• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What, if anything, is socialist about the Labour party?

Extracts from this document...


What, if anything, is socialist about the Labour party? Richard Wood Socialism is defined in the oxford English as a "political and economic theory of social organisation that advocates that community as a whole should own and control the means of production, distribution, and exchange." Philosophically this fitted the labour party and it's roots. When the labour party was founded in 1900 four constituent elements were instrumental in its make-up. Theses four elements were: the trade unions, the social democrat federation, the Fabians and the Independent labour party. They all needed socialism although only the Social Democrat Federation had a strong ideology. These groups produced a version of moderate evolutionary socialism with an idea of a fairer more just society. They claimed human nature was collectivist not individualist and could reach perfection. To reach this state intervention was needed to run industry- for the collective good. Labour, like all political parties, has changed and evolved over the years, it has most definitely moved away from it's roots and is by no means as socialist as it was. But is it still socialist at all? In order to find this out I will explore the context of old labour and socialism, the ideological debate, organisation and structural changes, changes in policy and policy-making, and Blair's 'New Labour' government. ...read more.


The modernisers have traditionally centred on the Parliamentary Labour party whilst the traditionalists have their strength in the extra-parliamentary elements- constituencies and other organisations (e.g. trade unions). The parliamentary wing of the party has always sought to be the alternative party to government and so has closely followed the wishes of the electorate and adapted policies. The modernisers have always seen clause IV and nationalisation as an electoral liability. The traditionalists did not want to loose sight of their roots however, nationalisation and public ownership were crucial ways to redress the class balance. During the Thatcher years socialists such as 'red' Ken Livingstone argued that labour should work locally to convince voters that socialism could work (e.g. Liverpool council). This proved an embarrassment to Labour leadership and the Conservatives. Power in the Labour party is divided between the Leader, the annual conference, constituencies and trade unions; therefore it is a federalist party. This reflects the debate as how much the extra-parliamentary wing should control the parliamentary wing has always been an important question in the Labour party. Much of the power in the Labour party was beyond the control of the part leadership because of this system and it is one of the reasons Tony Blair et al reformed the structure of the party. ...read more.


One of the reasons that the Conservatives are seen as such a weak opposition is because they agree with Labour on many things (e.g. war on Iraq). Tony Blair has changed the mechanism of leadership elections, altered the bloc vote and clause IV, introduced OMOV (one member one vote), consulted members through policy forums, and reduced dependency on trade union finance. This marks a move away from socialism and into 'democratisation' of the labour party. The party under Blair now has an acceptance of a so-called 'neo-liberal agenda'. This is shown most obviously in Blair's 'Third Way' policy, it is as Macmurray states communitarianism or ethical socialism. New labour emphasise community involvement instead of equality, a society midway between state provision and the free market. Left Conservatives favour these ideas just as much as they are by the right of the labour party. In today's labour party it is difficult to see exactly where the socialist policies lay but there are some there. The Third Way may not be traditionally socialist but there are socialist components, e.g. redistribution of wealth. At the same time there is absolutely no doubt that the labour party has moved to the right significantly Aneurin Bevan or Harold Laskii would hardly recognise the party, and traditional labour MP's such as Tony Benn often speak out against their own party. Glimmers of socialism can be seen in the labour party but the main agenda is most definitely neo-liberal. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Did the Labour Party show that it could govern Britain competently in the years ...

    But despite this, most historians claim that the second Labour Government's record on foreign affairs was highly successful, and showed a great deal of governmental competence. MacDonald was aware that naval rivalry had been harming Anglo-American relations for some time, and he himself took charge of this area of foreign policy.

  2. How and why did Federation occur?

    By 1909 half the reserves had been taken from the Aboriginals and given to pastoralists * Aboriginals were forced to move off the land and into the towns to become dependent on Europeans. * In Victoria and Queensland also set up reserves but could decide where Aboriginals could live.

  1. Outline the main ideological differences between new and old Labour.

    Tony Blair is consistently promising reform of prison systems and the whole criminal justice system. Since September 11 2001, Tony Blair has had to make policy on terrorist prevention.

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    They may prefer to have real influence with the MPs representing the whole of the city, rather than hold one MP responsible for their sector. The idea of working together, as a team with other representatives in the area is the norm for local government, where working together for a local ward, is often seen as advantageous.

  1. Churchill's Leadership

    Rationing was also another scheme introduced by the Government. Churchill also reinstated the War cabinet in order to fulfil a strong force to fight the war. This helped with the success of the Coalition Government. Churchill solemnly had the responsibility for military strategies and had the ability to make quick and realistic decisions, Such as the Dunkirk evacuation in 1941.

  2. How important was the contribution made by the socialist societies to the formation and ...

    He believed that everyone hated their jobs and that this was the reason for the increased amount of strikes and rebellions. He believed that all the proceeding events would lead to a mass revolution, after which people would reconstruct society and have a new 'meaning to life.

  1. Is New Labour a Conservative Party?

    Throughout the 1980s legislation was bought in which had a negative impact for the unions. Unions in Britain had priced many of their members out of jobs by demanding high wages for insufficient output. This had the effect of making British goods uncompetitive.

  2. How Profound Were The Changes Introduced by the Labour Governments?

    These social changes made by the labour governments between 1945-51 were substantially profound because they provided the public with cover against illness, unemployment and old age. So for instance if somebody was to be fired at work then they would receive a payment to cover this or if an injury

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work