• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To some poets, war seems a glorious adventure, to others it is merely brutal destruction. Compare the ways Brooke & Rosenberg explore the glory or futility of war.

Extracts from this document...


To some poets, war seems a glorious adventure, to others it is merely brutal destruction. Compare the ways the poets explore the glory or futility of war. The poem, 'The Soldier' by Rupert Brooke is written in the sonnet format but the rhyming scheme is divided into an octave and sestet pattern; the Shakespearean/ Elizabethan style of octave being 'ababcdcd', while the sestet follows the Petrarchan/Italian scheme of 'fgefg'. This contrasts to the structure of 'Dead Man's Dump' by Rosenberg, which does not show any consistency in the length of its stanzas or lines, nor does it establish a rhyming pattern. This may relate to the contrasting content of each of the poems. Rosenberg explores many ideas with the underlying view that war is an illogical, brutal destruction where the deaths of men are futile, much like the illogical structure his poem adopts. Rosenberg reflects on the mystery of life and death, and its gruesome reality in war. He also highlights spiritual and religious concepts of death through its connection with life, the soul, Earth and God. Brookes has deviated somewhat from the traditional thematic divisions associated with the octave and sestet rhyming scheme which question/predicament and resolution/solution, respectively. ...read more.


It stirs the question that if no one knew the extent of suffering the soldiers went through then what is the purpose of their deaths, is it of any value. These thoughts are conjured through rhetorical questions in 'Dead Man's Dump', 'have they gone into you?/ Somewhere they must have gone...' Both of the poems highlight dreaming, in 'The Soldier', Brooke compares dreaming to England, 'as happy and her day' and appeals to the reader's senses by imagining 'her sights and sounds'. 'Dead Man's Dump' mentions dreaming in a different light, those who are injured in the war 'dreamed of home', hoping that they will see it again and imagining as they take their final breaths. Brooke communicates that the death of the soldier was for England so that others may appreciate 'her flowers to love, her ways to roam' and to uphold the 'English heaven'. The religious imagery in this poem revolves around the country, 'blest by the suns of home', unlike 'Dead Man's Dump' which respects the 'God-ancestralled' wonders and reminds the reader of the Christian burial service, 'man born of woman'. It personifies Earth using strong imagery as evil waiting for the men to die 'fretting for their decay', compared to Brooke who personifies England as the mother who 'bore' and 'shaped' the man, 'all evil shed away'. ...read more.


Brookes expresses how he should be remembered 'if' he is to die. His poem reflects on the pleasures he has enjoyed in life and is not bitter towards death as those pleasures which have come from his country, will live on. The reminiscent tone of the poem is enforced by the frequent use punctuation to show his 'pause for thought' and listing all the 'glorious' aspects of life he has experienced in England, proud to represent 'English air' in a foreign land. Rosenberg, however, feels that 'the air is loud with death' and finds it a difficult concept to be at peace with. He questions different interpretations of it which is also reflected in the use of punctuation in the poem. A variety of punctuation is used to show Rosenberg's thought process as he tries to tackle the subject of death and its purpose in the context of war. He builds up the suspense of saving a dying soldier's life as he is symbolically 'stretched at the crossroads': 'we heard his weak scream/ we heard his very last sound' only for it to be too late and 'our wheels grazed his dead face'. His poem represents a personal journey of bitter emotions towards war, the disregard of life and the evil and wondrous forces that revolve around death. ?? ?? ?? ?? WW1 Poetry ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. 5 Ways to Kill Man - Analysis

    You could fly miles above the heads of your victims, and kill them without ever having known them, or seen them in your life. As the pilot flew over Nagasaki and Hiroshima, all he had to flick a switch, and cruelly kill millions of people who he had never seen, under the orders of the 'psychopath' Harry S.


    584). Gilbert and Gubar identify as their antagonists such "masculinist" critics as Ransom, and yet their argument, as they are forced to acknowledge, closely resembles his idea of the poet's mask (p. 557). But Gilbert and Gubar make one further move.

  1. 'Compare a selection of WW1 poetry to show how different aspects of the war ...

    'And laughter, learnt of friends; and gentleness, In hearts at peace, under an English heaven' Rupert Brooke now has finished symbolically making these two lines sound very close and peaceful, showing that dying in the Great War for the great country called England will bring purification.

  2. Compare The Poets Attitudes Towards Death In Sonnet 73 And Crossing The Bar.

    Thus being an optimistic attitude to death as we can assume that he thinks he is departing to a better place when he encounters death. Already, via the first verse of each poem, differences and similarities between the two poets opinions to death are noticeable.

  1. Compare and contrast the ways in which writers present their attitudes to the First ...

    A lot of the vocabulary is to do with funerals, for example 'prayers or bells', 'choirs' etc, which emphasises the point of the poem.

  2. What attitudes do these poets convey towards War and Death

    "What will you lack ... When the girls line up in the street ... what will you lack when your mate goes by With a girl that cuts you dead?" In this extract the focus is heavily targeted in making one feel the benefits of fighting in a negative way.

  1. Compare the ways in which the poets memorably describe soldiers going off to war ...

    procession - "Blithely they go as to a wedding day, The mothers' sons" - the emphasis on mother here, particularly as the four syllables of that line dramatically change the metre, reminds the reader that each of them belongs to someone, thus making it even more tragic.

  2. War Poetry Essays - "Out of the Blue", "Poppies" and "Futility".

    This shows that despite the futility of his actions, the narrator continues to believe that he will be rescued; he is not yet ready to give up his life. As the poem goes on, the narrator points out "I am still breathing".

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work