• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why did the Provisional Government fail, and the Bolsheviks succeed, in 1917?

Extracts from this document...


Why did the Provisional Government fail, and the Bolsheviks succeed, in 1917? During 1917 the political system of Russia, and the political opinions of its public, began to change. The First World War was deeply taking its toll, with the casualties running into millions, and food shortages were reaching crisis levels across Russia. Presided over by the Provisional Government, who had little support and even less real power, the people of Russia became restless. In October, the animosity between Government and populace came to a head, and a revolution put Lenin's socialist Bolshevik party in power. This essay will show that, while the Bolshevik party was dedicated and driven in the values they believed in, it was only the seizing of opportunity, and a lot of luck, that they succeeded in taking power. After the abdication of the Tsar, it was decided that the Russian people should democratically elect a new Constituent Assembly. Until an election could be organised, the Provisional Government, made up partly of ex-Duma members, was placed in control of Russia. Large delays, however, resulted in the Provisional Government remaining in power for far longer than was originally planned, and by October their failings as a government had resulted in leaving them little real power, and almost no public support. ...read more.


The membership of the Bolsheviks rose, and again people lost faith in the Government in the face of its naivety. Another blunder was part of the Government's plan to tackle the escalating crime levels in Russian towns, by reorganising the police system. The existing system was disbanded, but a new structure never came into effect, and left many areas of Russia with effectively no organised police presence. Faced with an incompetent and weak government, increasing food and fuel shortages, and the lack of police or army presence, much of the country turned to desperate crime. In the country, peasants seized land as fast as they could, often looting and burning the large, stately mansions of landowners as they went. In the towns, where daily bread rations for workers had dropped from 675g to 110g in just seven months, the situation was reaching fever pitch. N Sukanov, living in Petrograd at the time, recalls that '...destruction of homes and shops...unauthorised arrests, seizures and beatings up were recorded every day.' Kerensky and his Provisional cabinet were also partly resented by the public for not having been elected into office, and many suspected that the Government members were trying to delay the Constituent Assembly elections for as long as possible, in order to retain their positions. ...read more.


By 27th October, after just four days, an all-Bolshevik Council of People's Commissars was in place, with Lenin as chairman. Although the Bolsheviks' public support, Lenin's appealing manifesto and strong leadership were important factors in the Bolshevik's success, their main advantage was Lenin's determination to seize the opportunity that he saw before him. The Bolshevik's had missed a number of opportunities in the months before, and October may well have been their last chance, if Lenin's predictions of the election's outcome was correct. It was the failings of the Provisional Government, rather than solely the appeal of the Bolsheviks, that provided this opportunity - had the Provisional Government not been so appalling in its leadership, the Constituent Assembly elections would have taken place as planned, and the Bolsheviks would have remained a marginal party in the Congress of Soviets. The Bolsheviks did successfully capitalise on the Government's waning power and support, and this should not be denied as an achievement. However, as has been shown, their success was due far more to opportunity and luck, and the failings of the Provisional Government, rather than the Bolshevik Party's power itself. In 1917 every person in Russia knew that change needed to happen quickly. The Bolsheviks were the result of that change because they saw the opportunity to capitalise on the situation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. How did the failure of the Provisional Government allow for the rise of the ...

    An example of this is shown in the attempt to remove all the social constraints such as lack of social justice and censorship of the press14. This spontaneous emergence of freedom diminished the ability of the government to control the population effectively15.

  2. Why Did Revolutions Break Out so Widely Across Europe in 1848 and Why Did ...

    Pomeraria in Prussia achieving 75% growth between 1800 and mid-century, triggering the threat of Malthusian hunger. Overall in Europe, two thirds of the population still worked on the land, therefore this was a group which could mobilise huge support should its troubles get out of hand and this was the

  1. Why were there two revolutions in 1917?

    As a result of the July Days, many Bolshevik leaders were imprisoned and Lenin was forced to flee to Finland in an attempt to resist arrest. Recent historians have seen Kerensky's treatment of the July Days as evidence that he was a "devious Politian with limited ability".

  2. What was Chartism and why did it fail

    Chartism was virtually an exclusively working-class movement and seemed reluctant to forge political friendships with the middle classes. Without alliances in government they could only be viewed from the outside and were often seen as a potential threat to public order and therefore overlooking their demands of the charter.

  1. Was the collapse of the provisional government inevitable

    This caused the people not be so trustful with the provisional government and doubt their ability to lead well, since the war was a big failure. When the provisional government wanted to stabilize it by broadening its social base and live on the moderate socialists for support, they refused and

  2. Was the Provisional Government fatally weakened from the first? Notes

    meetings in the Soviet, while all parties, apart from the Bolsheviks and monarchists, were represented in the Provisional Government during the early weeks. As the year wore on and the problems mounted, the Provisional Government moved increasingly to the right, and the Soviet increasingly to the left.

  1. Explain why the Bolsheviks were successful in October 1917.

    This made the Provisional Government more unpopular because food, fuel and goods prices were still shooting up, and were becoming rationed in the cities due to short supply. This was because the men working in industry, farming, and factories were off working in the war, and also because the trains

  2. To what extent was the Great War responsible for the collapse of the Provisional ...

    Kerensky was closely associated with the Provisional Government, in fact to many they were the same thing. Hence, his image was important to its success and survival. Moreover, the policies he promoted needed to be popular and effective. Kerensky was seen as 'man of the people', when he initially entered

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work