• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Tsarist rule in the years 1856 - 1917 and Communist rule from the death of Lenin to the death of Stalin both depended on high degrees of central power and control by the state. The similarities between the two forms of government were therefore much g...

Extracts from this document...


Tsarist rule in the years 1856 - 1917 and Communist rule from the death of Lenin to the death of Stalin both depended on high degrees of central power and control by the state. The similarities between the two forms of government were therefore much greater than were the differences. How far do you agree with this judgement? It cannot be denied that both Tsarist and Soviet government did indeed rely on a high degree of central power and state control. However, the statement incorrectly follows that "therefore" the two regimes had more similarities than differences. The fact that the period 1856 - 1917 involved the rule of Alexander II, Alexander III and Nicholas II meant three different styles of rule, and ultimately different levels of state repression. However, since both the communist and Tsarist regimes faced similar difficulties, the sheer size of Russia and the ever present problems with agriculture, for example, they both inevitably had similar aims. Both regimes wished to modernize Russia, while preserving their own position of authority and prevent Western intervention. However, the methods each regime used to do this and the results of these methods differed between them. The motives of their aims also varied - Stalin had a political motivation for isolation from the West (communism versus capitalism), whilst the Tsar wished to preserve Russian tradition and symbolism. ...read more.


This certainly does not explain the irrelevance of the Soviets during his reign, but his attitude varies with the Tsar, who probably simply resented handing any of his God-given power to other authorities. The fact that Stalin personally signed every order of execution issued during the purges outlines the level of his involvement. It should also be remembered that despite the reforms and slight de-centralisation of power that can be seen under Alexander II, 1882 84 saw counter - reforms, and after his assassination in 1881, temporary regulations gave the police extra power to crush revolutionary activity - displaying similar attitudes to Communism - that ultimately the people needed to be repressed, not encouraged in order to ensure compliance. This is seen in Stalin's reaction to the peasant's stubbornness in response to Collectivisation, for example. The Orthodox Church was undoubtedly very important for the Tsar. It almost helped legitimize his claim that the Tsar possessed a God-given right to rule the country, and justified the autocratic nature of Tsarist rule. Particularly by the peasants, the Tsar was seen as a "father figure." However, by the early twentieth century, the overall opinion of the Russian people, now becoming increasingly educated, was that this claim was no longer as legitimate as it had once been considered. ...read more.


The use of press censorship, the military and general oppression by both regimes are strikingly similar, despite different motives. Neither the Soviets, nor the Zemstvos had any sort of power or influence, and the fact that the regimes were running such a massive country from either Moscow or St. Petersburg itself suggests a central state control. Both the Tsar, as a result of his divine right, and Stalin, due to self interest and paranoia, totally ruled everything in Russia, and any power designated elsewhere was never a significant amount. Although Stalin ensured that the following was not the case, the role of the leader was not integral to the ideology of Marxism, unlike in Tsarism. After the fall of Khrushchev, there was collective leadership, suggesting the central control exercised by Stalin within the Communist Party was indeed a part of his cult of personality. It can also be said that overwhelmingly the similarities between the two forms of government do outweigh the differences. Differences are often subtle or arise due to a variation of motivation. However, the question focuses on the degree of dependence of central control and power by the state, thus any other differences focusing on other subjects have not been examined, and so a response to the second part of this statement can only be based on the subjects referred to in the question. Words - 2181 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Russia, USSR 1905-1941 essays

  1. The fall of Tsarism in Russia.

    This situation could be compared with Great Britain, however they had introduced the Defense of the Realm Act which granted the government complete control over the economy and its planning through the Ministry of Munitions. This furthermore hammers down on the point that Tsarism was outdated.

  2. 'The Five Year Plans brought glory to Stalin and misery to his people.' How ...

    Nonetheless, many criminals were now being made to work so hard that it would stop other people from committing a crime. However during his reign I personally believe that there were probably more things that brought miserly to the Russian people than there were to bring them comfort.

  1. How did Stalin control Russia from 1924-1953?

    In order to industrialise Russia, Stalin had to provide the towns and workers with food. He thought this was vital, because the population of the industrial centres was growing rapidly.

  2. "The Governments of both late Tsarist Russia and early Communist Soviet Union were essentially ...

    the Russian people, and thus autocracy and almost dictatorial power were their god-given rights. It is questionable whether either regime was truly dictatorial anyway. Perhaps there was a dictatorship of Party Leadership by Lenin within the Communist party. The Tsar wasn't able to rule Russia on his own, due to its sheer scale and diversity of people.

  1. Stalin and Lenin

    Factories, mines, transport and farms. The government high extremely strict disciplines over the work forces, ordinary workers were harshly punished and poor output and absence from work only made things worse. Millions of peasants were moved from the country side to cities and towns in order to work in factories

  2. Why did the Tsarist regime fall in 1917?

    then it would not be unreasonable to suggest that the camera could simply be brought closer and closer to the men, until they filled the entire picture. They may have wanted to do this for several reasons. Mainly, they could have shown this picture to the Tsar (via newspapers)

  1. How true is it to say that Stalin effectively removed opposition to the exercise ...

    The purges were the attempts to 'clean-up' the party so that unworthy party members who only joined for their own advantage were expelled. They were also attempts to ensure the party members were loyal, dedicated and active. Whereas 'The Terror' is the name given to the use of fear by Stalin to control the population and to remove his opponents.

  2. Why was Lenin able to seize power in October 1917?

    Alexis had inherited a rare blood disease Haemophilia. In 1905 Alexandra employed a man called Rasputin that was said to have special powers to stop bleeding and pain, to look after Alexis. However people noticed something unusual about his eyes and that Rasputin was a heavy drinker and that he fascinated women.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work