• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Lay magistrates rarely have any experience of the law before they are appointed

Extracts from this document...


Magistrates The office of Justices of the Peace was first established over 600 years ago with the Justices of the Peace Act 1361 and Justices of the Peace or Lay Magistrates are essential to our legal system and try (or least deal with in some respect) 93% of all criminal cases and also perform an important function with regard to some civil areas. The role of the magistrates can be listed as follows:- > Trying summary offences > Trying offences triable either way where the accused elects for summary trial > Holding committal proceedings where the offence is TEW and the accused elects for jury trial. > Issuing summons, issuing search warrants and warrants for arrest. > Dealing with applications for bail > Dealing with applications for legal aid in criminal cases > Dealing with applications for licences such as firearms and liquor > Dealing with certain domestic matters such as maintenance orders etc. > Trying offences committed by youths in the Youth Court. Appointment Lay magistrates are appointed by the Minister of Constitutional Affairs on behalf of the Crown on the advice of a local advisory committee. These committees may either approach people or you can apply to become a magistrate. ...read more.


before the case is finally dealt with. This does not tend to be the case with District Judges (Magistrate Court). ii) Bias towards the Police - a criticism often raised against the lay magistrates is that tend to believe the evidence produced by the police without any hesitation which may be unfair on the accused. iii) Magistrates are not representative of the Community - the classic definition of lay magistrate has long been believed to be that they are "middle aged, middle classed and middle minded", but is this true? > Back in 1948 a Royal Commission on JP's found that 75% of all magistrates came from the professional or middle classes. The latest research carried out shows that this is still the case today. > Research into the political background of our lay magistrates shows that from a survey of 218 magistrates - 91 (42%) voted Conservative, 56 (26%) Labour, 41 (19%) Lib Dem, 30 (13%) other. > Only 4% of our lay magistrates are below the age of 40. From the research figures above it does seem to indicate that the description of a magistrate is correct but the question really to be asked is, does it matter? ...read more.


> Provide the Local Advisory Committees with updated details of the social make up of the local community so that they might bear this in mind when selecting new magistrates to their bench. b) Better training The present training of magistrates is a fault as there is insufficient training to obtain the consistency required. At the moment the majority of the training is done on the job and so if you are trained by a strict bench you will tend to become the same. This provides consistency among a particular bench itself but leads to variations between benches. The way to overcome this would be to have more and wider training (i.e. nationwide) but this would be expensive. c) Clearer guidelines At the moment magistrates have very wide discretion when passing sentences and thus allows magistrates flexibility but also inconsistency. If magistrates were to be given tighter guidelines and less discretion this might improve consistency. d) Replace magistrates entirely with District Judges (Magistrates Court) Some have suggested the abolition of lay magistrates in favour of professional magistrates. This would have the advantage of improved consistency and more efficient trials, but would lose the participation of lay persons, the local knowledge of issues and the relative cheapness of the lay magistrate to the system. There would also be the practical problem of where would you find all of these professional judges. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Law essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    In order to decide whether or not trial by jury should or should not ...

    4 star(s)

    That is to say jurors are not likely to become disenchanted by seeing the same type of case over and over. Until our judiciary is made up of a more representative sample of society, I would say that the risk of bias amongst the judiciary is far greater than that of a jury.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    abortion research

    4 star(s)

    Even if it were ethical to force women to carry pregnancies to term, it would not be ethical to force the birth of children who are unwanted and cannot be cared for. Women who choose to abort when they cannot be good mothers are making the most ethical choice open to them.

  1. Lay Magistrates.

    Applicant must be between 21 and 65 but applicant under 27 are not considered. This is a criticism of the selection procedure because the government wants to have younger people as Lay Magistrates but you have to be 27 so the government is being hypocritical.

  2. Criminal Law (Offences against the person) - revision notes

    The defendant has to plead diminished responsibility himself. * Stage 1 The defendant raises the defence (it needs to be supported by 2 medical experts) and, it has to be proven on the balance of probability * Stage 2 Once the defendant has raised the diminished responsibility the prosecution is

  1. What is an indictable offence and how is it brought to trial?

    There are three main ways in which this is evident. First, there is now an external body (or bodies, perhaps) competent to make laws affecting the United Kingdom, which are applied by the English courts irrespective of the wishes of Parliament.

  2. The Law Relating to Negotiable Instruments

    time is called a Muddati or Miyadi Hundi-the time bill of exchange. * Shah Jog Hundi A shah means a respectable and responsible person, a man of worth, and known in the bazar. A Shah Jog Hundi is payable to or through a shah.

  1. Critically evaluate the changes which have been made since 1990 to the definition of ...

    The proposal put forward was that there ought to be one legal position and the focus of the law should be on protection and criminal law should not interfere in the sexual behaviour of consenting adults.26 It was further recommended that the offence of rape should be extended to include fellatio (oral sex).

  2. Lay People

    are settled in the magistrates court but even when cases are sent up to the crown court three quarters of the defendants plea guilty anyway. There are two sides in a crown court case, the prosecution and the defence. The sides taking it in turns, begging with the prosecution, giving evidence to support their cases.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work