Who is responsible for the tragedy of Macbeth?

Authors Avatar

Stephen Williams    11E1      G.C.S.E English Coursework

Who is responsible for the tragedy of Macbeth?

        Firstly before we attempt to analyse who may be responsible for the tragedy of Macbeth we need to define tragedy.  In this case it may be the degeneration of a honourable war hero who becomes a murderer and a tyrant to his people.  However it is also feasible to say that the tragedy was that of Scotland’s, because of Macbeth’s succession to the Scottish throne, Scotland lost many men, became vulnerable to the threat of English invasion, many rebelled from within and the country began to decimate.  Personally I believe it is both, before Macbeth’s succession, Scotland was stable and ruled by a trusted king who had the support of his Thanes and subjects.  After the succession the country deteriorated or degenerated.

        The opening scene of the play shows the witches assembling for the first time, this is where they arrange to meet Macbeth, not only is this the start of the play, it is evidently the start of the tragedy.  Throughout this act Macbeth is built up as a war hero, and the thane of Cawdor is found to be a traitor.  The king then gives Macbeth the title  - he does not find this out until after he gets prophecies from the witches – this is ironic as The Thane of Cawdor is a traitor and Macbeth has now taken this role.  In scene three the witches give ambiguous prophecies to Macbeth.  This is really what he wants to hear and the witches have purely inspired unearthed ambitions.  Macbeth then pleads with the witches “ you imperfect speakers, tell me more” meaning that he is fascinated about the prospect of becoming king of Scotland.  Therefore we cannot say that they are to blame however it is feasible to say they are when looking at the way they have purposely manipulated him into acting (murdering) so that he becomes king and for fills his hidden ambitions.

        In scene three of act one just after the witches vanish Banquo comments to Macbeth that the prophecies may lead him to the crown as it did Thane of Cawdor “But ’tis strange, and oftentimes, to win us to our harm” this is also a prophecy even though Macbeth never truly realises its true meaning.

        It is the announcement of Duncan’s successor that aggravates Macbeth further, he realises that to become king he has to over step the Prince of Cumberland’s position “ that is a step on which I must fall down, or else o’erleap” meaning that he has to dispose of Malcolm or make him flee.  This is accomplished when Malcolm is named as a prime suspect in Duncan’s murder.

Join now!

        Scene 5 of Act 1 see’s the introduction Of Lady Macbeth, she is reading the letter that Macbeth has sent detailing the prophecies of the witches and his wishes to become king.  Macbeth writes a metaphor that describes his feelings and ambitions perfectly “ when I burned in desire”.  However he also says that he “fears thy nature” evidently meaning that he fears that he is unable to kill Duncan even though it would lead him to kingship.  It is also during this scene that we find out that Lady Macbeth is indeed ruthless this is seen when she ...

This is a preview of the whole essay