• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the view that devolution, under the Good Friday Agreement, created a more democratic system than that which existed under direct rule.

Extracts from this document...


Assess the view that devolution, under the Good Friday Agreement, created a more democratic system than that which existed under direct rule. There are a vast amount of references, which all to some degree support the idea that the Good Friday Agreement (GFA) created a more democratic system of government. However invariably, as is often the case there are those who would argue that despite the GFA and subsequent devolution, a democratic deficit still exists. First I would like to examine the latter view, namely that devolution under the GFA has failed to provide a more democratic system, than the system, which existed previously under direct rule. Direct rule refers to the situation whereby the affairs of Northern Ireland (NI) are governed directly by the Westminster parliament. The governing authority is held by the appointed secretary of state, accompanied by Junior ministers, each of which are responsible for a particular government department for example Health or Education. As prime ministerial appointees, the secretary of state and the junior ministers where more often than not usually British. ...read more.


Despite such problems it is undeniable that the self-government and re-establishment of the NI parliament (The Assembly) provided by the GFA has come a long way in ensuring NI government is more balanced and inclusive due to its Consociationalist principles which is a political system formed by the cooperation of different social groups on the basis of shared power. The assembly itself is directly involved in government and ministers are nominated to government through an electoral system called the 'd'hondt' system whereby seats are won singly and indeed successfully on the basis of the highest average. This method requires that the number of seats awarded to each party in the assembly, be divided initially by one and thereafter by the number of Executive committee seats won by the party by one. This rather tedious system provides smaller parties with the opportunity of winning seats by means of 2nd and 3rd preference votes. In essence it is a form of proportional representation provides a power-sharing situation. It is undeniable that such a system is both democratic and indeed fair. ...read more.


acts as a forum for discussion on issues which involve two or more ministers in order to recommend a common position where necessary. This is a further example of increased representation. In conclusion it can be argued that the GFA achieved its primary goals, which included the protection of rights and interests among all sides of NI's communities and moreover paved the way for a return of devolution and representative government. Indeed in this sense the GFA empowered local politicians to make local decisions, instead of a secretary of state and their junior ministers, who as we have seen were usually British politicians and therefore detached from the issues of governing NI and its people. Despite these undeniable successes the 1st assembly was plagued with the politics of sectarianism and regularly became bogged down and eventually suspended on several occasions. Nevertheless despite these problems, the NI assembly and executive debated, passed and initiated a range of legislation directly concerned with NI. Indeed personally I believe these devolved institutions of government created on the whole a much more democratic system that that which existed under direct rule. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. The core argument was that Scottish governance should not be dependent on political control ...

    The majority voted for Home Rule, but due to a clause in the bill about a minimum percentage of turnout at the voting, an assembly was not created. Then in 1997 a referendum was held and Scotland voted for a devolved Scottish Parliament with limited tax varying powers.

  2. The Word 'Hacker' To the popular press, "hacker" means someone who breaks into ...

    Lately hackerliness seems rather frowned upon. To hackers the recent contraction in civil liberties seems especially ominous. That must also mystify outsiders. Why should we care especially about civil liberties? Why programmers, more than dentists or salesmen or landscapers? Let me put the case in terms a government official would appreciate.

  1. With reference to material you have studied discuss the major policy differences between the ...

    Because the SDLP are an unquestionably inclusive party they were prepared to participate in the BIC for the greater benefit of all those in NI. Finally where the question of accountability is concerned the SDLP are quite opposed to the idea of greater ministerial accountability within the assembly.

  2. Scottish devolution.

    post - the way in which British people vote for their MPs - would lead to a huge Labour majority in the parliament even if their true level of support were less than 50% of voters. Another fear was that the Conservatives, despite their support of around one in five

  1. Serfdom – Emancipation, etc

    both wanted to abolish serfdom but were unable to do so. They feared the opposition of the gentry, they suspected that all social bonds might be weakened, they did not know what to put in its place; above all, they suspected that they would have to give the gentry political

  2. Spain and Devolution

    At the same time autonomisation has not brought an end to violent Basque separatism. There are conflicts between centre and region about the extent of the regional powers - the Spanish state, for example, has repeatedly challenged Basque industrial policy in the European Court of Justice (Loyer, 1999).

  1. Has Spain’s system of Autonomous Communities created more problems than it has solved?

    First, as Gibbson writes, the autonomous regions, each has a legislative assembly elected by universal suffrage, a regional government headed by a president and a High Court of Justice4. Moreover, an "asymmetrical devolution" system came about because "regions have obtained self-governing capacities in different degrees and with different levels of responsibility for transferred services"5.

  2. With reference to any material you have studied explain the approach of the Democratic ...

    The DUP claim that Sinn Fein are simply the political wing of the IRA and therefore will not commit themselves to seating on the cabinet of NI with terrorists. The only condition, they claim, which will alter their position is if the IRA transparently and verifiably decommissions all their weapons and secondly, the IRA abandons its paramilitary path and disbands.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work