• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Malcolm refers to Macbeth as ‘The Butcher.’ To what extent do you agree with this description of him?

Extracts from this document...


Jodie Booth 10P Malcolm refers to Macbeth as 'The Butcher.' To what extent do you agree with this description of him? In the play 'Macbeth' we are told that Macbeth is a 'butcher'. There is numerous references which agree with this throughout the play. There are, however, references proving that Macbeth is not all as butcher like as we are first led to believe. Many people may agree fully with this description, whereas others may have a different view on Macbeth's character. Here we will explore two different images of Macbeth to build a conclusion based on references from the play. From looking at 'Macbeth' we know that Macbeth kills without thinking. We can relate this to a butcher slaughtering his animals. Neither man thinks about the killing, as it is a way of their life. We have evidence that he kills without thinking; "The very firstlings of my heart shall be the firstlings of my hand" From this we are told that Macbeth also regrets not killing Macduff an is making a decision for his future after learning from the past. ...read more.


Macbeth's speech, shown above tells the audience that there are to be more killings, just like a butcher continues to kill his animals. Macbeth's first murder as a result of selfish reasons was that of Duncan. A phrase that strongly suggests that Macbeth is not proud of the killing is; 'for them the gracious Duncan have I murdered, put rancours in the vessel of my peace.' From the above phrase, we are told that Macbeth killed a gracious man and therefore deserves to have bitterness replacing his peace, maybe in his heart. Before the death of Duncan, Macbeth wanted Duncan dead but once he has been killed he soon regrets it. Early on in the play we are shown that Macbeth's intentions were to kill Duncan. A soliloquy shows this; 'Is this a dagger I see before me, the handle towards my hand?' Here we are told that Macbeth is having visions of a dagger in front of him, pointing towards Duncan's room. This shows us that his mind is full of killing. There is an image of torment and Macbeth can't resist the temptation. ...read more.


We are told that Macbeth's 'Fears in Banquo stick deep'. He therefore decided to murder him so he has nothing left to fear in. A butcher does the entire killing and slaughtering himself but this in not continually apparent with Macbeth. As we are shown later on in the play, Macbeth does not commit all of the murders, the killing of Banquo was performed by others. These others were two men who Macbeth quickly turned against Banquo. This gave them the incentive to kill. After looking at the evidence I feel that the description of Macbeth being 'a butcher' is agreeable. One reason for this decision is that there is more evidence. Macbeth is a butcher mainly because of the way he killed Duncan- by stabbing him with daggers. This is the way a butcher would kill his animals- with knives. However, Macbeth tries to hide the evidence that proves Macbeth killed Duncan by laying the daggers next to the guards. This would begin to persuade me to disagree with the statement, however I still feel that the evidence disagreeing with the statement is not strong enough to persuade me, and make me believe that Macbeth is not a butcher. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. Malcolm refers to Macbeth as "this butcher". To what extent do you agree with ...

    The greatest is behind." The referral to the "greatest" being yet to come gives a sense that Macbeth now believes in what the witches told him and now expects it to happen. Also given is an inkling that Macbeth may be beginning to plot the starts of terrible deeds.

  2. At the end of Macbeth, Malcolm refers to Macbeth as ‘this dead butcher’ and ...

    nature' Her mind begins to conjure evil deeds, ways to speed up the process that will have her crowned. We see the true extent of this in the following line: 'Unsex me here, make thick my blood, take my milk for gall.'

  1. Macbeth - A butcher, a savage slaughterer

    Just before the murder of Duncan, Lady Macbeth changes her mind and tries to prevent Macbeth from commiting the murder, but even his own arguement cannot sway the passage of events which he will take place in. On the otherhand Malcolm does have a reason to insult the dead Macbeth.

  2. Is the term ‘a dead butcher’ an adequate description of Macbeth’s character?

    The fact that Macbeth is linked to the witches at the very beginning as he repeats the words 'fair and foul and day', immediately suggests that something sinister will happen to Macbeth. His vivid imagination contributes greatly to the murder of Duncan, Macbeth believes he must follow an 'air drawn

  1. Macbeth - Hero to butcher

    When Lady Macbeth has returned from placing the daggers near Duncan's attendants and hears the knocking at the gate, she almost has to push Macbeth into their bedroom so that they will look as though they have just been awakened.

  2. This dead butcher- to what extent do you regard this description of Macbeth to ...

    With this mind set it is hard to see Macbeth as a ?butcher? in this point of the play. We also have respect for Macbeth when he tells Lady Macbeth, ?We will proceed no further in this business? it shows the traits in Macbeth that were so apparent in Macbeth

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work