• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

TORT ESSAY - PROBLEM QUESTION Economic loss and duty of care

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

TORT ESSAY - PROBLEM QUESTION Economic loss and duty of care Isabelle Richard As a result of a car accident caused by Rahul's negligence Sunita is transported to the Accident and Emergency Department of Milton Hospital where unfortunately it soon transpires that nothing can be done to save her. However her parents convince the doctors to keep her artificially biologically alive so as to carry her baby to term. Three months later her son Ashok is born with severe disabilities consequential upon the physical trauma suffered by his mother, and by repercussion, himself, during the accident. Sunita's husband seeks to sue the Milton Hospital Trust in negligence for the birth of his disabled son. The Milton Hospital Trust will be held vicariously liable for the torts committed by its employees during the course of their employment. The issue is therefore as to whether the doctors committed a tort in relation to Sunita's husband when they took the decision to keep her artificially alive for the sake of her unborn baby. The claimant will wish to establish that had they properly diagnosed the risks involved (i.e. the likelihood of the child to be severely disabled) and informed him accordingly he would have certainly exercised his right to terminate the pregnancy (and not keep Sunita on life-support) ...read more.

Middle

a result of it, Lord Steyn applying principles of distributive justice; it would seem normal, logical to anyone that the 'burden' of bringing up an healthy child should fall on the parents, and Lord Clyde considering the expenses the defendant would have to incur if a duty was found would be out of proportion with his culpability. The issue as to when the baby born is disabled was not directly addressed. Judge Henriques in Hardman v Amin reviewed the case concluding it should not and did not apply to the situation where the child is disabled as a result of such clinical negligence. The subsequent Court of Appeal's decisions in Parkinson v St James and Seacroft University Hospital NHS Trust (2001) EWCA Civ 530 and Rees v Darlington Memorial Hospital NHS Trust (2002) EWCA Civ 88 seemed to confirm the view that damages for the cost and maintenance of a disabled child born because of the negligence of the defendant. In such cases therefore it would be fair, just and reasonable to hold the doctors liable in negligence for the (unwanted) birth of a disabled child; it would meet the principles of distributive justice and liability would not be out of proportion with the culpability since the doctors should be taken to have known the disastrous consequences such birth could have upon the parents. ...read more.

Conclusion

The fact that the doctors' actions were not the sole reason for the disability of the child, that the child would not have been disabled if Rahul had not caused the accident in the first place, is mostly irrelevant. Recoverable damages Following the recent cases mentioned above will be awarded the extra cost associated with the disability of the child ; normal costs relating to the upbringing of a child (healthy or disabled) will not be included (following McFarlane). Sunita's husband should be able to recover the expenses that will be needed to accommodate the disabled child due to his disability, to provide for his special needs, the cost of any treatment needed ... Concluding comments on Rahul's liability We can note that Sunita's husband should be able to sue Rahul in negligence for the accident, which caused the death of his wife (considering a possible reduction in the damages awarded due to contributory negligence, by Sunita in not wearing her seat-belt). In relation to the disabled Ashok, if the doctors can escape liability by showing that their actions were not unreasonable then Rahul might be held liable instead since the chain of causation would not have been broken by the medical intervention (Knight v Jones [1982] 1 WLR 349 (CA)). WORD COUNT : 2190 MARK OBTAINED : 72 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Child Development section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Child Development essays

  1. The purpose of this essay is to describe the holistic assessment of a 66 ...

    The starting point for the Roper, Logan and Tierney model of nursing lies in the hierarchy of human needs identified by the psychologist Abraham Maslow (1954). This orders human needs from the most basic needs to the most sophisticated. The basic physical needs, i.e.

  2. Discuss how this comment by Lord Slynn illustrates the development of the general concept ...

    Lord Reid's ideas allowed the area of duty of care to develop based on the circumstances of the individual case because it had originally come from the opinion of Lord Aitkin not from a statute. This follows Lord Slynn's idea that the law of negligence develops incrementally.

  1. Occupier's Liability

    the sign is sufficiently clear and ensures the visitor's safety Note the positive duty in (b) (as opposed to the duty of omission in (a), for the sign to secure the safety of visitors. Thus, it is not enough for the sign to warn of the danger.

  2. Reflective essay on "The Little Prince"

    The prince realizes that the flower he loved so much won't live long. After meeting a railway switchman the prince discovers that unsatisfied people travel in these trains back and forth and indeed, only children enjoy their journeys. Indeed grownups do certain things repeatedly to gain satisfaction unlike children who try to gain maximum satisfaction the very first time.

  1. Health and Social care

    training in order to be able to work as a member of the primary healthcare team. The role of the Health Visitor is about the promotion of health and the prevention of illness in all age groups. Health visitors carry out a range of different work.

  2. Substance Use During Pregnancy

    The central nervous system and the brain grow throughout pregnancy and are affected no matter what stage alcohol is consumed. Claire Coles also stated, " [...] maternal alcoholism and heavy drinking during pregnancy are associated with readily observable physical defects, called dysmorphia; reduced growth; and damage to the fetus' nervous system.".

  1. People with learning disabilities experience loss and bereavement - Analyse how services might support ...

    The concept of 'normalisation' began to influence the delivery of care for people with learning disabilities during the 1980s. Normalisation theory recognised institutions as a major barrier to inclusion and emphasised the unique value of the individual, their right to choice and opportunity, and their right to extra support needed to fulfil their potential (Mencap, 2002).

  2. Throughout my essay I am going to study and look at the work of ...

    Before Simpson's discovery surgery had to be fast and efficient. But despite all the efforts patients often died due to exceptional pain and the lack of medical help. Chloroform diminished any feeling in order to prevent any such pain. Within days Simpson was using chloroform to ease the pains of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work