• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critique of Aquinas's cosmological argument - 3rd way(Contingency)

Extracts from this document...


Critique of Aquinas's cosmological argument - 3rd way (Contingency) Aquinas's 3rd way suggests that the world consists of contingent beings. As all contingent beings have a cause, namely another contingent being, there must have been a time when nothing existed, (unless contingent beings exist as a brute fact). Therefore, contingent beings could not have come into existence unless there is a necessary being which is non- contingent that caused them. Aquinas named this being God. The problem with Aquinas's view is that as physicians have suggested matter is eternal and therefore a necessary being is not required to cause contingent beings. The basis of Aquinas's argument depends on the fact that contingent beings require a cause which is in turn contingent. "Contingent beings require contingent causes", as stated by Stephen Evans in Philosophy Of Religion(55). This basis leads one to believe that an infinite series of contingent beings exists, but Aquinas claims this to be "illogical", thus the need for a necessary being. The objections occur due to the nature of contingency and the recently suggested, eternal nature of matter. ...read more.


Thus as Peter Cole suggests in Philosophy Of Religion(22), the cause of the universe is not about the metaphysical necessary being called God, it is about the nature of matter. In continuance to this, the matter itself could be defined as the necessary being as it is eternal and therefore could not have failed to exist. Thus "Matter would be a necessary being and would satisfy the arguments definition of God" ( Stephen Evans in Philosophy Of Religion(55). This would undermine Aquinas as he stated that the necessary being was separate from the universe. In essence, this view of matter as eternal means that if God exists, then far from being separate from the universe, God is the universe. Therefore, God would be defined as the matter of the universe which thus means that pantheism applies which undermines Aquinas. So if a belief in God is needed, then God is the universe, and not God was the cause of the universe as Aquinas argued. A further criticism of this argument, which also applies to Aquinas' 1st and 2nd ways, is that he never considered that the universe has always existed, and not finite as he suggested(i.e. ...read more.


The consequence of this principle is that, even if the universe has always existed and matter is eternal, there is no reason for its existence. Thus, Leibniz suggested that according to his principle the reason for the universe is God; God is the sufficient reason for the universe. As shown above, the matter of the universe and therefore the universe itself as a whole should have a finally adequate explanation. Kant points out in Philosophy of Religion p.190 (various authors), " the existence of a being whose essence included existence itself would not be self explanatory". As my argument has shown, this being is the matter the universe is comprised of (pantheism). Therefore, there is a clear contradiction between Kant's point and the fact of eternal matter. Because matter's essence does contain existence (a brute fact), it would mean that it would not be self-explanatory according to Kant. Thus the principle of sufficient reason has not been adhered to because the universe is not only without cause, it is without a reason for existence. This contradiction undermines the fact of eternal matter and to some extent invalidates it . However, as pointed out in Philosophy of Religion(selected readings) p. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. Assess Nietzsche's critique of religion.

    Nietzsche contradicts himself here. He says that Christianity denies life, but earlier he said that if believing in God gave a poor man some home and helped him live a better life, then he should carry on believing it. If you pursue pessimism far enough you might find optimism but

  2. T H E C O S M O L O G ...

    FINALLY ======== At the end of the day, the key issue is possibly whether the world as a brute fact (Bertrand Russell) is more self-explanatory than God as the cause of the Universe. The 'Big Bang' theory points to the idea that the universe had a beginning and that space

  1. Explain the Ontological argument.

    Nor is there a need for God to help us attain the highest goal of that law, since the law is no longer our objective duty (against Kant.) Kant's moral duty therefore can only work as long as we accept that Kant's world-wide view, which contains a 'priori' objective moral law.

  2. Man and the Universe

    With the discovery of the ever expanding universe, the theory of the Big Bang seemed more sensible than other existing theories, both scientific and mythodic. The Big Bang is the theory that the universe started from a tremendously dense and hot state exploding outwards to form the universe.

  1. One major difference between both Hindu and Muslims perception of God is the common ...

    conscience and from all this they conclude that there is a God. The light " God is the light of the heavens and the earth; his light may be compared to a niche in which there is a lamp; the lamp is in a crystal; the crystal is, as it

  2. What does St. Thomas Aquinas consider to be the nature and methodology of the ...

    "In revelation something pertaining to God is to man. (Schmaus.1968 Pp. 26-1). If so then divine revelation needs to be two way conversation as it has to involve an incarnation of God to reveal God in human terms. "In words and in images." (Schmaus.1968.Pp.26p2). These are recognised by the culture to which they are put and at the time they are put.

  1. Birth Of The Universe

    ripples wherever they hit, ripples that extend and run into and counterbalance each other, creating an interference pattern. The other part of the beam has been split off and is sent in a different direction, where it hits an object which is the focus of what you want to photograph.

  2. Outline Aquinas Cosmological argument

    However, atheists could argue that if life began from a series of natural causes then the purpose to life must be found in biology. St. Thomas Aquinas is considered by many to be the greatest scholastic theologian of the middle ages.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work