• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Can the condition of the Italian political system still be characterised by the phrases 'stable crisis' and 'eppur si muove' (but does it move) If so, why has the task of reforming it proved so difficult?

Extracts from this document...


Can the condition of the Italian political system still be characterised by the phrases 'stable crisis' and 'eppur si muove' (but does it move) If so, why has the task of reforming it proved so difficult? To foreign observers, and to countless Italians, Italian politics in the majority of the 20th century seems closer to a charade than to an orthodox conduct of public affairs. The first republic formed after Mussolini's fascist dictatorship had to deal with post-war anxieties such as economic problems although these weren't exclusive to Italy. It is fair to say that Italy in the political world is characterised by internal stability as there were 54 changes of government is as many years and a democracy system riddled with corruption scandals over a multitude of parties. However Italy is still a country that despite a 20-year dictatorship, and the end of world war two's economic devastation, still manages to struggle through to become one of the worlds top ten economies. The March 1994 election in Italy was seen by many observers as a new era in Italian political development. The demise of the first republic came about when Carlo Azeglio Ciampi's government resigned on 13th January 1994, followed by the dissolution of parliament three days later. The first republic was created in 1946 and was characterised by an electoral system based on a pure form of proportional representation with just ...read more.


However, although the Italians may have been justified in thinking that a fundamental change had taken place in their economic and political systems (with Italy now officially the 5th biggest global economy), cracks began to appear within the governing coalition. The Christian Democrats felt they had supported Craxi long enough and they wanted the role of premier to cede to a Christian Democrat. However, it soon became clear that Craxi had no intention of playing the supporting role. The Christian Democrats withdrew their support precipitating early elections in June 1987. Amintore Fanfari returned as caretaker Prime Minister seeming to indicate a reversion to the previous style of government. This shows that although one can characterise Italian politics as 'moving', it does not necessarily mean it will be moving forward. Italy is politically unique, not only because it had one of the only 'pure' Proportional representation systems in Europe but also because it has two organisations that need to be considered: The Mafia and the Catholic Church. The organised crime networks in Italy bear different labels. Camorra in Campania, N'drangheta in Calabria and most famously, Mafia in Sicily. Historians, anthropologists and criminologists debate its specific historical origins but most agree it is based on traditional patterns of patron-clientelism and that it burgeoned in response to the weaknesses of the administrative and judicial structures of the state. ...read more.


One can assess that this political instability left a problematical legacy to overcome when the process of reform came about. One must also take into account the exogenous factors exclusive to Italy, which made reform even trickier. The dominance of the Catholic Church, the corruption and 'Tangentopoli scandals' and the Mafia's extensive criminal activity all added to the complicated business of reforming Italy. 1 Fedele, Marcello taken from Leonardi, Robert, (1996), Italy: Politics and policy vol. 1, pg.88, Aldershot, Dartmouth. 2 Partridge, Hilary. (1993) Italian Politics today, pg. 70, Manchester: Manchester University Press 3 Furlong, Paul (1994) Modern Italy: Representation and reform, pg.60, London: Routledge. 4 Rhodes, P. et al,(1997) Developments in West European Politics,pg .95, London:Macmillan Press 5 Quartermaine, L. (1987), Italy Today: Patterns of life and politics, 2nd ed,pg.18 Exeter: Exeter University Press 6 Putman, Robert D., (1993) Civic traditions in Modern Italy pg. 46, Princeton University Press: New York. 7 Putman, Robert D., (1993) Civic traditions in Modern Italy pg. 46, Princeton University Press: New York. 8 Partridge, Hilary. (1993) Italian Politics today, pg. 139, Manchester: Manchester University Press 9 Spotts, Frederic & Wieser, Theodor (1986), Italy: A Difficult Democracy, pg.242, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 10 Spotts, Frederic & Wieser, Theodor (1986), Italy: A Difficult Democracy, pg.246, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 11 Spotts, Frederic & Wieser, Theodor (1986), Italy: A Difficult Democracy, pg.248, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Assess the impact of the Vikings on the political development of western Europe in ...

    the eldest son of the present ruler) but instead allowed a number of candidates, which led to court. The recognition that uncertainty over succession could lead to political disaster may have led to the acceptance that the direct male heir was the rightful ruler and thus altered the trend of royal inheritance.

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    because he or she is elected without it, or because he or she has too few votes to be elected, then the vote is transferred to the voter's second choice candidate, and so on. In this way, most of the votes help to elect a candidate and far fewer votes are wasted.

  1. The Negative Impact Of World War 1 On Italy: Weaknesses Of The Liberal State, ...

    Socialists were angered by Nitti's unwillingness to introduce reforms and conservatives were concerned that he did not crush socialist protest. Nitti was replaced by Giolitti as PPI support for the Liberals began to wane. However, his attempt at another trasformismo style government faired little better as the majority of socialists remained hostile to the Liberal system.

  2. Description of Citizenship Activity Describe how you participated in a school or community based ...

    the communication group could contact the RSPCA, and this helpfully resulted in a representative from the RSPCA to come in, and explain what happens at the RSPCA. Section Three: Communication List of supporting evidence List the support material and resources you used or produced as part of your work for the activity.

  1. citizenship data task

    Brainstorm ideas of what we were going to do on the day for the children -Sheena = 'teach the children some phrases and names in Swahili, make name cards for the children - Chandni = Perform short play about African animals for the kids - Sarah = teach children how

  2. Referendums. Although Referendums can provide clear decisive answers on difficult political issues, they also ...

    The results were clear with a 71% YES vote and a mere 28% NO VOTE. Turnout, at 81.1% was very high for a developed country where voting is not compulsory and it is estimated that approximately 147,000 people who do not normally vote in elections turned out to vote in the referendum, most of them in traditionally staunch unionist areas.

  1. Pakistan's Political and Economic Development

    Ayub Khan's 'decade of development' ended in 1968. He gave Pakistan 'relative political stability and a coherent public policy'.8 In this time he had managed to make Pakistan the only South Asian country that had a growth rate between 4-6%.

  2. To what extent can the failure of the Fascist Movement to challenge the existing ...

    There were also events Mosley had no control over and these considerably weakened the Fascist effort to challenge the British political system. One of the major events was the depression and if Mosley had launched his party at the right time it may well have seen him in power.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work