AbbeyThe term 'Gothic' was first really ...

    In classic gothic style, Catherine questions herself: 'An immense heavy chest! What could it hold? Why should it be placed here?' This is an example of Austen's Gothic parodying of the gothic characters and literary style it is, aimed to mock the traditional Gothic heroines who followed this curiosity, usually a feature in all Gothic novels.

  1. From a reading of Jane Austen's short stories what do we learn about women's ...

    Love didn't seem to come into the situation, material objects and money only mattered in a marriage. Marriage was more of a business transaction, where the only thing that mattered was money. Mary is the oldest out of the three sisters, she has been proposed to by a rich middle age man.

  2. The ideas of marriage and the roles of women are very closely linked, compare ...

    The roles of women in that society were to be a respectful wife and daughter in law. They should be seen as a good daughter in law, do all the house chores and help their mother in law in all ways..."she went about her daily chores- fed the cattle, cooked

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work