• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Desdemona a figure of weakness or strength? Discuss with relation to one key scene. Shakespeares' Othello.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is Desdemona a figure of weakness or strength? Discuss with relation to one key scene. Shakespeare has portrayed Desdemona to have both weaknesses and strengths that make her personality appear normal. Desdemona does seem to be an all rounded person however it is her weaknesses, which brings about her downfall. Desdemona shows blatant signs throughout the whole play that she fails to realise she is being manipulated by the main vice character Iago. Another weakness which can come to view is Desdemona's tendency to poke her nose into Othello's public life, which is unnatural for a woman to do in the Elizabethan era. Desdemona also shows weakness in allowing men to mistreat her; in the beginning of Othello, her father disowns her, Iago uses Desdemona for his own revenge throughout the whole play, and then Othello who ignores and silences her for innocently protesting to reinstate Cassio. Despite all of these weaknesses, her strengths do shine through her actions and words. Desdemona does show courage to repel against her father when he objects to her love for Othello, and there is a repetition of this repelling against Othello later in the play. Desdemona does also show the renaissance side of her personality, by trying to break free from the patriarchal society, and critics would argue why should she not speak her mind, however some other critics such as feminist Jardine would disagree. ...read more.

Middle

This is an example of a weakness; she does not think her action through. Another weakness Desdemona faces is the mistreatment of men. This is one aspect of her which has been repeated throughout the play, and which could to an extent mirror the insufficiency of her intelligence. In act one, Desdemona's father, Brabantio could not accept the truth that his "jewel" eloped with the Moor. Once he was proven wrong, he rejected his "jewel." Shakespeare compares Desdemona to a jewel because jewels are considered precious, and precious is what Desdemona was to Brabantio, so to reject her is a harsh move. However Desdemona marrying against her father's will is contradicting the innocent comments he made about his daughter, also Desdemona's actions are seen to be disobedient and it is something that is not common in a patriarchal society. Desdemona does defend herself and tries to justify her actions, but the audience is given the insight that she acted on impulse, and perhaps she did not think her actions through thoroughly resulting in her rejection. Desdemona fails to see Iago is using her, and it is through him her troubles thicken. She is playing into Iago's plot to make Othello's "jealousy so strong/That judgement cannot cure." ...read more.

Conclusion

Desdemona does not accept female degrading comments. You could decide to look at Desdemona's situation from a Structuralist perspective. Society is following patriarchal norms and values, however Desdemona could be seen as a renaissance character, thus it is society, which conforms her to resists against the Elizabethan society by speaking her mind and becoming an independent wife. The independence again mirrors Jardine's thoughts on Desdemona. As a feminist she believes Desdemona is too independent for an Elizabethan wife, how from a modern day opinion, a woman's independence is seen to be a great strength and quality which is highly valued. By weighing up Desdemona's weaknesses and strengths, it appears she is a figure of weakness. However the majority of her weaknesses appears because of surrounding characters, which funnily enough happen to be the men in her life. She allows men to mistreat her without her even consciously realising it, and it is Iago who cunningly manipulates her. But on the other side of the coin it can be said that she has been put in the situations, and it is for the audience to assess and witness her reactions. Desdemona's strengths are not right for the patriarchal society; her strengths are better off in a modern day society, which is why some would argue Desdemona is a figure of renaissance thinking. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Othello section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Othello essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Explore Shakespeare's presentation of jealousy in 'Othello'

    4 star(s)

    The handkerchiefs meaning changed throughout the play, initially Othello gives the handkerchief to Desdemona as a token of their love its ironic that it's the handkerchief that eventually destroys their love. Something so small and insignificant turns out to be the downfall of Othello and Desdemona.

  2. Peer reviewed

    Appearances and assumptions in Shakespeare's Othello

    3 star(s)

    It was due to his reputation that people accepted his relationship with Desdamonaiant Moor." O assumptions in Othelloy are vital as . It was only when Iago started putting thoughts in Othello's head about Cassio and Desdemona being together did we see the other side of Othello's personality begin to surface.

  1. How Does Shakespeare Present Desdemona in Acts One to Four

    This would suggest that not only has Iago got grudges against Othello, but Desdemona as well because she has never done anything wrong to Iago, yet he still wants to seek his revenge on her. This also makes the audience continue to conspire as it brings up the question, of has Desdemona done anything to upset Iago in the past.

  2. "Othello and Desdemona's marriage doesn't stand a chance." Discuss.

    Iago tries to touch on Brabantios status and makes an effort to rub in the public humiliation he will face, shown by the quote "Zounds sir, y'are robbed! For shame put on your gown" (1.1.84), but it is known that he loved his daughter a lot and I think that

  1. In Which way does Iago manipulate characters and contribute To their downfall in Shakespeare's ...

    Iago talks with Desdemona about his wife Emilia in her presence. 'She puts her tongue a little in her heart and chides with thinking.' Desdemona doesn't hesitate to protect her friend Emilia 'O fie upon thee, slanderer!' This is dramatic irony, because although Desdemona sticks up for Emilia, later on

  2. How do you react to Shakespeare's presentation of Desdemona, in Act 5 Scene 2, ...

    It is no ordinary handkerchief; it had been especially as it was made with rare silk and more. Also it was a wedding gift it is a symbol of there love. She does not want him to worry or to get up set so she lies about where it is.

  1. How do the different critical readings of the play inform our understanding of the ...

    Factors not considered by this approach are that the manipulation done by Iago also made Othello believe that Desdemona had cheated on him. If Iago hadn't said anything, Othello wouldn't have suspected his wife. Shakespeare's view of society, civilisation or the renaissance for this critical viewpoint was that women were

  2. Rebecca as Desdemona

    . the nature / Whom passion could not shake?" Ludovico wonders (4.1.275-76). Of course, since the tragedy of Othello precedes the popular fiction of Rebecca by more than 300 years, it is only through retrospect that those elements defined as "Gothic" can be applied to Shakespeare's play.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work