• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Consider the arguments for and against the claim that the causes of the Great Depression were long term.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Consider the arguments for and against the claim that the causes of the Great Depression were long term. The Great Depression is one of the most debated topics in modern world history and the causes are greatly discussed. People thought that things were going along quite nicely in the USA during the 1920s until Thursday October 24th 1929, the first day of the Wall Street Crash and the beginning of one of the fiercest economic depressions ever seen. One of the main features of the Great Depression was the collapse of the farming industry with many farmers going bankrupt and their property being repossessed. This was because farmers couldn't afford to run their businesses anymore with the price of wheat plunging from a mighty $2 per bushel at the end of the war to a miserly 51 cents at the height of the depression. Many historians have argued that the demise in farming came about very quickly and that the causes were short term. During the war American agriculture was booming due to the opportunity to supply food to the disrupted European market and after the end of conflict in 1918 European agriculture picked up meaning that the American farmers were over producing. It has been said by historians that the end of World War One acted as a short-term trigger causing a capitulation in the farming industry. This can be illustrated by the fact that between the years of 1919 and 1921, total farm income catapulted from $10 billion to $4 billion. ...read more.

Middle

The 'seven years of plenty' were over and a period of economic depression was about to begin. By the end of that year they had been proved right. Moreover, historians such as Galbraith have said that the infrastructure of the American economy was not strong enough to support such rapid expansion. Some historians have placed great emphasis on the way much of the boom was fuelled by "Get Rich Quick" schemes. Between the years of 1925 and 1929 many Americans went "Wall Street Crazy". Shares could be bought "on the margin" and more and more people were buying shares as a short term speculation rather than as a long term investment in a company. The market value of all stocks catapulted from $27 billion in 1925 to a whopping great $87 billion by October 1929. Many share prices rose spectacularly such as the Radio Corporation of America whose shares went from 85 to 420 just in the course of 1928. This speculation relied almost solely on confidence, something which cannot last forever. Therefore speculators were bound to sell their shares when confidence dropped and share prices would fall catastrophically. This is what happened in the Wall Street Crash. Galbraith argued that the American economy relied too much on confidence and a belief that everybody could become rich. Obviously this optimism could not last forever and a depression was inevitable. This viewpoint could suggest that the causes of the depression were mainly short term in that a lot of people lost confidence very quickly following ...read more.

Conclusion

The coal industry suffered new competition from more modern energy sources, most notably oil. The cotton industry also suffered because of modernisation with the introduction of synthetic fibres. The changes in young women's fashion also meant that fewer textiles were needed to make clothes. This caused an increase in unemployment as the textile mills of the north could not compete in a shrinking market with the southern mills, which employed cheap labour and longer hours. The unemployment caused by the closure of mills further reduced confidence and helped lead to the depression. In conclusion, the long term problems such as the overproduction in farming, the problems with the banking system, the uneven distribution of income and the decline of old industries are more important causes than the short term problems. The stock market would not have been able to rise so steeply had it not been for the way banks gave out credit so easily, causing confidence not to have got so high in the first place. If the income had not been so unevenly distributed then the short term loss of confidence which triggered the depression would perhaps not have happened so easily due to the fact that people's financial situations would not have been so precarious. The short term factors were not as important because of the fact that they were results of the long term problems in America. One thing that is evident throughout this period is the fact that not many economists and politicians at the time knew enough about modern economies to predict the depression and maybe prevent it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1919-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1919-1941 essays

  1. Explain the Causes and Effects of the Great Depression.

    The situation was so bad that during the same period, 5% of the population earned 33% of incomes (socialstudieshelp.com, 2002). As time passed, the gap only grew. Working class Spending was falling whilst production was increasing, thus resulting in the overproduction of consumer goods.

  2. The crash (causes and consequences of the Wall Street Crash)

    Yet the Crash affected the vast majority of American people because there were serious weaknesses underlying the US economy. However, you must be careful in saying that the crash led to the depression. This is unlikely. American business was simply too big and too diverse to be affected by the crash in that way.

  1. (Q1) Describe some of the key features of Americn society in the 1920's?

    The crime rate of America seemed to be on the rise and more people where being arrested for being drunken and disorderly and for drink driving. By 1925, in a single year, Americans drank 200,000,000 gallons of sprits, 685,000,000 gallons of malt liquor and 118,000,000 gallons of wine.

  2. Explain how both the long-term and the short-term causes contributed to the great depression ...

    In the years just after the war the European countries especially France could not grow food from their land because there was so much lead sown into it from bombs and bullets. The high tariffs from both sides made it impossible for any export trade what so ever.

  1. The Wall Street crash, the great depression and its how it affected the lives ...

    Obviously this caused a lack of profit and a lot of poverty in the countryside. During the post World War 1 farming boom their lands had expanded because the government had encouraged them to buy more lands and to modernise their methods.

  2. 'The causes and effects of the great depression caused equal suffering to all of ...

    This extract is biased because it does not give a reflective view of the economic situation at the time and it suggests that that Great Britain was not affected by a depression and in fact the economy improved. It is very generally clearly fails to address the regional variations.

  1. The Great Depression 1929-33: A Sources Assignment

    This is a typical story of what happened to many working-class men during the Depression. They spent their lives working hard for a better life but the suffered worst during a Depression that was not their fault. This makes the song seem accurate as this actually happened to many people.

  2. What caused the great depression?

    For instance, one person would buy another's shares using credits, that person now would sell the shares to another person who pays with them with borrowed money. The second person would not pay the first back. It all operated from banks, which were willing to loan money.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work