• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How effective is Parliament in Controlling the Executive?

Extracts from this document...


How effective is Parliament in Controlling the Executive? Within the parliamentary government currently in place in Britain, the executive should, in theory, be subordinate to the legislature, due to the fact that members of the executive are chosen from the majority party in the legislature. However, in practice, with electoral systems that tend to produce governments with strong majorities, it is usually the case that the executive dominates the legislature; the legislature limited to scrutinising the executive rather than controlling it, hence the phrase 'electoral dictatorship'. In scrutinising the government, the legislature employs a variety of methods including Question Time, Select Committees, Her Majesty's Opposition and The Controlling of Finance. Question Time is an opportunity for MP's within the House of Commons to ask oral questions of Cabinet Members, with written questions also being replied to. The theory of 'Question Time' is fundamentally important, i.e. questioning the government will hold them to account. However, in reality, the process lacks spontaneity. All ministers are given 48 hours notice of any questions they will be asked in the House of Commons, allowing them, or more likely their civil servants, to prepare a suitably vague answer. ...read more.


Committees run for the whole duration of Parliament, not just one session. This helps create continuity throughout the Commons. A further advantage is the relatively low level of absenteeism, suggesting a certain amount of respect for the committees. The Lords also has a number of Select Committees, like the House of Commons. However, unlike the Commons, Lords investigate committees do not mirror the work of particular government departments. Instead, they deal with broader issues and draw on the wide-ranging experience of members. In this way, the House of Lords system of committees complements the scrutiny of the executive carried out by the Commons. All committee finances are controlled by the House of Commons, not the Treasury, and investigations also tend to attract media attention, thus helping keep Government to account. An example of this was the media interest in the Foreign Affairs Committee 1998 investigation into arms to Sierra Leone. Select Committees can also gain access to valuable government information that would have otherwise remained undisclosed. However, committees hold no power to demand this information and any details the Government does not wish to release will remain undisclosed. ...read more.


The PAC reports to the House of Commons and all findings are publicised in the press, thus keeping the Government to account. However, the control of finance could be seen as a formality due to the vagueness of the government's estimates and the fact that the budgets of the security and intelligence industries are not available for scrutiny. As previously mentioned, the effectiveness of the legislature controlling the executive can be determined by the size of the Government's majority and party unity. An example of this was shown on 27th January 2004, during a vote over University tuition fees. The Labour Government, holding a majority of over 160, should have won the vote easily. However, due to a period of party disunity, Labour's majority was reduced to only 5, narrowly winning the vote. In conclusion, the effects of Question Time, Select Committees, the Opposition Party and the controlling of finance are minimal. Overall, Select Committees functioning marginally better than others. It could be concluded that the legislature has no control over the executive and its powers of scrutiny are limited. In fact, ignoring the recent Tuition fees votes, a large majority can insure a government has overall control of the legislature. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. How effective is Parliament in holding the Government to account?

    When Labour came into power, they reformed the House Of Commons, they modernised some things, they changed the times that the House sits, moved PM Question Time, closer to the lunch time news on television so more people would view it.

  2. How effective is Parliament? The effectiveness of Parliament can only be ascertained by evaluating ...

    The main purpose of standing committees is to consider possible amendments to legislation during its passage through the House of Commons. Although it appears to be an important role in reality party whips largely control the committees.

  1. How effective are M.P.'s at scrutinising the Government?

    Another reason why M.P.'s in Select committees do not check up effectively on the government is because they are wilting under the pressure of excessive workloads. With all the work they are landed with M.P.'s do not have the time in which to read all the papers relevant to the

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    of the 13 blocs or parties registered to run in the election. A party needed at least five percent of the vote to enter the Duma. The rational behind a semi-proportional system reflects an attempt to combine the positive elements of both the purely proportional and majoritarian systems: to have

  1. Free essay

    Outline the principal sources of authority available to US presidents. How similar is executive ...

    He can propose legislative measures and veto bills emerging from congress. In terms of the armed forces and foreign policy, the president in America is similar to that in France in the sense that he regards this as his reserved domain.

  2. Malta at the turn of the 19th Century.

    The idea of unconcerned (laissez-faire) towards the Maltese repeated itself very often in times when Malta passed from various kinds of situations. Every governor denied his responsibility towards the economic failures on our islands and openly rejected the protective policy that the Maltese enjoyed under the Knights.

  1. Legislators have three essential functions: representation, law-making and control of the executive. How does ...

    The former means that the Bundestag can try to ascertain government policy or, having ascertained it, to criticise that policy. It can do so by menas of the Question Time(Fragestunde) twice a week for ninety minutes during twenty-six weeks a year, when the Bundestag is in session.It can do so

  2. "Debates, Question Time, and Select Committees all give Parliament Teeth." Do you agree?

    However, some things that can help Parliament to scrutinise the Government through Question Time is that issues can be raised to the public, and these can be viewed by anyone in Hansard, similarly to Debates. Also, if the opposition has a strong leader they can be very effective during Question

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work