• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Some critics say that Amanda (from The Glass Menagerie) is trying to relive her youth. How far do you agree with this comment?

Extracts from this document...


Elaine Cox. Revision Essay Questions. Some critics say that Amanda is trying to relive her youth. How far do you agree with this comment? After reading The Glass Menagerie I would tend to agree with this comment for a number of reasons that I shall discuss in this essay, but do not agree with it completely, and feel there are a number of significant reasons as to why Amanda behaves in the way she does, and I plan to discuss this too. To begin with, throughout the play, Amanda constantly talks about the abundance of gentlemen callers she used to receive in her youth. This annoys her son and, I would suggest, embarrasses her daughter who has never has a gentleman caller. I do not think she talks about these men in order to bring out these feelings in her children, and may indeed be as a way of 'returning to' her youth by remembering the way she acted in her past. ...read more.


Within this scene, Amanda's behaviour as well as her appearance does appear to be very immature for age. She is constantly jumping around, 'baptizing herself' with lemonade that she spills in her girlishness, and cooing over Jim constantly, almost to the point where he is embarrasses by her actions. Returning to the idea that Amanda is trying to relive her youth through her daughter, I would suggest that, indeed, she is doing well in this when Jim comes around for she indeed demands more of his attention in the dining scene than Laura. Amanda does not seem, however, ready to let Laura get on with her own life and wants her daughter to do exactly as she did when she was young; to marry and settle down. Amanda feels that unless her daughter does this she will always be living off the 'grudging patronage' of others. I would therefore argue that Amanda is indeed trying to relive parts of her life through her daughter, even to the point of desperation for her to get married, even though her own marriage ended in her husband abandoning her and their children. ...read more.


However, there are significant points that suggest Amanda is trying to relive her youth, which I feel have not been ignore, such as her flirtatious behaviour with Jim, wearing her teenage dresses, and constantly talking about her past. I would however argue, on the grounds of the points I have made, that Amanda is not trying to relive her youth. She is actually reliving her good times, in a time of hardship in her life, and trying to find a way of communicating with her children. Consequently I do not agree with the comment that 'Amanda is trying to relive her youth' as I feel the underlying reasons are far more important in understanding why she appears to be trying to relive her youth, rather than the simple fact that she behaves immaturely for her age, and that her unhappiness, loneliness and misunderstanding of her children are the main factors that led to her behaviour, rather than a simple desire to return to her youth. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Glass Menagerie section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Glass Menagerie essays

  1. Important Symbols and Themes of The Glass Menagerie

    It is getting harder and harder for Tom to avoid real life. The time for a real departure is fast approaching. Amanda eventually pushes him over the edge, almost forcing him out, but not without laying overpowering guild trips on him.

  2. Relationships in The Glass Menagerie, by Tennessee Williams.

    As for Jim himself, he never gave "that weird girl from high school" Laura any important significance, never stopped to think too much about her, and he is acting in a rather irresponsible way when they are together, not making very clear his intentions and his feeling for Laura.

  1. A Critic suggests that the source of the plays dramatic power lies in the ...

    However, this illusion that Amanda holds of Laura breaks as easily as the horn from the glass unicorn. When they find out that Jim is engaged this illusion is not simply on the verge of being shattered, but is in fact in pieces.

  2. To what extent is the glass menagerie about glass? Discuss.

    " Don't push with your fingers...the thing to push with is a crust of bread." She also wants to relive her past through her daughter Laura; " Picture looking at a drinking glass and imagine seeing Amanda's memories dancing about within the hardness and confines of the glass leaving her

  1. Some critics argue that the Glass Menagerie is a tragedy. How far do you ...

    Laura, whose situation appears to be most serious, is crippled so she is physically disabled, but the shyness this causes also leads her to become psychologically malfunctioned. These people's situations are, indeed, very serious. Aristotle then goes on to argue that a tragedy must 'excite the emotions of pity and fear.'

  2. 'Amanda is selfish and heartless' How far do you agree with this statement in ...

    She does not want to believe that her only daughter is a disheartened and a lonesome woman who finds contentment among a world of glass figurines. Though she does care it is selfish and heartless to keep on reminding Laura that she has no gentleman callers.

  1. A Phenomenon of Theoretical States: Connecting Crane and Rilke to Tennessee Williams' The Glass ...

    It is commonly known that Williams attended two universities, at which works of both philosophers were collected. Another possible source of direct exposure to either Hegel or Pater (or both) is the library of his grandfather. In his Foreword to Sweet Bird of Youth, Williams confesses that he was tormented

  2. The Thing.

    "Laura you call the 999 while I'll do some breaths on him" he quickly said looking up at her. Laura was now running in her tatty dress to the door of the garage of which she opened to call 999.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work