• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Malachi's Cove and Flight, are about two young ladies growing up but in different times and places. Both asserting their independence and developing relationships with young men. Malachi's Cove is set in mid-nineteenth century and Flight in the 1950s.

Extracts from this document...


Wide Reading: GSCE Coursework Both of the stories, Malachi's Cove and Flight, are about two young ladies growing up but in different times and places. Both asserting their independence and developing relationships with young men. Malachi's Cove is set in mid-nineteenth century and Flight in the 1950s. The authors' outlook on these stories express many differences. Anthony Trollope (Malachi's Cove) was a male author, he wrote his story when women were expected to find satisfaction in getting married to a man whom might not love and having their children. This left them dependent on men. This of course was in the Victorian period. Doris Lessing wrote her story when women like herself were becoming incredibly frustrated by the restrictions if their familial responsibilities. One of Doris Lessing's best-known novels The Golden Notebook (1962) was esteemed as an important manifestation of feminist ideas. Doris may have been showing her views from when she was younger when she went to a Catholic convent school but then left at the age of 14. She also joined the Communist party in 1949. This may explain the reason why she wrote this story, to express her beliefs on women's rights and feelings. At the time Trollope wrote his story women were expected to take certain duties onboard. He's written about a girl who is going against all of the ideals of Victorian women. A stereotypical view of one of these women was to be paled faced and have a 'delicate constitution'. ...read more.


But when she rescues him she sees him as beautiful. This is when she changes her attitude towards him because she realises he has feelings and willingly surrenders her freedom. Alice is a typical 1950s woman who wants to marry and have children to look after, unlike Mally who doesn't want any of this. Alice gets along well with her grandfather like Mally does, but Alice's grandfather doesn't want her to leave home whereas Old Glos wouldn't mind Mally getting married because he would get a nicer house and some security, which he got. Alice and Steven were in a playful relationship of young love and Steven had won Alice's love, and stole it from her grandfather. Whereas Barty had to earn his love and thought of Mally as a challenge that had to be won, and was. Alice at the start was all for marriage and being dependant on Steven but seeing her grandfather with his pigeons made her change her mind because she would have to be locked away and do whatever Steven wanted her to do like the birds to their master. Mally made it clear at the beginning that she didn't want anything to do with marriage and wanted to keep her independence. But then she sees a man in a different light and thinks about the security she would have if she married Barty. Mally is very protective of her grandfather, because he was old and couldn't do much. She was possessive of her cove and her seaweed, because if anyone entered the cove they were entering Mally, and if anyone took any seaweed they were taking a bit of Mally's independence. ...read more.


There seems to be a suggestion that Alice is sad at the realisation that marriage will involve a loss of freedom. This ending completely supports Lessing's ideas about women's rights in the 1950s. This would have appealed to women who were fed up with being a housewife and maybe wanted a bit more in life. I am disappointed by the ending of Malachi's Cove because there's not that much lead up to Mally changing her mind and she doesn't really think about losing her independence. She just collapsed when someone pushed her; she didn't stick up for her rights or beliefs. Barty could've been manlier and Mally could've put up more of a challenge. These days stories have a lot more sexual activities and usual the women are more emotional and it doesn't always ending happily. I liked Flight because it showed a lot of emotion and what relationships can be like. It also hinted at the end that Alice wasn't too happy about getting married now, which showed that women do have a choice and they're not just there to do the cleaning and washing up. I think it could've been made a little bit longer and during a longer space of time, as it all happened in just one afternoon. I think people may like this story but I think it should have a bit more emotion in it and maybe some notes on what Steven and Alice did when they went to get the grandfather the bird. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Harold Brighouse section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Harold Brighouse essays

  1. Hobson's Choice Summary

    Whereas Hobson saw marriage as slavery, it brings freedom to Will and Maggie. Their relationship becomes one based upon genuine affection. Equality Hobson is seen as a bullying parent and a bullying employer. He intends to 'choose a pair of husbands' for Alice and Vickey and doesn't like the way they dress.

  2. Hobson's Choice

    "Yeh," was the response I got, along with a nod of the head before Kim turned and walked towards the building. I hung back, thinking. I knew what a life Kim had had when she was a kid. Everybody agrees that no-one should have to go through that, but I

  1. hobson's choiceStudying the Victorian period from Hobson's choice, I rewrote a section of the ...

    Indian this is because, in my point of view, I think their culture relates more to the Victorian culture. Also because the population in the U.A.E. is about 2, 4000,000. The majority of the population are foreigners, and many of the population living in Dubai are Indians.

  2. Hobson's Choice by Harold Brighouse.

    Audiences of the past and present would furthermore laugh at Mrs Hepworth's reply in which she says, "Get up Hobson. You look ridiculous on the floor". For audiences this would be humorous because it makes light of Hobson's actions. Hobson makes more of a fool of himself when Mrs Hepworth asks, "Who made these boots?"

  1. In Hobson's Choice, how does Harold Brighouse make the audience aware of the changes ...

    Willie may have had a "brutalized childhood" in the sense that he was treated brutally and violently by his family and he may even have been beaten by employers, possibly Hobson. Even though Mrs Hepworth did not strike him, Willie was accepting she would, he did not retaliate, allowing the audience to see he is a good-tempered, non-violent person.

  2. Hobson’s Choice is not only a comedy but it also deals with historical, social ...

    This is clear evidence of Hobson's xenophobic attitude and his pertinent comments. He believes that only the British Constitution is correct and that all others are inferior. Another example of this attitude can be found in act four when the doctor consults Hobson: DOCTOR (Page 65): I'll tell you nothing, sir.

  1. What do you think of Maggie Hobson in the first act and how does ...

    I think that Albert is scared of Mr. Hobson and so wants to get out of the shop, so goes along with what Maggie wants him to do instead of arguing. Maggie does have a good side though. The things that she does are for other people's good.

  2. At the end of the play “Hobson’s choice” Maggie says to Will, “You’re the ...

    "Read it." "I'm trying." Here we find out that Willie is illiterate. He has trouble reading basic letters, but Mrs Hepworth's card is in italics and so Willie has even more trouble reading. Once again, this shows us what Willies character is like.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work