• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Consider the similarities and differences Between a TV news report and a TV Documentary Drama film of the same Incident

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Consider the similarities and differences Between a TV news report and a TV Documentary Drama film of the same Incident Here I will be discussing the similarities and differences, the responses and the power to shock inform and creature change for the before-mentioned drama documentary 'Warriors', and an 8-minute news clip broadcast at 23rd April 1993 by the BBC. The reporter was Martin Bell from the BBCM and it was shot on location at the village of Annichi (Bosnia). Warriors is a BBC Drama Documentary, filmed on location at the same place as the news report, and at about the same time. A 'Drama Documentary' is usually classified as a Documentary with dramatic elements, and which serves to entertain to a degree as well as inform. Both the news clip and Warriors aim to inform and educate. This can be backed up as the sole reason news programs exist for is to inform and educate, and Warriors is a Drama Documentary and documentaries exist to educate and inform, and to create change. Also not all things shown that are unsuitable for a universal audience are 'covered up', so they both inform and educate to a higher degree. To some degree is provides entertainment too, as some people enjoy scenes of violence as shown. ...read more.

Middle

In the news clip the camera is still and fixed most of the time, like when the reporter is talking the camera is fixed on him. Violence limits are higher for the drama documentary than the news clip, this can be proved because I don't think a shot was fired once in the news clip, yet in warriors there are quite a few gunshots, and a few people are dying too. In the news report acts of extreme violence are rarely displayed, as the main goal of 'news' reports are to inform. Hence 'Drama Documentaries' are generally allowed more, as they aim to educate, and sometimes violence is needed more. Another factor contributing to the limits are the BBC guidelines, which put restraints on any BBC content, such as the news clip. Another difference is the narrator. In the BBC news clip the narrator is the reporter, yet Warriors is completely without a Narrator. This may be because Warriors has characters, who talk amongst each other about what is going on, their feelings, etc, and that the news clip has no characters, so a narrator is needed. Another difference is the production times. Being a daily news report the news clip doesn't have much time to get filmed, in a way it is rushed, as some of the finer visual details are missing. ...read more.

Conclusion

That, however, greatly increases the shock at that moment. Building the tension up defiantly has an impact upon the shock. The 'Drama' part of 'Drama Documentary' can usually include shock, so it is not really a surprise to see it there. However, the news clip's main function is to inform, not create Drama. The only shock in the clip is the news itself, which the documentary shares. The drama documentary shows the audience more, and the music etc might tangle with the viewer's views. This could create change, but it might not be completely reliable. However, it could certainly change people's perceptions towards one of the sides, in Warriors it will make them side with the soldiers and the victims, as they are portrayed as the 'good guys who are fighting to save the defenseless inhabitants of Annichi.' A much wider audience views the news clip, and the reaction of the reporter himself could change someone's perception towards the incident. I think the drama documentary would be the greater at creating change, as it shows what really happened in a lot more detail, and what did happen would stimulate certain emotions which would certainly create change, the change might not just be very widespread. The drama documentary 'Warriors' defiantly educates, informs and shocks quite a bit better than the news clip, excluding the potential to create change, in which I think they are equal. Martyn Osborne ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Narrative section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Narrative essays

  1. "Sicko" by Michael Moore documentary film review

    Their hospitals are also completely free. You can stay for as long as you need, in Cuba they will not charge you a dime. How does the 9/11 rescue workers react when treated in a Cuban hospital? They burst out in tears of joy.

  2. James Bond - Bond(TM)s female characters are fully liberated women. They use Bond. Consider ...

    bit of enjoyment out of it he is still just using her to get what he wants. The difference is that she is a doctor so she is obviously quite intelligent, but even so she doesn't act professionally and is quite happy to be used by Bond.

  1. Compare the representation of ethnicity in a range of popular mainstream TV programmes or ...

    Her father was seen as abusive and a drunk. He was imprisoned as he attacked Denise in the time that he spent on the square. In Hollyoaks, the Black people that are in the soap are portrayed in a positive way as Calvin Valentine has a steady and influential job in the community as a police officer.

  2. How effective is X-Men at presenting the flawed hero and the sympathetic villain through ...

    Magneto is fearful and adamant that a repeat of the past will happen again and feels that there can be no compromise between mutants and humans, in his eyes they can never co-exist together. He plans to pursue an epic battle with humans and is determined to do anything in

  1. 'How is the recent broadcasting of the BBC documentary 'The Secret Policeman' relevant to ...

    'The perspective within which coloured people are presented as ordinary members of society has become increasingly overshadowed by a news perspective in which they are presented as a problem.'5 Teun. A. Van Dijk was highly influenced by Hartmann and Husband's early study of racism in the press which concluded the above labelling of Blacks.

  2. Analyse the ways that the director builds suspense and scares the audience in the ...

    Brody is distracted, causing him to become more anxious to see what was going on. However, the scream was meaningless, which was the first false alarm. The second false alarm was the old man and woman. The old man swam underneath the water and slowly rose, causing Chief Brody to

  1. Bias and Moral Panics in the News and the Effect on Policy.

    June 2002 a report reflecting a more favourable relationship between the authorities was completed by the Joint Working Party, it was titled 9/11: Implications for Communication. Its foundation was that dedication to public service was a shared responsibility of both the media and authorities in exceptional circumstances.

  2. First Year Psychology Students' Memory for The News as a Function of Media of ...

    scenes), but also means the individual does not need to pay attention as much, as no extra thinking must be done. When reading and to some extent listening to an article, the individual must think of the visual ingredient themselves, as this is not given.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work