Poetry from other cultures

Authors Avatar

Poetry from other cultures

Compare and contrast the notions of culture and identify in ‘Half-caste’ by John Agard and ‘Presents from my Aunts in Pakistan’ by Moniza Alvi.

The poems I have chosen to analyse are ‘Half-Caste’ by John Agard and ‘Presents from my aunts in Pakistan’ by Moniza Alvi. I have decided to focus on these poems because I believe they project strong messages and discuss the issues of identities and mixed race.

   Furthermore, both poems are autobiographical and the poets are from different cultures to each other. As readers, it is very interesting to understand their different views about mixed race backgrounds as we are from a different culture to them.

   John Agard is a respected Caribbean poet who has won the Paul Hamlyn Award in 1997. On the other hand, Moniza Alvi was born in Pakistan and has achieved the Poetry Business Prize in 1991. Both poets confess the difficulties of living in different cultures and not knowing their fixed nationality.

John Agard was born on 21 June 1949 in Guyana. His mother was white and Portuguese but his father was a black Englishman, therefore making him half-caste. He began to write poems at the age of sixteen and many were published in the school magazine. In the 1970’s he moved to England where he not only progressed to become a literary poet but also moved on to develop into a performing poet. From there, he has travelled significantly performing his consequential poetry.

Join now!

   In his poem ‘Half-Caste’, Agard has accepted the fact that he is half-caste but he is very concerned about the term. He uses various everyday objects and famous people to aid him in giving his views about the term.

   ‘Half-Caste’ is an interesting title to use. It is a one word phrase, short and simple. What is more, it is direct and refers to what the poem is going to be related to.

   Agard begins the poem by capturing our attention and describing the image of a half-caste person.

‘Excuse me

standing on one leg

I’m half-caste’

...

This is a preview of the whole essay

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

Avatar

*** This essay shows some detailed language of analysis and uses terminology appropriately and accurately. There needs to be more discussion and analysis of the fact the poem is written in dialect. Discussion of rhyme, structure and dialect need to be at the beginning of the essay. At times the student seems to be confused or does not clearly explain how satirical the poet is being futher compounded by the fact that the student uses the phrase 'half caste' to describe a person of dual heritage.