• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assignment B: Stalin: Man or Monster

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Stalin: Man or Monster? Study sources A, B, C. Do these sources give similar or different impressions of Stalin? Explain your answers with references to the sources. Source A shows an anti-humanitarian side of Stalin which shows the deaths of many Russians. Stalin seems to advertise them as a kind of tourist attraction. This was drawn by enemies of Stalin who were in exile in Paris. The skulls show the victims of the purges as it was drawn in the 1930's which were ordered by Stalin because of his paranoia. Source B is propaganda portraying Stalin in a positive way, as the man who whilst being friendly with the workers whilst also being an efficient leader by building a dam (the Dnieprostroi dam) which is made to look very modern. The fact that Stalin is smoking shows that while he has built a huge dam he also has the time to relax and be communist, talking with his workers and be an equal. However, he is dressed in white which indicates that he his angelic and not equal to the workers around him. It also shows Stalin in the middle focusing attention on him, not as an equal to his workers. Source C shows Stalin as a large figure perhaps more than a man. ...read more.

Middle

However, source F shares a view that is very much against Stalin. It was written in 1936 by Bukharin, at that time an enemy of Stalin after the losses of key Bolsheviks who were killed in the 'Purges'. Bukharin himself was a victim and was tried and executed in 1938. The author of source E is unknown but seeing how extreme it is, ' the first word it shall utter will be: Stalin' and how we now know of the terrible murders of the 1930's this is quite unbelievable and may have been written by the Bolsheviks as propaganda since it appeared in the party newspaper, Pravda. Bukharin had been betrayed by Stalin after he helped Stalin to become the leader over Trotsky. Not only Bukharin but Zinoviev and Kamanev, former allies of Stalin were said to be traitors to communism during the Purges and were executed. Source F can therefore be seen as reliable with Bukharin stating that Stalin was 'not a man, but a devil'. Stalin was regarded as a very suspicious man which is also stated in source F. Even though we now see that Stalin was a tyrant, people in Russia may still have seen him as a very successful and powerful man. We can see this from his propaganda. ...read more.

Conclusion

Stalin did erase all the Kulaks by 1934. Collectivisation did not achieve a lot only human lives. Stalin did not seem to care However, on the other hand Stalin did successfully make Russia a leading industrial power. His five year plans could be argued to have saved the Soviet Union from the Nazis. Stalin successfully used Russia's rich raw materials to his advantage. Unemployment was almost non-existent. Women were allowed to work (40% of workers) and bonuses were given for overachieving. Even with his great successes, the human cost was huge. Discipline in factories was harsh with punishments including death. Workers were not allowed to travel between cities and there were many deaths. 100000 people died in the Belamor canal, the same may have died during the making of the dam in source B. You can see from source C the might of Stalin's industrial Russia but you don't see the human cost that was made to make it. Stalin in his time was seen by many as a good leader this may have been upheld by fear of his labour camps and his secret police; he did get the job done. He is however, without doubt, a tyrant who killed many men to achieve his goals and stay in power. Source I shares my view that even if he was a successful leader, he did have 'a dark and evil side to his nature'. ?? ?? ?? ?? Ben Clarke ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. 'The Five Year Plans brought glory to Stalin and misery to his people.' How ...

    ran his own secret police, courts, and was able to sentence anyone who was against the Communist revolution. He sent people to labour camps, were they were treated as slaves, and working in harsh conditions. Overall Stalin improved the quality of life in Russia, new hospitals, new cinemas better education for the young.

  2. Stalin Man or Monster

    the reader to sympathise and understand that he has been through an unpleasant life. He goes on to say that when 30 men went to the river to carry out a timber and returned with just 29. It is important to note that he uses the word 'comrade', this is a communist word for brother.

  1. These three sources do not all give the same impression of Stalin. Source A ...

    The main message of this source is to show that Stalin already set the outcome of the show trials and there was nothing anyone could do about it. Source J is of a cartoon published in France in the late 1930s. The cartoon shows what happens in the show trial.

  2. Assess the Impact Stalin Had On Russia and Its People Stalin came to ...

    The development that took place could not have been done by any other method, other than slave labour. Therefore, the purges did provide slave labour which benefited Russia as a country but did not benefit the Russian people. Though, the purges did cause for there being a lot of problems for Russia and the Russian people.

  1. Stalin: Man Or Monster?

    There are two main interpretations of this source. One interpretation is that the writer truly believes what he is saying and didn't see (or chose to ignore) the darker side of Stalin's personality. At this time the purges and show trials were just starting and it is hard to believe that anyone who really knew the horror of what Stalin was doing would write like this man did.

  2. Stalin man or monster

    Source C portrays amongst a crowd the wives of army officer cheering and commending Stalin. This could be because of Propaganda in order to encourage more women to work as there was a shortage of workers. Thus the government concentrated on drafting more women into industry.

  1. China 1945-90 - source based questions.

    However, he was permitted to keep his Party membership at the personal request of Mao. On 9th September, 1976, Mao himself died. Mao's death was not exactly unexpected, but nonetheless, the reality of it hit the country hard. Where China was to go, and who was to lead her was the burning question.

  2. Russia - Stalin

    Before the funeral, Stalin tricked Trotsky into not coming by telling him the wrong date and then people think that Trotsky could not be bothered to turn up and begin to dislike him. This then gives an advantage to Stalin, who then made a stirring speech praising Lenin and saying he was his disciple.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work