• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Lack of Evolution in the Detective Genre.

Extracts from this document...


The Lack of Evolution in the Detective Genre Sherlock Holmes is probably the most famous detective in literary history. Therefore, it is not surprising that many authors in the 20th century have followed Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's template when writing detective stories. For example, Agatha Christie's character Hercule Poirot is nearly identical to Holmes. In this essay, I will compare "The Hound of the Baskervilles" by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and "Hercule Poirot's Christmas" by Agatha Christie, two basically similar novels, which are clear examples of the detective genre. In doing so, I hope to prove that the basic elements of detective stories, such as the detective, his methods and the feeling of suspense, have remained unchanged over the years. Firstly, the most obvious point of comparison lies in the many similarities between the two main characters, the detectives, Holmes and Poirot. Both of them are quite vain and self-obsessed. Near the beginning, they are constantly taunting or bragging to their companions. For example, when Holmes proves that one of Watson's theories is incorrect, he says "'No mention of that local hunt, Watson'... with a mischievous smile", gently mocking him. Earlier on, he also says "in noting your fallacies, I was occasionally guided towards the truth". Although this might be interpreted as a compliment, I believe that this is a very pretentious remark, which reflects Holmes' vain and egotistical nature. ...read more.


One night, Watson hears Barrymore walking around very quietly "with no covering on his feet" clearly trying to be stealthy, and then sees him signalling someone on the moor. This is clearly intended to convince the reader that the butler is at least working with the murderer if he himself is not the murderer. However, it is then discovered that he was communicating with his brother-in-law who could not have had any connection with the murder. Christie however, goes much further, and gives all the characters a motive for murdering Simeon Lee. She does however, include a character very similar to Barrymore. Horbury, although not a butler, performs more or less the same tasks for Simeon Lee, and like Barrymore, is trusted by nobody. He "sneaks around like a cat", which is very similar to Barrymore's description, and "listens at doors". Because of this mistrust he was the main suspect for a while, but it was then proved that he was not the culprit. The fact that clues appear irrelevant at first is another very obvious similarity between the two books. For example, in Christie's book, when Poirot, Johnson and Sugden are interviewing Pilar, she say that Simeon Lee "'must have been handsome - very handsome, like you'... to Superintendent Sugden" and Sugden's face turns "brick-red at the compliment", the reader is lead to believe that he is simply embarrassed. ...read more.


Stapleton appeared to be the harmless friend of Sir Henry. I believe that this makes the story more exciting and keeps the reader interested until the end of the story. The final similarity is that both murders are "remarkable". As he was killed in a room that was locked from the inside and nobody was even near the room at the time, Simeon Lee's murder was considered "unreal". Sir Charles Baskerville was killed by a hound, "but not such a hound as mortal eyes have ever seen". "Fire burst from its open mouth" and "its eyes glowed with a smouldering glare". This clearly shows how unnatural the hound was, if not supernatural. Although the crimes seem unreal, the authors give reasonable explanations. For example, the Hound's ability to glow in the dark is explained in a single word by Holmes, "Phosphorus". In Christie's novel, Sugden visited the house twice on the day of the murder, once before, and once after. Poirot explains how he "killed him (Simeon Lee) before you (Sugden) left the house the first time" and "turned the key from the outside". Despite being quite strange both explanations are plausible. In conclusion, I believe that all these similarities between the two stories, such as the similarities between the two detectives, the way in which clues are revealed and the way in which the author keeps the reader interested, show how similar Agatha Christie's novels are to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's. Therefore, I believe that the detective genre has evolved very little over the years. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle essays

  1. An analysis of the Detective Genre.

    He has an immense understanding of the world and people and this is shown in the quote taken from The Man With The Twisted Lip 'I have seen too much not to know that the impression of a women may be more valuable than the conclusion of an analytical reasoner.'

  2. In the beginning of my second story, written by Charles Dickens, The Signalman, the ...

    His whole face sharpened away into the nose and chin, and the skin of his cheeks was drawn quite tense over his outstanding bones.' (The colonel)-'Well, perhaps it is better that i should not tell you just at this moment.

  1. The Lack of Change in the Detective Genre.

    Holmes, on the other hand, says that he knows that he is the best detective in Britain, showing that he is very vain, and wants people to notice that, but also wants people to acknowledge that even he has failed in cases in the past, saying "...it has happened far more that people who read your accounts...may realise" to Watson.

  2. An Analysis of the Detective Genre

    Holmes is no different to the modern day detective but is an example of what the society expected of a person in such a profession over a period of one hundred years ago. In nineteenth century detective fiction, perhaps as a reflection of to the society in this period, the

  1. Explore the detective story genre with particular reference to Conan Doyle's stories.Show it's social, ...

    on the night of the murder. The story is however extremely unusual in two ways: 1. Sherlock Holmes fails to save the victim who came for help. 2. He hardly does any detective work. The story revolves around the history of a young man who went by the name of John Openshaw whose uncle had adopted him.

  2. Agatha Christie -

    That told me had knowledge about things that was above average. Agatha Christie's "Death on the Nile" started off in England. Linnet Ridgeway a young, beautiful, and rich girl had just bought an estate there, after she had just inherited a great fortune from her father Melhuish Ridgeway.

  1. Relevant history & Business environment.

    March 2002 hotel performance . Occupancy (%) Average room rate RevPAR RevPAR change (%) Central London 76 95 72 -16.0 Outer London 65 65 42 -18.6 Average Annual Room Rate AARR over �200 64 248 158 -17.8 AARR �160-�200 70 152 106 -22.2 AARR �110-�160 75 115 87 -18.2 AARR �80-�110 81 83 68 -14.4 AARR under

  2. To what extent are chapters 5 and 6 of Doyle's Hound of the Baskervilles ...

    In this chapter, Holmes' partner in the mystery Watson is to go with Sir Henry Baskerville to Dartmoor to protect him. The three clues that Holmes thought he had in order to help him solve the case conclude to be unhelpful.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work