• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The Speckled Band" by Arthur Conan Doyle and "Lamb to the Slaughter" by Roald Dahl both belong to the genre of murder/crime stories. In what ways are they similar and how do they differ?

Extracts from this document...


Date: 26 September 2001 Assignment title: "The Speckled Band" by Arthur Conan Doyle and "Lamb to the Slaughter" by Roald Dahl both belong to the genre of murder/crime stories. In what ways are they similar and how do they differ? In my essay, I shall analyse two murder stories: "The Speckled Band" by Arthur Conan Doyle and "Lamb to the Slaughter" by Roald Dahl. These stories both belong to the genre of murder stories and I shall explain the ways in which they are similar and how they differ. The first crime novel was written by Wilkie Collins and was entitled "The Moonstone." At the turn of the century, Arthur Conan Doyle, one of the authors of my comparative stories, appeared and bought us the detective "Sherlock Holmes." This produced a 'recipe' for the writing of murder-mystery novels. The first thing to comprehend when comparing these two stories is what a murder/crime story actually is. The main ingredients of a murder/crime story are that it contains a murderer/criminal, a victim, a detective(s), a weapon and usually some sort of twist in the tale. "The Speckled Band" is the story of a woman called Helen Stoner, who goes to Sherlock Holmes when she hears the identical whistle she heard on the night of her sister's death two years ago. Julia's last words referred to "The speckled band!" ...read more.


It was left to the reader's imagination, although, it indicated that Patrick was going to leave Mary. In these stories, there were two leading detectives. They were Jack Noonan in "Lamb to the Slaughter" and Sherlock Holmes in "The Speckled Band." However, Sherlock has an assistant, Dr. Watson. In "The Speckled Band," Sherlock and Watson are main characters whereas Jack Noonan from "Lamb to the slaughter" is not. A well as this, another difference is the fact that Sherlock and Watson are private detectives compared to Noonan who is not. Sherlock Holmes is renowned for his "intuitions" and "logic." A fine example of this is when he notices that Helen Stoner travelled by train, then dogcart, having observed the return ticket in her hand. This makes the reader admire Sherlock and have faith in him to solve a difficult case. In contrast, Jack Noonan from "Lamb to the Slaughter" is not as open-minded as Sherlock Holmes. He says, "...you've got the man," which shows that he didn't think of suspecting Mary, as she was a woman. The reader would have probably have thought that if Sherlock was investigating this particular crime, he probably would have suspected Mary sooner or later. Jack, however, is very kind and caring towards Mary as he regularly talks to her to make sure she is ok. ...read more.


However, the reader's interpretations of Mary change dramatically as the story approaches the end. This is because Mary is not as nice and sweet as she was at the beginning. This shows that Mary has the signs of a split personality. In comparison, when the writer for "The Speckled Band" uses his character, Sherlock Holmes, to give his views, Holmes appears quite calm and even callous as he says, "I cannot say that it is likely to weigh very heavily upon my conscience." The issue of orals and ethics is bought up at the end of both the stories and, in some ways, debates if murder is acceptable in certain situations. The answer to this from Dahl's point of view is that Mary was essentially a sweet and nice woman who was provoked into committing a crime that she didn't mean to commit and so should not be punished. Conan Doyle thinks that Roylott was a nasty and evil man who got what was coming to him and that justice had been served in the form of his death. This means that both the stories had effective endings. In conclusion, this essay shows that these two stories had many similarities and differences which all contributed to the way in which the stories are interpreted by different readers and make them what they are. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Roald Dahl section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Roald Dahl essays

  1. Compare the murderers and their crimes, with attention to their description, in 'The Tell ...

    how Mary's life is revolved around Patrick and how much she lives him, so when he tells her he's leaving, we understand why she burst out and kills him. 'The Tell Tale Heart,' focuses on the murderer, and his sanity.

  2. The stories which I have chosen to explain how the writers keep the reader ...

    voice is very ruthless and dull, it shows the audience that Patrick is not happy and something has gone wrong this can be seen by the tone of his voice and he is only replying with one word answers and not having a proper conversation.

  1. Comparison between the Lamb to the Slaughter And the Speckled Band

    In the Lamb to the slaughter they give us no evidence that they are scientific, brave, deductive or even professional. They drink on the job, eat and have a chat whilst they are meant to be working. In the Speckled Band the detectives searched the outside of the room which

  2. Write a comparative essay about two stories you have studied - Compare characters, theme, ...

    the occupants of the bed the English man puts his handkerchief, with the money, under his pillow so it's safe. Then the man so he ties the handkerchief to the back of his cravat (tie) because when he lies down on his bed he sees the canopy moving down as if its going to crush him to death.

  1. Explain the main similarities and differences between the two murder mystery stories "Lamb to ...

    The start of the end is when Sherlock and Watson stay in the bedroom where Helen Stoner is going to be killed. They sit quietly until Sherlock suddenly stands up and starts to swing his cane aimlessly. We find out later that he is actually trying to hit a snake.

  2. A comparison of two short stories from the murder mystery genre

    To show their ignorance the detectives also consume the evidence. 'Probably right under our very noses' I think Roald Dahl put this quotation to give some humour and show that people are sometimes not what they should be. The problem in 'The Speckled Band' is Helen Stoner.

  1. The Landlady - Roald Dahl , A teribly strange bed - Wilkie ...

    She then tells Billy 'We have it all to ourselves'. The situation seems very peculiar as she seems to anticipate everything Billy says. This makes the reader become slightly suspicious of her due to her overly keen attitude. She also seems to be slightly crazed which makes you wonder what has happened to her in the past.

  2. In this wide-reading piece I will compare two murder mystery stories: 'The Speckled Band' ...

    When we first meet him we find he is very observant as the text states; "No but I observe the second half of a return ticket in the palm of your left glove". This shows that Holmes is very attentive and quick to spot things.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work