• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The Long March was a Great Retreat" what evidence is there to support or contradict this interpretation of the Long March?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Question 5: "The Long March was a Great Retreat" what evidence is there to support or contradict this interpretation of the Long March? Explain your answer using both the sources and your own knowledge A retreat is a withdrawal of a military force from a dangerous position or from an enemy attack. The above quote originates from source C and as such portrays purely a GMD view on the significance of the Long March, which is therefore bound to be a negative view. However the Long March undeniably had a great long term impact, as the communist ideals formed by Zedong now form the basis for China's constitution. Therefore it is questionable as to how much The Long March really was a 'Great Retreat' if such an outcome was achieved. Though how far do the other sources and my own knowledge help to contradict or support this view? Interestingly, the word 'Great' can be interpreted differently depending on the view of the historian. For example it could be seen that the Long March was a beneficial retreat and that the word 'Great' is a positive way of describing the March. However it could also be seen that the Long March was 'Great' in the terms of the size of the retreat and is therefore not such a positive thing as source C demonstrates. ...read more.

Middle

Therefore, as an isolated year it is undeniable that the Long March began as a retreat, yet how far did this continue, and when did it cease to be a retreat? The answer can be obtained when analysing Source C. A key date which is vital to the interpretation of the Long March is 1935, when the CCP reached Zunyi and assessed their position. At this point the focus of the Long March altered, it was no longer a retreat as they had reached their destination. From here the aim of the March became to unite peasants against the GMD, the retreat can be seen as over. From Zunyi onwards the Long March became things Zedong referred to in Source G; propaganda, a message and a seeding machine. However the motive of this Source should be taken into consideration, as Zedong may have glorified his version of the Long March. Thus lessening the focus on the fact it began as a retreat. After the March was seen by historians such as Graham Hutchings as a 'road to victory', rather than a retreat. Hutchings also believed that the CCP's area of control was expanding, which contradicts directly with the definition of retreat, as determined by Source C. ...read more.

Conclusion

The Long March can only be seen as a victory in a modern context, as China, a communist country has been accepted by the world and this is evidenced through the fact they will be holding the Olympics in 2008 and how Mao's face remains on all currency in China. In conclusion, the Long March was both a retreat and a road to victory yet neither could have been possible without the other. The initial retreat was inescapable, but at the same time can be seen as an example of tactical excellence on Mao's part as it allowed him to generate the support he needed. Hence it would be incorrect to assume that the word 'Great Retreat' always has negative associations for the CCP, especially as Source C portrays the Long March as negative. This retreat proved beneficial in the end. Once the CCP had reached Zunyi this was the turning point. The March was no longer a Great Retreat but became a long-term road to victory. Here it altered into the seeding machine Mao referred to, and this fact is proven by the fact the CCP were victorious and communist theories are still in practice today. WORD COUNT: 1172 OVERALL WORD COUNT: 3917 ?? ?? ?? ?? Rebecca Sigrist 11T History 01/03/2007 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE International relations 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE International relations 1945-1991 essays

  1. CriticismCrisisEvidence For Evidence Against

    They attempted to punish the aggressor, Poland, and afterwards attempted to enforce the decision. Upper Silesia 1921 There seems to be no obvious evidence that the members acted in their own interest. However, when they created a watched safeguard between Poland and Germany it is possible for them to exploit the information they may gather from there.

  2. THE GREAT LEAP FORWARD 1958-62

    Why did Mao put so much emphasis on the masses? Mao understood that the masses gave him power because when the other leaders wanted his resignation, the masses supported him, so he stayed in power. What evidence is there that the masses were mobilized successfully?

  1. How did Mao Zedong secure control of China in the 1950's?

    Just 2 out of 29 ministers were female. Peasants also received land of their own, what they had always wanted. This was called the Land Reform. To conclude this section, Mao improved the life of many Chinese people by introducing these laws, but there was still a very long way to go.

  2. In February 1943, the German army surrendered at Stalingrad. Was Hitler's interference the main ...

    Hitler, while many factors can be attributed to him, was clearly not the sole cause of defeat at Stalingrad. There were many other factors, including Zhukov's tactics which exploited German weaknesses; Zhukov surrounded Von Paulus's army with a fresh force who were not weary like the 6th army, and effectively created a secure perimeter around them.

  1. Why the CCP won the civil war

    Chiang ignored this threat, saying that the Japanese were a disease of the skin; which could be cured. Communism is a disease of the soul that affects the whole body. Chiang was obviously more interested in defeating the Communists than actually fighting foreign invaders.

  2. Castro's revolution: WOMEN

    These women then became instructors to nearly 29,000 peasant women, greatly expanding the traditional role of the Cuban women and greatly enlarging their options outside of the home. First aid training was given to 11,000 women and the FMC managed over one hundred day care centers.

  1. Cold War Short Essays - Questions and Answers.

    In conclusion, all of these reasons led to a change in relations. However, the most significant reason was because of the INF treaty. This showed that both superpowers were willing to slow down the Arms Race and focus on

  2. Do you agree with the assessment that Mao was nothing other than a ruthless ...

    The First Five Year Plan was a success as outputs were even more than planned which helped to push China forward as an industrial nation. Also, in the Great Leap Forward although many died it would be wrong to blame Mao for it all.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work