• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How useful are the sources A-I to a historian studying the main causes and events of the demonstration in Tiananmen Square June 1989?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

China In The Twentieth Century Question 1 - How useful are the sources A-I to a historian studying the main causes and events of the demonstration in Tiananmen Square June 1989? On the 22nd of April 1989, Chinese students collected together at Tiananmen Square to pay respects to Hu Yaobang, the students saw this as an opportunity to protest for democratic reform. Little did these students know this protest would end with tragic results. Deng blamed Hu Yaobang, a member of the Deng Xiaoping communist party, when students protested for political reform. Due to this he lost his position in the government but still remained in the politburo. His death on 15th April sparked the Tiananmen movement. Sources A, F and G are from books. Source A, the background to the Tiananmen Square incident from China in the 20th Century written in 1990 by Harriet Ward, a British Historian, who, unlike some Chinese sources controlled by government, has freedom of speech. The book gives a general overview of one hundred years in China, which suggests that the information gathered, could be considered vague and facts possibly have been overlooked, which of course would reduce the source's reliability. ...read more.

Middle

Sources E and D are both sources from newspapers. Source E: The events of 4th June 1989 from a report in the Sunday times in 1989, a British newspaper. The reporter has freedom of speech and cannot be controlled by the government unlike some Chinese sources. This is a primary source and therefore reliable due to the fact that it is an eyewitness report by the reporter, Louise Branson, who was in Beijing at the time. The information is stark and certainly anti-Chinese government, and only gives one side of the story, which could be considered as reducing the report's reliability. This is a very useful source in showing the events that took place at Tiananmen Square. Source D: The students believe they have won from Tiananmen, The rape of Peking 1989, a book published by the British newspaper, The Independent. This source is very useful in explaining the causes and events of Tiananmen Square. It is reliable due to the fact that it was written the same year as the incident; this suggests that the information is correct and up to date. The Independent, has a reputation for well researched, fair, and unbiased reporting. ...read more.

Conclusion

This is a useful version of the Tiananmen Square incident because a reliable British newspaper has published an objective report of events. Source E is an extract from a report in a British Newspaper, The Sunday Times (4th June 1989). It differs from source D because the reporter, who is British, was in Beijing at the time of the Tiananmen Square events. The report is most likely unbiased because it is written by a reporter from a western society. Its value is increased because it is an eye witness report. Source F, an extract from China, A New Revolution (1990) written by an American Historian, John Bradley. It is similar in sentiment to source D because it is against the Chinese government. It is a second hand account because he was not there at the time the events took place. His overall view is that the events that took place in Tiananmen Square have had a detrimental effect on the Chinese Democracy movement. Source G, an extract from the book The Truth about the Beijing Turmoil differs from sources D-F because it was written and published in the People's Republic of China. The book toes the official Chinese Communist Party line. Protest was effectively ended and although China has modernised and, to some extent westernised, democracy is as far away as ever. Lewis Morrison - 10DG 14/07/07 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. What were the causes of Indian Independencein 1947, and was partition inevitable?

    how the British were beginning to give in, but also how important and influential Gandhi was. By this point independence was probably inevitable, and this cause was a further step in its direction. The Round Table conferences began in November 1930 as it was clear that the Dyarchy system was not working and a new system was needed.

  2. How useful is a visit to the Tudor parts of Hampton Court to find ...

    Henry ignored the decline of the old Great Halls and built one in Hampton Court. I believe he did this because he wanted to impress foreign ambassadors and members of court and one way to do this was to build a Great Hall that was extremely impressive.

  1. How useful is visible evidence in explaining the development of power at Styal Mill ...

    the intention of using them, and so we can assume that there was a gas system installed in and around the building. The only evidence we have to support gas power actually being used to power the mills machinery is in the form of a gas turbine engine.

  2. WWII research report D-day invasions

    execution of the amphibious assault landing, and the multiple outcomes of the landings on D-Day. I. Prepartion for the D-Day Landings A. Reconnaissance 1. Photo-reconnaissance a. Photo-reconnaissance for a full year 2. Air superiority a. Spitfire gas tank range 3. Enviroment a. Terrain studies and soil samples b. Weather (2).

  1. Free essay

    How did Mao ze Dung and Deng Xieoping contribute to the history of China?

    When Mao was practicing his health scheme, he decided to tell everyone to collectively kill what he thought were the three enemies of hygiene, rats, flies and sparrows. Each person must kill a certain amount of days, if they didn't they got fined, if they killed more, they had a bonus.

  2. Free essay

    History medcine overview

    So along with the changing attitude towards letting women getting the vote came, the change of attitude towards women in medicine. There were also other influences such as the shortage of doctors in Britain. Many were asking themselves if the country could actually to afford excluding women.

  1. How reliable and useful is the evidence about Stoke Bruerne?

    As the source match in their content, I judge the reliable. The historian uses the source because they want to know what the people have done to the canal of which is traffic and they want it to speed things up.

  2. Life In The Trenches - research and evaluation of the sources

    From my knowledge I know that trenches were not designed, they were just dug wherever they could be, in zigzagged lines. They had to be the right size, because if they were too big, then fewer trenches would be able to fit in the allocated area.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work