• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11

Examining and discussing the quotation from Sontag's latest book Regarding the Pain of others to see if her statement is just in its implications.

Extracts from this document...


"An Image is drained of its force by the way that it is used, where and how often it is seen. Images shown on television are by definition images which, sooner or later, one tires. What looks like callousness has its origin in the instability of attention that television is organised to arouse and to satiate by surfeit of images." (Sontag,2003:105-6) Susan Sontag has been acclaimed to be "One of America's best known fictional writers, essayists and cultural critics" this and the last century. Born in New York City in 1933 she went on to study at philosophy at the University of Chicago only turning sixteen whilst she was there. Since that time, Sontag has gone on to accomplish many great achievements in writing both fictional and non-fictional texts as well as becoming an accomplished film-maker. As a critic she has been described as being influential, provocative and controversial. Her novels have been described as angular and devious, but at the same time 'ruled by special rationalism' (Hardwick, A Susan Sontag Reader, 1982). Sontag's first book was published in 1966 at the age of 33and was called "Against Interpretation". The book itself it was a collection of essays which had been printed in magazines and was almost a catalyst to dismiss her from being categorised as a purely fictional writer. Since that time Sontag has written many more essays and has released a large number of books, some of them collaborations with other writers and some on her own. One of her most notorious publications was the book On Photography (of which I will be discussing more in detail in this essay later) ...read more.


"Harrowing photographs do not inevitably lose their power to shock. But they are not much help the task is to understand. Narratives Can make us understand. Photographs do something else: they haunt us" (2003: 89) In this point, Sontag does concede to the fact that with photographs although they do have the power to shock us, photo's can be taken out of context because unless a photo belongs to the photographer the photo is timeless. By this I mean to the viewer the photo could have been from anytime or of any place. For example the photograph below depicts a large explosion in the background with some soldiers in the field in the foreground but you would be unable to distinguish when this photo was actually taken as it could have been from any war over the last 40 years. The viewer is given no more information on the subject and are therefore forced to use their imagination about where and what could be happening. In Regarding the Pain of the Dead Sontag concedes to the fact that photographs are 'anti-linear', that is to say that they do not have the linear existence as humans do. In order for photographs to have a linear existence they require annotation to provide the context for the photograph. Only by doing this does the photograph achieve a linear existence because it gives its audience a time period in which to place it in. "Movies and television programs light up walls, flicker and go out, but with the still photograph the image is still an object, lightweight, easy to carry about, accumulate, store" (Sontag, 1978: 3) ...read more.


it because I believe that I have seen the shot or similar shots too many times and therefore would be suffering from compassion fatigue. In conclusion I believe that in the most part Susan Sontag's understanding of the power of the still image is extremely well founded. I personally believe that the still image has a lot to offer the audience: it can capture people's imagination and give more strength to pictures than that of the moving image. Although it can be argued that television can give the audience a lot more variety and quantity of a subject whilst at the same time providing the narrative to explain its images, what it loses in detail of the event outweigh the other factors. For me, this decision came really because of the complete contrast of the Vietnam War footage of the street execution. Although an unpleasant and inhumane act carried out by the police chief, the photo was inexplicit and only suggested the act of violence, whereas the actual video showed it in its over explicit nature, which, after seeing it a few times although did still shock me, but showed no emotion: just a collection of images depicting death. I personally believe that you can tell more of a photograph than just a picture of something you have been witness to once - it can also create a 'flash bulb' memory, almost taking you back to that moment when the photo was taken. Sontag makes the point in her interview with the Boston review that writing a document is better than writing a novel because it is of a factual nature. She also then states that the interview that a photograph can have a greater effect then a document. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Audience and Production Analysis section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Audience and Production Analysis essays

  1. Compare the way cultural difference is represented in two films (East is East and ...

    This angers them as she stereotypes them to be criminals and dangerous. However, they turn out to be exactly that as they have guns and as a result, 'jack' the couple's car. The two of them do not accept the racism that was displayed towards them and thus they stole Jean and her husband's car in order to get revenge.

  2. The film I will be discussing is Dracula. The director of Dracula is Francis ...

    It may also be to symbolise that he is entering in to hell. It also signifies that the film is a horror and is meant to be daunting. At that moment eyes also appear in the sky; this would be to tell the audience Jonathan is being watched.

  1. Compare the representation of Britishness in the Metro Notting Hill Carnival article, the clip ...

    The language in the Notting Hill film clip is used to send a message about Britishness or Britain culture to its audience, by showing us the way people are with each other and how nice some people can be and that nothing bad can always happen.

  2. Documentry Photography

    From, the connotations of the image we can say that the photograph has been taken in the village Treng Bang while the Vietnam War on 8th June, 1972 when America attacked with Napalm bombs. The second photograph has a really dramatic effect on the viewer, as after seeing that naked girl we feel pity and helpless about the situation.

  1. How Steven Spielberg was able to convery the true horror of WWII in "Saving ...

    the wounded men screaming in pain and doing everything they can to just stay alive. The sheer horror really came across to me when the camera focuses on one particular man who is lying on his back, surrounded by his own intestines and crying out for his "mama" This shot

  2. Analysis of Top Gun

    But Stinger knows that he has a choice to make after Cougar's unlikely resignation. He confirms that Maverick and Goose will be going to Miramar, Fighter Town, USA to fly with the best of the best in the piloting business.

  1. Genre & Narrative

    They both have some kind of romantic storyline going on, although this is more in Sweet Home Alabama than in Gladiator. Both films have a happy ending, in Gladiator Maximums is reunited with his family after death and Melanie finally gets together with her true love.

  2. What makes the beginning of the film The Others an effective beginning of a ...

    become genuine to the audience. There are several narrative hooks in the opening ? which makes the audience wish to watch the rest of the film. Some are given full on in the beginning (Grace?s scream stirs up many questions, as mentioned above), and others are introduced slowly and regularly through the first few scenes.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work