• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'The Speckled Band' or 'Lamb to the Slaughter' - Which is the More Effective Crime Story?

Extracts from this document...


'The Speckled Band' or 'Lamb to the Slaughter'-Which is the More Effective Crime Story? The 'ingredients' of a crime story usually consist of a murderer, a villain, a victim, a weapon, a witness/alibi and clues. I will be looking at each story's characteristics. 'The Speckled Band' and 'Lamb to the Slaughter' are both crime stories but they are of different types. A 'whodunit' crime story is where a crime is committed and we along with the detectives try to solve who did it, why they did it, and how they did it. 'The Speckled Band is a 'whodunit' crime story. The adventures of Sherlock Holmes were highly popular in 1883 because Conan Doyle was the original crime writer. Sherlock Holmes was the first hero detective. He was of upper class, well educated and wealthy. The amazing mysteries with bizarre crime and complicated plots were always solved and explained by Sherlock Holmes. 'Lamb to the Slaughter', written in 1945 by Roald Dahl, is a 'murder mystery'. This type of story is where we know who committed the crime, how they committed the crime and why the crime but watch the detectives try to solve it and the murderer try to get away with it. In 'The Speckled Band', a 'distraught' woman whose twin sister dies a horrible death (two weeks before her wedding day), which is haunting her, so she approaches Sherlock Holmes for help. He visits their estate to solve the mystery. In 'Lamb to the Slaughter', Mary Maloney, a 'calm' and 'keen' housewife kills her husband unexpectedly, with a frozen leg of lamb, ...read more.


She carefully plans out, just as he carefully planned the murder of Julia. Dr Grimesby Roylott and Patrick Maloney are quite similar victims because they start of as villains and end up being killed. Mary, on the other hand starts of as a victim but then turns into a villain, but we don't really hate her, because she is a nice person. We feel sorry for Julia because she is murdered before her wedding day, and our feelings are similar towards Helen too because she doesn't know what to do and seeks help, unlike Mary. The women are different in both stories; possibly because both stories were written in different times. As 'Lamb to the Slaughter' was written about a century after 'The Speckled Band', the role of women in society had obviously changed. Mary Maloney is more cunning and bright and devious while Helen is reliant, weak, and dominated. '(Mary) certainly wasn't going to take a chance.' 'That's the way, she told herself. Do everything right and natural...'(Lamb to the Slaughter) ''It is not cold which makes me shiver...it is fear, Mr. Holmes. It is terror'' ''Oh, sir do you not think that you could help me too, and at least throw a little light, through the dense darkness that still surrounds me...I shall be married, with the control of my income...'(The Speckled Band) Sherlock Holmes and Detective Jack Noonan aren't similar at all because Detective Jack Noonan doesn't turn change roles but Sherlock turns from detective to villain. ...read more.


When Mary goes to get the leg of lamb out of the freezer, she held it in the most peculiar way. 'She carried it upstairs, holding the thin bone-end of it with both her hands.' The leg of lamb can't be that heavy. This makes us think that she's up to something. There is a contrast in both endings of the story. 'Lamb to the Slaughter' leaves you thinking about what's going to happen next. Will she get caught, or will she get away? 'The Speckled Band' didn't leave us wondering. A comparison would be that neither character showed remorse. 'And in the other room, Mary Maloney began to giggle.' (Lamb to the Slaughter) ''In this way, I am no doubt indirectly responsible for Dr Grimesby Roylott's death and I cannot say that it is likely to weigh heavily upon my conscience.'' concludes Sherlock Holmes after killing Dr Grimesby Roylott. I think that both characters think that both the murdered characters deserved to die. Both writers promote that it is fine to kill. The writers position us to side with the villains. Dr Grimesby Roylott deserved it and so did Patrick. We actually want the murderers to get away with it. 'The Speckled Band' is typical to its genre because it is spooky and dark while 'Lamb to the Slaughter isn't typical to its genre because it is a nice clean and calm house that the murder takes place in. I think that both stories have different types of effects that make it hard to choose which is the better crime story. Conan Doyle wrote the first ever, detective crime story whereas Roald Dahl wrote the first subverted crime story. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle essays

  1. Coursework-The Speckled Band How does Conan Doyle present Dr. Grimesby Roylott as a typical ...

    Holmes inspects the house in his usual manner, thoroughly looking for any clues. He scrutinises the scene and objects with fine detail, unlike Watson who is less careful and less observant. Holmes obtains the necessary clues, such as an air vent not leading outside and the bed being chained to the floor.

  2. Compare and contrast 'Lamb to the Slaughter' and 'The Speckled Band' as examples of ...

    From 1882 to 1890 he practised medicine in Southsea where he met and married Louise Hawkins, his first wife. He began to send short stories to magazine editors and he found his success in his first published story 'The Mystery of Sasassa Valley' (1879)

  1. Both the Adventure of the Speckled Band and Lamb to the Slaughter share some ...

    We know this because Holmes says "when young ladies wander about the metropolis at this hour of the morning, and knock sleepy people up out of their beds, I presume that it is something very pressing which they have to communicate", suggesting that the woman wouldn't come at this time for no reason.

  2. Look carefully at 'The Speckled Band' and 'The Five Orange Pips.' How does the ...

    In 'The Five Orange Pips', Holmes says, "I think, Watson, that of all our cases we have had none more fantastic than this." Than Watson replies "Save, perhaps, the Sign of Four." 'The Sign of Four' was another Sherlock Holmes book written by Arthur Conan Doyle.

  1. Brighton Rock and Sherlock Holmes: A Comparison

    For example, all events must take place while Dr. Watson is present, or they must be recounted to him by another character. In contrast, Greene can make the reader everywhere at once and it allows him to use the cinematic detail in his description that gives his locations the depth and quality that Conan Doyle's does not due to his use of the first person.

  2. The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes

    in 'The Speckled Band', when Dr Roylott murdered his native butler but did not get executed for doing so, as the punishment for murder in the Victorian times was execution.

  1. The Speckled Band and Lamb to the Slaughter comparison

    He also uses the word 'pray' often, which means please, showing that he has good manners in general. However, Jack Noonan from 'Lamb to the slaughter' doesn't seem to be quite so caring and polite, when dealing with Mary Maloney (his client).

  2. Discuss the two Sherlock Holmes stories and say which you think is the more ...

    The letter tells us how a beautiful Peruvian woman of "alien religion" has married a man who already has a disabled child from a previous marriage; they too now have a child. However, the family appears to be far from normal, as the woman has been caught assaulting her husband's child on two occasions.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work