• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far should Lord and Lady Capulet be held responsible for the final tragedy?

Extracts from this document...


Romeo & Juliet How far should Lord and Lady Capulet be held responsible for the final tragedy? The final tragedy, to which this question refers, is the separation of Romeo and Juliet by death. It is my view that this situation arose out if a number of factors in which Lord and Lady Capulet played a significant role, but by no means were they entirely responsible for the outcome. The Capulet family had been in conflict with the Montage Romeo's family for a long time. The hostility between them seems to colour the attitudes and behaviours of many of the players. In this context it can be argued that the treatment of Romeo by Lord and Lady Capulet was an inevitable result of history and thus the outcome would have been unavoidable, whatever the catalyst was. From the start of the play, the audience knows that the love between Romeo and Juliet is doomed. The Chorus speaks of the two as, 'star-crossed lovers' and their romance as a 'death marked love'. Shakespeare introduces the concept of Fate governing the paths of the characters. Fate is seen to be the ultimate force controlling the actions and motivation of the players and is therefore responsible for the outcome. ...read more.


Lord Capulet verbally attacks the Nurse when she tries to defend Juliet's corner. (Nurse) 'May I not speak?' (Capulet) 'Peace, you mumbling fool!' Without the Nurse able to speak her mind, Juliet is left few people to turn to, as is underlined when she later turns to her for advice on how to deal with her situation. 'I think it best you married with the county' This shows that although she deeply cares for Juliet, Lord Capulet's influence prevails. The audience is left to wonder if Juliet had had the Nurse to consult, the tragic end might have been avoided So far, the influence of Fate has been recognised and with that, a failure of the Capulet's to support and care for Juliet has created the environment for Juliet to choose a bizarre and dangerous solution. The Capulets are mainly guilty of neglecting their daughter; there are many examples of Lord Capulet's behaviour, which made the impending tragedy more likely. Lord Capulet is seen to be uncompromising and expecting of blind allegiance from those around him. For example at the party, which is held at the Capulet residence. Tybalt sees Romeo and wants to make a scene but Capulet stops him. ...read more.


Responsibility for the final tragedy in Romeo and Juliet rests with Fate. However, the audience is left uncertain as to how the actions and motivations of the players may potentially have influenced the ending. It is arguable that the Capulets are merely the tools by which the inevitability of Fate is achieved and so their behaviours are pre-determined. This means that their alienation towards Juliet not only created a background in which she could make self-threatening decisions more easily but also the Capulets may not have had the freedom of choice to behave differently. Fate was in control. Analysis of the direct contributions by the Capulets to the tragedy also suggests that they may have had little choice in their behaviours. Much of Lord Capulet's attitude to Romeo came from years of hostility between the families. The greatest irony of the play is how the two families would find a bond and cease the hostilities through the tragedy. In conclusion, Fate was primarily responsible for the tragedy. Even if Lord and Lady Capulet had the freedom and the will to behave differently the audience is left to believe that a change in such behaviour would not affect the outcome. However, if the Capulet's were indeed 'tools of Fate' they would not have been ultimately and personally responsible for the events. Mike Sims. Year 11 English Coursework. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. How does Shakespeare create a sense of tragedy in the final scene of 'Romeo ...

    Fiend angelical!" Both of these statements are oxymorons, and throughout this speech Juliet uses similar vocabulary. Juliet is lamenting Romeo's beautiful appearance could hide an evil reality when she finds out that he has killed Tybalt. This theme of appearance Vs reality gradually heightens the tragedy of the play because

  2. Romeo and Juliet - The changing relationships between Juliet and her parents, Lord and ...

    not do anything if Juliet doesn't approve of the match, only if she falls in love with Count Paris and agrees herself, will he allow them to marry. Juliet herself first appears in Act 1 Scene 3 with her mother Lady Capulet and the nurse.

  1. Romeo and Juliet - look at the attitude and the behaviour of Lord Capulet, ...

    During Shakespeare time fathers were very different from the fathers nowadays. The setting of the play is in Verona a patriarchal city where the fathers had held absolute sway over they daughters and if their daughters disagreed with them

  2. Romeo and Juliet. Discuss the behaviour of Lord Capulet and consider his attitude, and ...

    Verona, at the time when this play took place was patriarchal city. Fathers hold virtually absolute sway over their daughters. They could give them to whomever they choose and feel deeply insulted if their daughters dare to choose otherwise. Juliet makes that choice and incurs the unmitigated wrath of Capulet:" ......

  1. My assignment will look at the attitude and the behaviour of Lord Capulet in ...

    Lord Capulet did this as he threatened to drag Juliet to the church if she did not go on her own will, "I will drag thee on a hurdle hither." Another difference between then and now is that when girls get married They are usually above 18 but during the

  2. Romeo & Juliet - Lady Capulet

    It sounds as if she is delivering a message. She has her hands on the bed knelling right next to Juliet's bed. This is the point when Juliet stops crying and looks up at Lady Capulet. This is when Juliet throws her tantrum. She is completely shocked and appalled at what her mother has just told her.

  1. Who is responsible for the final tragedy in romeo and juliet

    scene had not occurred then Juliet would not have proposed, but you cannot be certain that if they had met again then the story might have been different, because they have only just met. Knowing that both their families would never agree and be happy to this relationship Juliet proposes to Romeo, and he accepts.

  2. Jonathan Tindall10x1 Final Draft

    For Shakespearean times I would cast an actor of the same features apart from I would cast an uglier actor. This is so that the actor's looks matches the evil thing's Tybalt says and does. This is more likely to help the audience know that this character is one to boo.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work