• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Far Can 1997 Be Described As a “Critical Election?

Extracts from this document...


HOW FAR CAN 1997 BE DESCRIBED AS A "CRITICAL ELECTION?" The general election of 1997 was seen by many to be a fore-gone conclusion. The experts and the polls had been predicting a Labour victory for almost five years, ever since Black Wednesday in September 1992, and many felt election day itself, may just be a forgettable formality. What had not been expected, however, was one of the biggest Parliamentary majorities in recent times, and one of the biggest collapses of any government in history. Was it, therefore, a "critical election"? The whole terminology surrounding a critical election began in 1955, when V.O. Key identified the type of contest "in which the depth and intensity of electoral involvement are high, in which more or less profound readjustments occur in the relations of power within the community, and in which new and durable electoral groupings are formed." The key word here is "durable" because we need time to know whether a critical election has actually occurred. Subsequently, as Pippa Norris explains, "this idea was extended by Angus Campbell (1966) to classify elections into three categories, as 'maintaining', 'deviating' or 'critical' types." A "maintaining" election is one where very little alters politically, such as the 1992 general election. The issues that dominated the campaign would follow the old agenda, i.e. economic performance, or the welfare state. Similarly, the social alignments of the voters would be consistent with previous elections, such as the Conservative's predominance amongst professional middle classes. ...read more.


no longer the party of economic competence, whilst at the same time, Labour became a party conceived as being strong, united and capable of governing. The party also enjoyed huge membership, becoming the fastest growing political party in Europe and in addition, there was also a significant increase in the number of women MPs, combined with Labour's apparently successful attempt to make politics more modern and appealing to the voters. Penultimately, is the question of new social alignments - paramount for an election to be called "critical." Not surprisingly, therefore, 1997 achieved this criteria with huge Labour advances into traditionally Conservative areas of support. As John Curtice explains, "as in Scotland and Wales, so also across Great Britain as a whole, the Conservatives' principal problem is that their vote has become too geographically evenly spread." The South of England swung enigmatically towards Tony Blair, with almost 50% of the London vote, and even a 12% swing in the South East. the gender gap was breached, with 47% of women (traditionally more conservative) voting for Labour, the same statistic as men. The middle class professionals, Margaret Thatcher's key support-base, voted this time with Labour - 49% of C1s and 56% of C2s, although it can also be noted that the move towards Labour was almost the same in each social grade. Nonetheless, the changes were there for all to see, including incredibly rare moves such as some Tories refusing to vote (perhaps as much as 29% of supporters) ...read more.


Curtice notes that "they still managed to win 3% more of the vote than Labour did in 1983, when Michael Foot received a drubbing at the hands of Margaret Thatcher." However, this evidence all fades into near obscurity when faced with the size of the Labour victory, which is no doubt the result of a very "critical election." The political system of Britain has finally shattered. After 18 years of pushing against the walls, they finally gave way in 1997. It was a "critical election" to rank alongside, or even above, any in British history, setting the scene for a new era of politics. The statistics themselves almost tell the story - a 179 seat majority for Labour, only 165 seats for the previous government and a national average swing of almost 13%. The issues at stake had been new and different - a single currency? a Scottish Parliament? a minimum wage? The voting behaviour of Britain significantly altered - traditional Conservative supporters all turned their allegiance to Labour, such as southern voters, women and middle-class professionals. The party system was affected so much that it not only destroyed the Conservative dominance, but by-passed any suggestion of two-party dominance and started an era of Labour dominance. In years to come, I believe 1997 will be looked upon as the definition of how to produce a "critical election." ?? ?? ?? ?? ALAN RODEN THE 1997 GENERAL ELECTION ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Influences on Voting Behaviour

    The gender gap in voting has disappeared. Opinion Polls Opinion polls are one type of social survey and are used for various purposes. For example, Market research companies use opinion polls to find out consumer preferences e.g. regarding beer or soap powder. Opinion polls are used to find out our views on topical issues, such as the NHS or capital punishment.

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    This is far more important than that a government should be formed by only one political party. * It enables the voters to express opinions effectively. Voters can choose between candidates within parties, demonstrating support for different wings of the party.

  1. Scottish devolution.

    The UK Parliament also has power of the Post Office, telecommunications, and weights and measures. * Energy - Westminster still oversees such matters as offshore oil and gas exploration, pollution. Mining ownership and the nuclear industry are also under the jurisdiction of the Westminster parliament.

  2. The rise of Fascism in Italy was the result of a conservative reaction to ...

    In 1914 the war broke put and Italy's membership of the Triple Alliance apparently committed her to support Germany and Austria-Hungary, but the government in Rome declared the alliance invalid because of some claims against Austria-Hungary. However, the government increasingly took the view that Italy must intervene in the war

  1. In this essay I will explain the distinctive features of the Scottish political system, ...

    The main political division inside Scotland is between the Glasgow conurbation (Strathclyde), which contains about half the population and is overwhelmingly Labour, and the rest of the country where Labour is challenged by Scottish Nationalists, Liberals and Conservatives in more or less that order.

  2. Democracy's Biggest Fan Speaks.

    under a republic: Much of the Queen's income is spent on official duties, staff, and maintenance of state-owned properties. Obviously this sort of expenditure would continue under a republic because a President would have official duties as well, would need staff, and listed buildings should be cared for.

  1. The 1906 General Election saw a convincing Liberal landslide of 399 Liberal seats to ...

    saw the Tory opponents adopt this line of criticism. The 1904 report of the Interdepartmental Committee on Physical Deterioration merely served to underline this neglect on the part of the Tories. The country's plight, and the poor reflection this had on the party of power, first raised by the Boer War, was brought to the fore again by the

  2. What, other than the personal beliefs of Margaret Thatcher was there to Thatcherism?

    The prime example of Thatcher's personal beliefs becoming manifest in law can be found in Section 28 of the Local Government Act 1988, which states 'A local authority shall not * a) intentionally promote homosexuality or publish material with the intention of promoting homosexuality; * b)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work