• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How effectively can the legislatures and the executive control each other's actions in the UK and the USA?

Extracts from this document...


Eddie Poole Politics essay 23 November 2001 How effectively can the legislatures and the executive control each other's actions in the UK and the USA? This question is asking me to analysis the relationship between the legislative and the executive in both America and Great Britain, and draw comparisons and conclusions as to their operations. Both the American and British constitutions have three branches, namely the executive, legislative and judiciary. These three branches work together in passing bills, making amendments and carrying out all other political tasks, however this does not mean that in both countries they work in exactly the same way. In terms of legislation, both parliament and congress have the power to pass bills. However parliament is not actually the origin of much legislation in Britain, as in it is mostly controlled through the executive. In fact the executive is so powerful when it comes to legislation that it has not failed to pass a bill since the Sunday trading bill 1986, and even in this case it was only held off for a year. ...read more.


Parliament is remarkably powerless in its consideration of public finance, even though it takes a lot of time considering annual finance bill. The executive in Britain has all the power when it comes to finance and taxations, it is even able to push controversial finance bills through parliament such as the poll tax (1988). In parliament expenditure is very rarly questioned. The public accounts committee, does scrutinise the spending programmes but only after they have been done. In terms of representation of interests, congress is hands down the more effective of the 2 houses. Congress is extremely open to lobbyists. Members rely heavily on interest groups for finance of election campaigns and Political support. The weakness of the Party system in congress, frees members from party commitment, allowing them to support external groups more easily. The fact that election comes once every two years for those in the House of representatives means that they are much more liable to take care of constituent interests rather than party interests. In parliament Lobbyist action is possible although it is a very uncommon occurrence. ...read more.


In America such a notion does not exist so consequently members of the government can be more frank about what is happening in their apartment. In general parliament, and in particular the government has always been known for its secretive nature. Select committees have fewer powers to see government documents, as the official secrets act often inhibits their actions. Committees in parliament are much lower profile then those in congress and are often led by members of the executive. Question time what was once seen as a direct scrutinisation of the government has now become largely government controlled. In looking at both congress and parliament it is blaintently obvious that the American legislative is much more effective in controlling the executive, than in Britain. Congress has many checks and balances between the legislative and the executive, and in comparison to Parliament is much more open to debate. In my opinion the executive alone controls Parliament. It is the executive that sets the agenda for the legislative and this must be abided by. Harsh whip systems and secrecy shadow the UK executive and in my opinion make it less effective than America. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. "The British Parliament is weak whereas the US Congress is powerful." Discuss.

    president's own party would not have any qualms about opposing him if they feel his plans to not coincide with their interests or the interests of those they represent.16 In addition, Congress, compared with Parliament, is far less likely to pass legislation requested by the head of government.

  2. Conflict Analysis: Angola

    However there is a lot more to deal with than individuals in government. More transparency in the government's finances is required, especially in how it spends the revenues gained from oil exports. In this sphere the oil companies have a considerable amount of leverage to help the situation, since they

  1. “The US Presidency is utterly a-typical and cannot be used as a model of ...

    No country that has sort to copy the US model has come anywhere close to replicating the checks and balances that the "Founding Fathers" wrote into the US Constitution. The reasons for this vary from country to country but include, the multiplicity of parties, the power of the military, the

  2. How far were Gandhi's actions after 1920 responsible for Indiagaining her independence in 1947?

    The only major factor in Gandhi's favour was that British elections after WWII in 1945 made it clear that the British public was no longer prepared to make sacrifices to maintain British supremacy in India, and thus moves towards independence were made.

  1. Gun control

    Aggression can overcome one's feelings and it would impulse the gang member to shoot the victims. Hunting should not be allowed because it is the same as using guns for recreational purposes. Hunting is a game in which hunters use guns to kill animals and sometimes hunting is dangerous because the gunner might accidentally shoot someone.

  2. The Uk policy making process.

    In particular, the guidance is careful to state: "DO NOT give the impression to a lobbyist that any particular advice, idea or information from their clients could or will be decisive in the decision-making process. Decisions are for Minister who will want to weigh up all the evidence and all the advice they receive before they judge the public interest."

  1. What is Politics UK politics revision notes

    AGAINST * Sectionalism and Selfishness * Only favour the well organised * Anti-Parliamentary democracy * Insider Groups may not work in public interest * Elitism * Re-enforces existing class and power structure * Pluralistic Stagnation * Too many groups, lots of contrasting aims, can immobilize the system * Social Disharmony

  2. Analyse the relationship between the executive wing of the UK government and the legislative ...

    including proposals for expenditure * Debate the major issues of the day Parliament has a maximum duration of five years. At any time up to the end of this period, a general election can be held for a new House of Commons.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work