• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In this essay I will be discussing whom was/were responsible for the suicide of Daisy Renton/ Eva smith in JB Priestly's "An Inspector Calls". I will discuss each character in turn and their involvement if any in the death of Eva Smith.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

An Inspector Calls Who was to blame? In this essay I will be discussing whom was/were responsible for the suicide of Daisy Renton/ Eva smith in JB Priestly's "An Inspector Calls". I will discuss each character in turn and their involvement if any in the death of Eva Smith. Although each member of the Birling family and Gerald Croft have had contact with Eva Smith/Daisy Renton during the previous two years, none of them is aware of the others� involvement in the tragedy until the day of the inspector's visit. He makes them aware of the part they have played in her tragic end. The characters each react differently to the news and to the degree of responsibility, which they should bear. The first person to have contact with Eva was Arthur Birling. Mr Birling and the rest of his family are quite rich and would be part of the upper class. The first indication you get of this (apart from the description of the house at the beginning of the play) is the phrase from Mr Birling "tell cook from me", back in 1912 and indeed in modern times anyone who employed a cook would be quite "well off" and of a high social standing. Mr Birling is quite an arrogant and pompous man, probably because of his wealth and social standing. The phrase spoken by Birling in act 1 "I'm talking as a hard headed businessman" is a good indication of this arrogance. Another phrase, which is spoken by Birling also in Act 1 "working together for lower costs and higher prices", tells us that Birling cares more about profits than people, the phrase is also another indication of Birling's arrogance. Birling is quite social and seems to be the centre of conversation among his family and Gerald. He maintains a relaxed disposition and there is no indication of a bad temper when in this atmosphere. ...read more.

Middle

He took her for a drink and a meal because he pitied her and he learnt she was desperate and so let her use his friend's room. She then became his mistress and they were together for the whole summer of 1911. He finished with her and cast her aside because of his relationship with Sheila Birling. Gerald, throughout the play comes across in a way as a young Mr Birling. He constantly agrees with Mr Birling about The way business should be run, he also backed Birling up during his interrogation and agrees with Birlings actions towards Eva. I think Gerald's character is quite a vague one compared with the other characters. I can't really describe his character too well as he does not Seem to own many levels of personality or character. I do know however that Gerald is of a high social standing mainly because of his attitude to the lower class labourers and the mention of his father's profit making business. Gerald probably saw Eva as a lonely and desperate girl, and owing to the fact she was very pretty probably saw her as a good target for sex. The Phrase used by Gerald to describe their relationship, "I didn't feel about her as she felt about me" is why I believe Gerald just wanted Eva for sexual reasons, Eva however obviously wanted a real relationship with Gerald but did not get it. Even though Eva took the news of the break-up very well ("she was very gallant about it" in Gerald's words) I do believe this was a front and Eva was probably very upset about the break up. I believe this because Gerald did say, "she'd been happier than she was ever before". Being rejected by Gerald was probably more hurtful to Daisy than the dismissals inflicted on her by Arthur and Sheila Birling because there were strong emotions involved. ...read more.

Conclusion

By making her pregnant he put her in an unbearable position and is very much to blame for her downfall. The only two things in his favour were that he was sorry for what he had done and he tried to help her financially but these came too late for Eva. In my opinion Sybil Birling is the most to blame because she knew Eva was genuinely in need but still turned her away in a callous fashion. As the inspector tells her, "You refused her even the pitiable little bit of organised charity you had in your power to grant her". It is Sybil's uncaring attitude that makes her actions seem even worse. She adamantly refuses to accept any blame and although she is shocked by Eric's involvement she never shows any genuine remorse. In fact she believes she behaved correctly and "did my duty" in turning away an undeserving claim. She is typical of the sort of women involved in philanthropic societies at the time. Priestly criticises them for sitting on committees merely to ease their own consciences rather than out of a genuine desire to help. Although for this essay I had to choose which character carried the most blame I was not choosing who was legally wrong. I don't believe whether in the 1900's or in modern times that any character in the book would have been convicted for any kind of charge whether manslaughter or murder. Throughout the book I was constantly perplexed to why the Birlings and Gerald worried about being convicted. The use of an inspector instead of another form of character by Priestly puzzles me as the actions carried out by the characters in the book were purely of an ethical position than a legal one. Maybe priestly could not think of another type of character that could get almost blind obedience and submission from the Birling's and Gerald I don't know, but I do believe another form of a character is needed to be someone who wants to ethically blame instead of legally. Tom Westerman Leytonstone school 13411 8202 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE J.B. Priestley section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE J.B. Priestley essays

  1. An Inspector Calls - Who is responsible for the death of Eva Smith?

    Also, Birling does not do anything illegal although it seems morally wrong to the audience and some of the other characters, he thought - at the time if not now - that what he did was the right course of action to take.

  2. To what extent can Gerald Croft be held responsible for for the death of ...

    cleverly introduces, the audience can see how upset Gerald is when he is telling the story.

  1. Do you agree that Eva Smith is presented as a victimin the play 'An ...

    Mr Birling however shows no sympathy for Eva Smith. He seems much more concerned with his works and the financial side of it, rather than the welfare of his employees. Eva Smith was sacked because she was one of the ringleaders in a group of workers wanting a pay rise.

  2. How does J.B. Priestley use Eva Smith/ Daisy Renton as a dramatic device in ...

    name like hers' and so she wonders to herself whether she should be more kind and not worry about other peoples opinions. Sheila is envy and wrath as she is angry with Miss Daisy Renton for laughing at her and jealous as the young girl is naturally more attractive than

  1. Compare and contrast the characters of Sheila Birling and Eva Smith in J.B. Priestley's ...

    "Both her parents were dead." This informs us on her background. This means that Eva probably feels a great sadness for her parents and she probably learned how to stick up for herself quite early in life. Eva's lifestyle is completely contrasting to that of Sheila's.

  2. Extracts from the diary of Eva Smith.

    He was drunk and I really didn't know what he would do so I thought that I could just ask him, nicely, to go away. He, however, would have none of it and started turning rather nasty and threatened to make a scene if I didn't let him in.

  1. Which character was responsible for the death of Eva Smith / Daisy Renton / ...

    She therefore decided in a callous manner, to deny the girl the charitable services the organisation stood for. He is also eager to obtain a knighthood, a goal, well within his reach, as he said to Gerald, 'so long as we behave ourselves.

  2. Who was most to blame for the Death of Eva Smith?

    He also shows this when speaking of the future, ?Nobody wants war, except some half-civilized folks from the Balkans.? I think that this not only shows that Mr. Birling feels that he knows everything, because less than a decade later there was in fact a war with many people fighting,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work