• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Romeo and Juliet

Extracts from this document...


How does Shakespeare make the audience feel sorry for Juliet in the second part of Act 3, Scene 5? At the beginning of Act three, scene 5, Romeo and Juliet have just spent their first night together. Romeo has to leave for Mantua, because it's morning and if he was found in Verona he would be killed. Juliet, though she doesn't want him to leave, says goodbye to Romeo and is left feeling unhappy. Her father, thinking she is still mourning her cousin Tybalt's death, announces that he is moving her marriage to Paris forward. He expects her to be happier because of this, however when Juliet refuses the marriage, he loses his temper and threatens to throw her out. At the end of the scene Juliet is left with a dilemma, whether she should stay faithful to Romeo and het thrown out of her home, or follow her father's wishes and marry Paris, betraying Romeo in the process. Shakespeare uses contrasting atmospheres for the two halves of the scene. In the first half of the scene, having spent her first night with Romeo, Juliet is content and happy. She doesn't want Romeo to leave her as shown in the line, "It was the nightingale and not the lark." This shows her desire for Romeo to stay, she is so desperate for him not to go that she lies and tries to convince him it is still night time. In the first half of the scene, Juliet feels wanted and loved by Romeo, shown when he says, "Come death, and welcome. Juliet wills it so." He is prepared to risk being caught and put to death by staying with Juliet as she wishes. Even though Juliet would feel frightened that Romeo wanted to put himself in danger, she would be happy that he loved her so much that he would be willing to die for her. ...read more.


One other language technique Shakespeare uses to create sympathy for Juliet is when Capulet uses a metaphor comparing Juliet to an animal when he says, "Graze where you will." Capulet comparing Juliet to an animal makes the audience feel sorry for her because he is insulting Juliet, making it clear he sees her as less than human. Shakespeare could have also used this to represent the status of Juliet. This is because animals cannot speak and neither can Juliet in the way that she has to do what her parents tell her to and be respectful and docile to them, a bit like a farm animal. Shakespeare is using Capulet's line to emphasise that Juliet's society prevents her from independently making certain decisions, she cannot choose who she wants to marry. This would make the audience feel sympathy for Juliet because she is similar to a farm animal in the way that her father is making decisions about what is essentially her future but she can't speak up without being punished. Nevertheless, a Shakespearean audience would not be against Capulet saying such things, since in Elizabethan society, women were seen as the property of men and men were free to do with them what they chose. One final way Capulet's behaviour makes the audience feel sorry for Juliet, is his use of threatening language. He says "My fingers itch." meaning he really feels like hitting his daughter at that moment. This would make Juliet feel scared and the audience frightened for her. A modern audience would feel the most pity for her because a modern society doesn't tolerate abuse and many people would see hitting a child as going too far. On the other hand, a Shakespearean audience would feel more sympathy towards Capulet because in their time punishing a child for obedience by hitting them would have been seen as normal and acceptable. ...read more.


Juliet being left alone and isolated on the stage at the end creates sympathy from the audience because she has been let down by everyone she has turned to. Her father ignored her pleas even when she lowered her pride by falling in front of him. Her mother said she didn't want anything more to do with her, and the nurse, who Juliet was much closer than with her parents, disappointed her by supporting the marriage. The audience would also feel sorry Juliet as her parents don't know about the dilemma they have created for her. The nurse, if she does know of the dilemma, chooses to ignore it and acts like the decision is simple and straightforward when Juliet doesn't see it that way. The scene overall would leave the audience feeling a variety of emotions about Juliet and other characters present in the scene. Firstly, they would feel sympathy for Juliet because the whole scene has been full of bad events, from Romeo leaving since he was banished, to her facing homelessness if she did not marry. The person she had trusted the most, the nurse, has also let her down. They would also feel frustrated at Capulet and his wife for trying to force into a marriage she clearly does not want. They would also feel this because people in modern society are encouraged more to marry fro love and arranged marriages are generally frowned upon in modern England. However, an audience in Shakespeare's day may feel much less sympathy for Juliet than a modern one would. This is because they would think Juliet was being ungrateful for refusing the marriage, as Capulet says, "My care hath been to have her matched," which implies that he has spent a long time finding her a suitable husband. They would think Juliet not wanting to marry as being extremely inconsiderate to her father, who cared for her enough for him not to choose just any man. Nonetheless, a modern audience and an Elizabethan audience would feel some pity for Juliet being essentially forced by her parents to betray Romeo. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Lord Capulet, How good a father do you feel he is to Juliet

    He is so delighted that Juliet has changed her mind, he moves the marriage a day forward 'I'll have this knot knit up tomorrow morning', again, he does not know or care if this is convenient for anyone involved. This scene shows that Capulet is only content if he gets exactly what he wants and everyone obeys him.

  2. How would a modern and Elizabethan audience react to the way that Shakespeare portrays ...

    Although this is true, he also highly values the need for his daughter to marry well and to someone of which he approves, which is why Paris, a handsome, somewhat self-absorbed and very wealthy gentlemen who her Father deems more than suitable to be Juliet's husband, creates issues in Juliet's

  1. Romeo & Juliet.

    We are seeing Juliet how Romeo sees her, in the Luhrman version however, the camera movement is quicker and has more variety than staying linear, it follows Romeo and Juliets eyes, this is good because eye contact is the best way of showing how someone is in love.

  2. Diary entries for Juliet

    never see him again, if he goes there is a chance I could see him again, the nurse started calling and Romeo was gone, my heart sank.

  1. Romeo & Juliet - Lady Capulet

    As he says, "How will she none?" He is standing looking directly at Juliet with disbelief and shock. Juliet looks back at him frightened to death. He then says, "Doth she not give us thanks? Is she not proud?" He is still calm trying to understand the situation.

  2. Romeo and juliet

    Romeo's love for Rosaline was short lived, his attraction towards Juliet shows how frequently he changed his mind. His changing mind and impulsive behaviour becomes a problem for him later. His immaturity and adolescence can be blamed for his death.

  1. Romeo and Juliet VERY FULL OVERVIEW

    They make vows of love to each other until Juliet is called away by the nurse. She returns and tells Romeo that she will send a messenger the next day to find out when and where they are to marry.

  2. How Does Shakespeare Present The Relationship Between Capulet and Juliet in Romeo and Juliet?

    He loses control and shouts ?my fingers itch!? in his fit of madness showing that he is unstable and is finding it hard to control his temper. Juliet is distraught at her father?s hateful words and kneels down to him in anguish; ?Good father, i beseech you on my knees,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work