In the concluding scene of Macbeth, Malcolm refers to Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as "This dead butcher and his fiend - like queen." To what extent do you agree with this statement?

Authors Avatar

Macbeth                        

Emma Rubakumar

In the concluding scene of Macbeth, Malcolm refers to Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as “This dead butcher and his fiend – like queen.”

To what extent do you agree with this statement?

Malcolm is someone who, understandably, has a great hatred towards Macbeth and his wife because he hears rumours about their deeds, making him utter this quote. He is told that they may have possibly killed his father, King Duncan. The words used by the Prince of Cumberland are said at the end of the play when being crowned the new King of Scotland after the death of Macbeth.    

The quote uses very strong language such as, “dead butcher” and “fiend-like”. These words have strong meaning and this will be soon discovered.

Malcolm relates a butcher, someone who kills unthinkingly and ruthlessly, to Macbeth. However, Macbeth was not always condemned when committing a murder. At the very beginning of the play, he is applauded for being so brave in battle and for acting the way he did. Macbeth becomes increasingly violent through the play and commits more and more murders as it progresses. He kills not only King Duncan, but later on he appoints people to murder Banquo and he also kills Macduff’s wife and all his “pretty ones”. This implies he has the blood of others on his conscience, but it does not seem to bother him very much, similar to a butcher. However, we know that there is far more to Macbeth than just being a butcher as he shows the audience that he is more aware of the situation than Lady Macbeth. Although he reveals he has a large imagination, guilt and rationalism are also exposed through his character. Lady Macbeth seems to have quite a lot of control over Macbeth, and whenever she has to try and stop him from over – reacting, she appeals to his manhood. Lady Macbeth describes him as “too full o’ the milk of human-kindness” which is extraordinary when you consider the murders he has committed. He also seems as though he has a firm grip on the witches, which shows even more awareness. The audience feel they have to sympathise with Macbeth because he needs the external help from the witches to perform these evil deeds and acts of torture.

Join now!

His guilt and conscience are emphasised greatly when he appears to imagine a dagger floating and leading him to the bedroom in which King Duncan lay asleep before he was murdered and at the banquet he sees the ghost of Banquo. This proves that Macbeth has a guilty conscience that worries him. It is Lady Macbeth that rescues him from these hallucinations, appealing to his manhood once again.

When Macbeth hears that Macduff has gone to England to find and help Malcolm, this infuriates him and he orders people to go and murder Macduff’s family. The reason ...

This is a preview of the whole essay