• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

russia: what happened to the romanov family question 1 and 2

Extracts from this document...


Russia what happened to the Romanov family Question A A) Sources A and B give similar accounts. Does this mean they are reliable? Source A and B give similar accounts of what happened to the Romanov family. They both state that they believe the tsar , Dr Botkin, two servants and the maid were shot in the Ipatiev house. Source A is a report from an American newspaper and it tells us that Judge Sergeyev investigated the murder of the Romanov family and he believes there was a murder, and it happened in the lower storey of the building, although Sergeyev also believes that not all the members of the household were shot there. He believes "the Tsar, the family doctor, the two servants and the maid were all shot in the Ipatiev house" [source A], however he believes that "Empress, the Tsar's son and four other children" [source A] were not shot there. The fault with this source is that as it was written for a newspaper, Sergeyev may not have actually said this it could just be the journalists interpretation on what was actually said. ...read more.


Source A and B are similar in that the information in both originate from Sergeyev. The sources are different in that Source B is more open-minded than Source A. Both sources A and B suggest say the Tsar, the family doctor (Dr Botkin), two servants and the maid were all shot in the Ipatiev house. Sources A and B are both taken from what judge Sergeyev had said, it is therefore not surprising that the sources are similar. Although source A and B give similar accounts this does not necessarily mean that they are reliable ,as the information in the sources have been orientated from the same place. However, by cross-referencing to other sources I can find evidence information that supports what both Source A and B are saying. b) How far does the account in source C differ from those in sources A and B? Sources A and B are similar to C because that they all say that people were killed in the basement of the Ipatiev house. ...read more.


Source C is written in a way that makes the murders seem very horrific using powerful words such as "the bloody carnage" and "Massacred", words like these could suggest that the judge was not impartial. The reason for this is possibly because Judge Sokolov was appointed by the 'Whites'. Having said this Source C appears to be the most reliable evidence in terms of key facts being mentioned in other sources for instance Pavel Medvedev also talking about the family being taken by lorries in his interview. In comparison Source B is written with uncertainty but seemingly impartially. Source C has more differences than similarities to source A and B as it includes many opinions in it. Source A and b are uncertain accounts whereas source C sure that the family were killed. Sergeyev's report was not biased enough this is more than likely to be the reason as to why he was sacked and source B is unbiased whereas as source C is very biased and makes the 'reds' look bad. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. China 1945-90 - source based questions.

    Agriculturally Mao had introduced the 'Agrarian Reform Act' the communes he set up were strictly controlled, people had to work when they were told to and to grow what was given to them. Deng abolished the communes, people were allowed to charge prices and grow crops of their own choice.

  2. Stalin Sources Questions

    Stalin's tactic was to issue the suspect with an ultimatum saying that he would kill them at a "show trial" under the offence of treason. If the suspect admitted guilty to treason then he alone would be killed but if he admitted not guilty then himself and all his known relatives would be killed.

  1. What happened to the Romanov family? - Study Sources A and B. Sources A ...

    Furthermore, looking at the Sources A and B from a different perspective, from the context of origin and purposes, it can be deduced that both sources contain information originate from and are influenced by Judge Sergeyev. The Whites were mainly Tsar's military supporters but also all the opponents of the Bolscheviks or the Reds.

  2. What happened to the Romanov Family? - Sources A and B give similar accounts. ...

    In particular, source J greatly contradicts the evidence given in sources A and B. Source J affirms that the Tsarina and three of the royal daughters were found at the burial site implying that they were killed with the Tsar, unless for some reason they were killed at a different

  1. Stalin Sources Question

    Explain your answer. Source E is from the communist newspaper Pravda. This newspaper would be used as a tool of propaganda; therefore only good and positive stories towards Stalin would be published. It would be biast towards Stalin. This source is 100% over flattering towards Stalin.

  2. Stalin: Man or Monster - Sources Questions

    The opposition was not legal, and usually consisted of individual people, such as writers, doctors etc. These however were quickly removed. On the other hand the source may not be fully reliable as we can sense almost anger and exaggeration; this would probably be because of the way Stalin treated Bukharin.

  1. What Happened To The Romanov Family?

    reliability in his own right means that both differ to a large extent considering Sergeyev's input. Source B also contains additional information, which could improve its reliability but when comparing with Source A which does not include this, it makes me question both sources reliability.

  2. Stalin Question 3

    The Soviet government introduced a policy of collectivisation on farms. This meant that farms were handed over to the state and larger farms, worked by many families, formed. Some farmers liked this idea, since it would improve efficiency and allow them to buy modern equipment such as tractors.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work