• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What is Dickens Attitude to the Working Classes in Chapter XX (Book 2, Chapter 4)?Does Dickens portray the Unions with as much Sympathy as the Workers? Charles Dickens wrote Hard Times in 1854.

Extracts from this document...


What is Dickens Attitude to the Working Classes in Chapter XX (Book 2, Chapter 4)? Does Dickens portray the Unions with as much Sympathy as the Workers? Charles Dickens wrote Hard Times in 1854. He lived in London and because he was writing about industrialisation in the North at that time he went up to Preston in 1852 to explore the industrialisation there and to witness the strike of the weavers. He was horrified by the oppressing industrialists he witnessed and also horrified by seeing the way the common people were made to work. His experiences in Preston and the characters he met were very much portrayed in Hard Times. Chapter 20 in Hard Times shows Dickens' attitude to the different classes of people that were involved in industrialisation. The chapter is about the mill workers who are debating whether or not to go on strike because they are tired of the bad treatment they are receiving from their oppressor, Bounderby. The two main characters who are speaking in this Chapter of the book are Stephen and Slackbridge. Stephen is one of the workers in the mill who has sworn to the woman that he is in love with, Rachel, that he would not join the Union because of reasons not explained in the book. The main point that Dickens is putting across through what Stephen is saying is that if they strike and join the Union then it will result in even more harsh treatment and a bleak future. ...read more.


Not that such meetings are less susceptible to humbug than meetings of any other class.........But even at their worst trade union organizers are not a bit like Slackbridge. . . . All this is pure middle-class ignorance. It is much as if a tramp were to write a description of millionaires smoking large cigars in church, with their wives in low-necked dresses and diamonds."'(2) 'Dickens notes that the strike organizers refused to listen to a group of Manchester delegates from the Labour Parliament, as they felt that these honourable gentlemen marginalised the strike and tried to explain and justify the policy of the Labour Parliament. This wisdom, order, dignity and moderation are totally absent from Hard Times'(3), which further shows Dickens attitude towards the people at the head of unionism and going on strike. In chapter 5, Slackbridge glorifies labour which is completely hypocritical to what he had been previously been saying about their suffering. He is very repetitive and goes back to the same point 'at such at time...at such a time....' Although some of his words could be seen as revolutionary 'with a noble and majestic unanimity that will make Tyrants tremble,' these good things are turned into manipulation and hypocrisy by Slackbridge. Another interesting point to note about Slackbridge is the similarity between his body language and that of Hitler's 'holding out his right hand at arm's length' etc. Whereas Dickens' portrayal of Stephen is completely different. Stephen is portrayed as the hero in this chapter and almost characterizes Dickens own personal thoughts to the problem at the time. ...read more.


He was afraid that strike might lead to rioting and cause the whole country to drift into chaos and even civil war.' (4) 'It seems more probable that the novel called forth a heightened picture all round, and in writing about the strike meeting he had only to draw upon that part of himself which had (with some reason) despised the more violent leaders of the chartists, that feared so desperately mob rule, to find himself in tune with the middle class who could take so much concern for social reform.'(5) Dickens had spoken to Karl Marx and possibly have read the publication of Engles' and Marxs' 'The Communist Manifesto.' It was unknown whether he agreed with his solution to the social injustices which industrialization had brought but it was certain that they both had very strong feelings of the workers being oppressed. Dickens had also seen what had happened when the workers did eventually revolt as 1848 was the Year of Revolutions; France, Germany and Russia had all revolted and we see that from the Chapter XX of Hard Times Dickens was definitely against the English workers forming a revolution too. It seems probable that Dickens's life-long distrust of political association and his early experience as a reporter in the House of Commons are partially responsible for his attitude to trade unions aswell. So although the tone of this chapter is revolutionary, it actually fails to be revolutionary. Hard Times was one of Dickens weakest novels as he didn't follow through his points and the most obvious question that he left unanswered and ambiguous is his solution to the industrial problem. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Hard Times section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Hard Times essays

  1. Compare and Contrast the role of Character and Characterization in the novels 'Hard Times' ...

    This is what makes his character so believable; Bounderby wants to be admired but if he were to be honest then his admiration from his peers would be non-existent. He gains his admiration from his story - "he is a self-made man."

  2. Charles Dickens wrote the novel 'Hard Times' in 1854. This novel expresses the extremity ...

    She marries Mr. Bounderby who is the owner of the bank and by doing this she can boost her brother Thomas' position in the bank. Louisa has an affair with a manipulative man called Harthouse. Harthouse is just wants casual sex from Louisa and comes across to her as very genuine.

  1. Hard Times by Charles Dickens.

    Hard Times opens with a comic yet frightening lecture on the purpose on the purpose of education.Significantly, the speech is not made by the schoolmaster, but by a businessman who underlines each point on the school master's sleeve, giving the impression that he is lecturing the instructor more than the pupils.

  2. Does Charles Dickens Show Affection To The Working Classes Of Victorian England In Hard ...

    yet he treats him with respect even though that is the last thing he deserves. Blackpool is a man of realities, even though others are perceived as this in the novel he is the only actual person that is. He is a man of realities in the sense that he

  1. analysis of hard time by charles dickens

    hard facts and the unaccommodating grasp that are later re-cast as the "Protestant Work Ethic" by Max Weber, a philosopher. The second Biblical allusion is along the same lines: one of the New Testament parables makes mention of good Christians as "vessels" who are to be "filled" by God, much

  2. Y10 English Literature Coursework

    Once more the children are objects as Gradgrind call to a girl and labels her as 'Girl number twenty'. He shows no concern at all for the children and there's no warmth or care in his tone of voice as he says, 'I don't know that girl.

  1. Charles Dickens - A disscussion on "HardTimes".

    Throughout the entire book, Dickens is constantly trying to prove his points through the characters he has created. On the one hand he shows the people who are oppressed by the other characters in the book, like Sissy, Louisa,

  2. How Does Dickens explore the conflict between "The Wisdom of the Heart and the ...

    "Some persons hold," he pursued, still hesitating, "that there is a wisdom of the Head, and that there is a wisdom of the Heart. I have not supposed so; but, as I have said, I mistrust myself now." This quote is Dickens' way of explaining to the reader, how each

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work