Macbeth : Act III scene III

Authors Avatar
In Shakespeare's Macbeth, Act III scene III, the scene is that of a murder with three guilty parties, one having been unexpected by the initial two. It is clear that the first two were lowly murderers recently hired by Macbeth, but the mysterious third is somewhat of an enigma, his identity having never been concluded upon. Evidence shows that it couldn't have been Macbeth, seeing as how the unnamed was asked by the first murderer "But who did bid thee join with us?" had it been Macbeth then anyone in their right mind would have known that he had come on his own accord. Also obviously exempt from suspicion is Lady Macbeth, her being emotionally distraught at the time, besides the fact that the plot against Banquo's life was completely unbeknownst to her, is more than enough to prove without a doubt that she was not involved in this most fatal affair. However there are others to consider, such as Ozzy Osborne and Woody Allen, the latter of which does have a knack for getting himself into slightly precarious situations, which has landed him into many an imbroglio. Although I conjecturally considered him as the unrevealed murderer, upon second analysis I found that this was in fact profoundly dubitable. For one thing, his ridiculously comical antics and characteristic tendencies indicate that Woody most likely would have stammered and stuttered, eventually bungled in holding the knife, let it fumble to the ground, and took to the medieval hills. The most convincing contradiction to Allen's presence in scene III is the fact that he is not fluent in Elizabethan English, and had he been murderer #3, instead of exclaiming "'Tis he." In line 25 of act 3, his proclamation would have been more along the lines of "Holy Bejesus, it's him!" Now as for Ozzy Osborne, I believe that he wouldn't have been so unceremonious as to simply stab Banquo. Rather, as his hit "Black Sabbath" implies, he would have been inclined to feel that an abduction and sacrifice were in order, yet this did not occur.
Join now!


Allen and Osborne now eliminated, there is really only one person left who could be designated as the third murderer, and that would be Macbeth's servant Seyton. T%he first indication that led me to consider Seyton as the third murderer was the unpremeditated-ness of the third murderer's presence, made apparent by the 1st murderer's inquiring "But who did bid thee join with us?" When he had answered "Macbeth", I set myself to wondering whom I would have called upon, being in Macbeth's position, had I wanted a trustworthy man to do my spontaneous bidding. Well whom better than ...

This is a preview of the whole essay