• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why is itdifficult to give an accurate picture of what happened on Bloody Sunday?

Extracts from this document...


Why is it difficult to give an accurate picture of what happened on Bloody Sunday? The true events on bloody Sunday are concealed beneath contradictions, false statements and biased opinions, the result being that neither side are able to agree on the order of events. The points they do agree on are: That the events took place on Sunday 30th January, 1972. It was a march made up of catholic protesters, to protest against internment, imprisonment where prisoners can be hooded during interrogation, continuous noise and sleep depravation, carried out by the British Army. The army was stationed in Chamberlain Street and Little James Street to block off the march. 26 barriers were put up in total to contain it within the Bogside. A bullet, from which side is disputed, hit a drainpipe. 13 people were killed and 14 were wounded.The army commander is quoted as saying 'An arrest force is to be held centrally behind the checkpoints and launched in a scoop up operation to arrest as many hooligans as possible'. ...read more.


The catholic view that the victims were innocent is arguable, even with the forensics. The claims made by the Catholics that have been backed up with forensic evidence can be disputed without making the evidence itself wrong in any way. For example, the evidence says that Gerald Donaghey's hands were in the air when he was shot doesn't necessarily mean he was holding his hands in the air as an act of surrender. He could have been brandishing a firearm or throwing a bomb when he was shot. Also if you were a soldier who had been under months and possibly years of fire and you saw someone throw their arms in the air your reflex action would be to shoot them. Another piece of evidence suggests the army planted a bomb on William Nash because he had lead deposits on his right hand, although he was left-handed. This too could be disputed, as he may have been holding the bomb in his right hand and a firearm or other bomb in his left hand, or simply held the lead bomb in his other hand without thinking about it. ...read more.


Stones were thrown (as shown in video footage) and the soldiers were taunted. The troops went after the rioters who ran away after seeing the support company approach. After the first shot, most likely fired by the IRA from a block of flats (giving way to the possibility of more snipers and gunmen). From the army's perspective, they were told to expect trouble from an illegal march, when they were shot at and petrol bombed by gun wielding Catholics. From the civilians view, they were on a peaceful march that turned into a massacre of innocent civilians, not gun wielding fiends taking pot shots at the army. It is very difficult to give an accurate picture of what really happened on Bloody Sunday, shown in the Saville Inquiry, costing �130 million, which has spent years collating statements, physical evidence and expert opinion to create an accurate picture of the events. Most of the evidence is speculation, and largely opinionated so this creates another obstacle blocking the truth. It is hard to know if a witness is reliable, even more so in a situation where the two sides are so bitterly divided. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

  1. Sunday January On 30, 1972, in an incident since known as Bloody Sunday, twenty-seven ...

    By about 4.05 pm most people had moved to 'Free Derry Corner' to attend the meeting.At 4.07 pm an order was given for a 'sub unit' of the 1st Battalion Parachute Regiment to move into William Street to begin an arrest operation directed at any remaining rioters.

  2. Explain why Bloody Sunday Happened.

    People were not allowed to leave their homes for 35 hours and tear gas was used. Now the army looked like the enemy for too many Nationalists.

  1. What Happened at Sharpeville on 21st March 1960?Massacre or Self-Defence?

    Although, these two sources were describing the same incident, both writers always managed to deflect the blame onto the other party. Source A saw the police as having reacted violently without provocation whilst, Source B saw their actions as necessary self-defence in the face of the aggressive crowd.

  2. Which of these two sources would a historian studying 'Bloody Sunday' find the more ...

    The source totally supports the view that the working and living conditions in St Petersburg were poor and, as it is written by the marchers, we know that this is why they are marching. Source D does not actually tell us why the marchers are there.

  1. The build up to Bloody Sunday, and why it happened.

    There was an instant increase of violent behaviour and 17 people were killed in the next 48 hours. Of these 10 Catholic civilians were shot dead by The British Army. There were more arrests in the following months. Internment was to continue until 5 December 1975.

  2. What happened on Bloody Sunday?

    The army, determined to get up-to-date intelligence, resorted to interrogation methods previously used in the former British colonies. Detainees thought likely to have important information were physically weakened through sleep deprivation and a bread and water diet. They were then spread-eagled for hours against a wall with hoods over their heads and subjected to disorientating electronic white noise.

  1. “Why has it proved so difficult to reach agreement about what happened on Bloody ...

    The use of "If anybody..." suggests that he is the one who saw everything. And it seems that he would have required good positioning to gather all the 'proof' that he did. This source is useful, but it would have been just to easy for an angered Catholic to have heard only shots from the other side.

  2. bloody sunday assignment 1

    was created. In this General election Sinn Fein was elected and claimed 73/105 seats. They had the choice to go for Home Rule, British Rule or Complete Independence. The vote was unanimous, they chose Complete Independence. This proved to be a major turning point.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work