• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Images of London in ‘A Christmas Carol’ by Charles Dickens, and a ‘Kiss Miss Carol’ by Farrukh Dhondy

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Wider Reading Coursework London is a vast city, with people of various religions, cultures, traditions and backgrounds. It is a city, which allows people to have freedom and choice. London is the commercial centre of Great Britain with diverse institutions. It is also famous for tourism; millions of people come to London to experience what it can offer. It has many famous historical buildings, botanical gardens, and great landmarks, which are an essential when visiting London. It is an honoured country to be proud of. We studied and analysed two stories. 'A Christmas Carol' by Charles Dickens, and a 'Kiss Miss Carol' by Farrukh Dhondy. Both stories portray disadvantage. A Christmas Carol is about a man called Scrooge who has a mean character and see's no good in life, he never makes the best out of things. He hates poor people and thinks that Christmas is a 'humbug'. 'A Kiss Miss Carol' is about a young Bangladeshi boy named Jolil whose life is in monopoly control of his father. He has no free will whatsoever. Jolil is overwhelmed to be included in a Christmas play at school, but realises that his parents are not ready to support him. The poverty in London from the story 'A Christmas carol' is described through depressing gloomy language. Dickens brings the settings to life by using adjectives like 'cold' 'bleak' 'dingy'. These words give a poor effect to the climate, and make it seem dull and lifeless. Dickens describes houses using boring colours like 'black'. He contrasts the black lifeless colours with the 'white' sheet of snow so that the bleak depressing colours stand out more. These lifeless colours, make the atmosphere feel unhealthy, Dickens varies his sentence length for great effect and breaks them up by the use of colons and commas. His choice of words such as 'dirtier' and 'dingy mist' make the climate seem crowded and filthy. ...read more.

Middle

Mr Miah is fuming to find his son is due to act as a beggar boy in a Christmas play at school, and so refuses to let him go. He has to work hard to escape poverty within his family, and doesn't find it appropriate if his son will expose his poverty through a Christmas play. Mr Miah has absolute control over his family; he acts like an overall dictator of his family, having monopoly control over other people's lives. 'You'll do exactly as I say' Here Mr Miah is giving more of a direct command, rather than an option to Khalil as to whether he wants to go Bangladesh or not. The author, Farrukh Dhondy has portrayed Mr Miah in a demanding way. He has an oppressive character, yet his family is generally submissive towards his behaviour, leaving his oppression unchallenged, thereby allowing it to grow. Mr Miah is submerged into his religious, traditional, and cultural values. "He turned up in his prayer cap". This shows Mr Miah is a respectable Muslim and still abides by the Sunnah of the Islamic religion. He is hoping to influence his children to be loyal to the Islamic religion, but this is not shared by his sons. Scrooge and Mr Miah are similar in many ways, but they also differ from each other. Both men are hardworking and committed to their jobs, however Scrooge gets paid a vast amount of money, and only has himself to consider, whereas Mr Miah is put into slave labour, gets low wages, and has to support his whole family. Both Scrooge and Mr Miah are keen to save up their money. However, Scrooge has the potential to live like a King, and certainly never spends his money on luxuries. Mr Miah on the other hand, cannot afford to spend on luxurious items, and needs to save up as much money as possible to run his household. ...read more.

Conclusion

As when Dickens communicates he shows us an insight into the character as he uses the dialogue to show their feelings. The kind of humour, which Dickens uses, is facetious. The characters that are presented are described about their physical features first then Dickens opens the characters feelings up during the story with dialogue. Dickens uses a large amount of descriptions and he uses several amount of vocabulary. This book was written for a particular audience in the Victorian era, which was high class, educated people. Many rich people would have read this novel and would have also been able to thoroughly understand it. I feel that Dickens uses a lot of description in his writing, and seems to pile it on a bit too much. The language is complex as it was meant for people from the eighteenth century. This book was hard to read as some of the English used is complex and hard to understand, as being a 21st century reader, most of the English used is totally different compared to 18th century English. The long sentences and prolonged descriptions were hard to comprehend, as they were composed of some phrases, which I have not come across before. Farrukh Dhondy has a completely different writing style to Dickens. Unlike Dickens, Farrukh does not use lengthy descriptions; his text is easier to understand. Farrukh writes about real life situations, whereas Dickens has a more imaginative mind, he writes about situations which nobody has ever arised before. Then again, both writers want to get different responses from their audience. Farrukh wants his audience to be aware of situations of the like which were faced by Jolil, and hope it can make a difference to anybody suffering the same situation, whereas Dickens wants everybody to appreciate Christmas, despite of whether they are rich or poor, as wealth doesn't implicate money, but also gratitude, love, obedience, and moral values. Alternatively, poverty doesn't just have financial implications. Poverty can also be shown by terms of lacking gratitude, love, obedience, and moral values. By Lubna Khatri 11RK ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE A Christmas Carol section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE A Christmas Carol essays

  1. How Does Dickens Portray Poverty In A Christmas Carol.

    The poor law was the only way of collecting money for the poor, and this tax was so very little that it hardly helped any of the poor or needy. The first ghost Scrooge is haunted by is that of his old business partner Jacob Marley.

  2. Explore how Dickens makes his readers aware of poverty in A Christmas Carol.

    From the girl's description of being in a mourning dress the reader is quickly aware that the girl is sad. The girl informs Scrooge that "another idol has displaced me." and that there is now something more important than her in Scrooge's life.

  1. Dickens’ A Christmas Carol and Priestley’s An Inspector Calls have strong messages for the ...

    You never did. You never even tried." She and her husband however are less remorseful, Birling in particular as he refuses to take any responsibility for Eva Smith's death and seems to be more concerned about the money Eric stole from him than Eric's treatment to Eva Smith.

  2. A Christmas carol by Charles Dickens-what do we learn about the conditions of the ...

    Charles Dickens is almost trying to compare Scrooge with an ice block since he says his features are frozen and describes him as 'blue' which is the description of an ice block. Moreover, Charles Dickens wants us to realise that Scrooge takes his cold personality with him everywhere he goes

  1. The novel 'A Christmas Carol', by Charles

    The references to the weather make us think of what kind of person he is, and the different moods he might have. All the weather references are of bad weather, painting a bad first picture of Scrooge and where he lives, and the differences in conditions in Victorian times.

  2. How effectively has charles dickens managed to portray a range of different attitudes through ...

    However the amount of time spent at work would obviously take a toll and family life would deteriorate so Sundays were kept very special as a time to chill once a week and just to spend time with family and friends.

  1. What do you see as Dickens' social aims in 'A Christmas Carol' and how ...

    Dickens introduces Tiny Tim to add yet more sympathy for the Cratchits, showing just how difficult life is for the poor, but they can still be happy. Dickens uses the conversation that the Cratchits have about Scrooge again to frighten the reader, showing that if they do not give out love and kindness, then they will receive none.

  2. An essay on A Christmas Carol. I will discuss how Dickens uses different language ...

    This is the first point in the story where Scrooge is showing lots of different emotions, which contrasts with his cold and careless attitude before the spirits arrive. The spirit says that the school is not quite empty and that there is ?a solitary school child, neglected by his friend?s?.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work